How to Decide who You should Work with

Nadine- Claire

The generalist vs. specialist debate stems from the shift in marketing trends over the last two decades. Early marketing roles were largely generalist by default, as marketers were expected to wear multiple hats. However, as technology advanced, the explosion of tools, platforms, and strategies created niches that required dedicated expertise, giving rise to specialists.

The choice to hire a generalist marketer or a specialist marketer often depends on your business’s stage, goals, and resources. To make the right call, it’s essential to understand what these roles entail and how they’ve evolved in the marketing space.

Here’s a practical guide to determine which marketer is right for your business:

1. Startups & Small Businesses: Go for Generalists. When budgets are tight, and the marketing team is small, a generalist can cover multiple bases and ensure no critical area is overlooked.
2. Scaling or Established Companies: Choose Specialists. With larger budgets and more ambitious goals, specialists can focus on fine-tuning specific marketing elements to maximize ROI.
3. Hybrid Teams: Many companies are now opting for hybrid models, blending the strategic oversight of generalists with the technical depth of specialists. For example, a generalist might oversee a campaign strategy, while specialists execute SEO, PPC, or design tasks.

The question isn’t whether a generalist is better than a specialist—it’s about understanding what your business needs at its current stage.

Generalists bring breadth and adaptability, while specialists deliver depth and precision. By defining your goals and constraints, you can make an informed decision and build a marketing team that supports your vision for growth.

Next week, we'll go over the disadvantages of both the generalist and specialist.

Which one are you looking for?

PS. Subscribe