How to Connect Operational Data in Financial Forecasting: Variances

Variance reports, fundamental tools in the SaaS world, are instrumental in achieving the objective of the details of how a business is running. We explore their significance from a SaaS standpoint.

Decoding the Value of Variance Reports?

A variance report shows budgeted metrics against actual performance. Its primary aim is to highlight discrepancies, allowing SaaS businesses to pivot or reinforce strategies as required.? We use a KPI dashboard to track important metrics and then we color-code the achievement vs plan and then see why things ended up different

• Utility of Variance Reports in SaaS: Variance reports provide an eagle-eyed view of a SaaS company's financial health. By identifying where the differences lie, they ensure that resources are allocated effectively to areas like customer acquisition or feature development.
• As SaaS Early Warning Systems: Variance reports can indicate potential churn rates, uneven MRR growth, or ballooning CAC, allowing timely interventions.
• Interpretation for SaaS: Addressing variances depends on their impact. It's crucial for SaaS companies to distinguish between minor growth hiccups and major customer acquisition challenges.
• Positive Vs. Negative Variances in SaaS: Positive variances might indicate successful feature adoption or low churn, while negative variances could signal issues in customer satisfaction or pricing models.

SaaS-centric Variance Types

• MRR (Monthly Recurring Revenue) Variance: Highlights discrepancies between projected monthly subscription revenues and actual figures.
• CAC (Customer Acquisition Cost) Variance: Reflects the difference between budgeted acquisition costs and actual expenses.

Reasons for a Higher CAC Than Expected

• Inefficient Marketing Campaigns: If marketing campaigns are not precisely targeted or do not resonate with the target audience, the company might end up spending more money without a corresponding rise in acquired customers. Digital market costs are higher these days so that can have an impact.
• Increasing Competition: In saturated markets, the cost of acquiring a customer typically goes up due to the increased spending required to differentiate one's offering from competitors.? Sometimes we do higher promotions for “conquest” events which can impact the CAC.?
• Lengthy Sales Cycle: In scenarios where the sales process is prolonged, especially in B2B SaaS, the costs associated with nurturing leads and converting them can escalate.
• High Churn Rate: If existing customers are leaving at a rapid pace, the company might ramp up its spending to replace them, driving up the average CAC.
• Over-reliance on Paid Channels: An excessive focus on paid advertising, without balancing it with organic growth strategies, can result in a high CAC.

• Sales or Marketing Team: A team that's still scaling the learning curve can lead to inefficiencies in the acquisition process.?

Impact on the Magic Number

The SaaS Magic Number is a metric that measures the efficiency of a SaaS company's growth. A SaaS magic number of 0.75 or greater is a sign that you should continue to invest in customer acquisition as the machine is working.? Anything less than 0.75 means that you should reevaluate your spending. A magic number of 1.0 or greater to be ideal. However, you need to be careful not to view this in isolation. The magic number is great at helping you determine how efficiently you can create new revenue, but it won’t show the whole picture. The best metric we use for a holistic view is Net Dollar Retention.

Change in Quarterly Revenue: This is the difference in revenue between two consecutive quarters.

Sales and Marketing Spend in Previous Quarter: This represents the investment in sales and marketing efforts in the prior quarter.

Multiplying by 4 annualizes the change in quarterly revenue, providing a yearly perspective.

A high CAC affects the magic number in the following ways:

• Reduced Efficiency Indication: If CAC is high, it means the company is spending more to acquire customers. Consequently, the magic number, which measures the return on sales and marketing spend, will be lower.
• Profitability Concerns: A lower magic number due to a high CAC might signal to investors and stakeholders that the company's growth isn't as efficient as it could be, potentially impacting future investment decisions.
• Scaling Concerns: As businesses scale, they expect economies of scale to reduce CAC. A persistently high CAC and a low magic number might indicate problems in scaling efficiently.

• Churn Rate Variance: Captures deviations in expected versus actual customer attrition.
• Feature Adoption Variance: Showcases disparities in anticipated user adoption rates of new features or tools.

Sample Variance Report for Q2 2023?

Optimizing Budget Variance

Manual data handling can be cumbersome, but with automation and analytics tools specific to the SaaS industry, teams can focus on actionable insights. The endgame is not just to identify disparities but to act on them, ensuring customer satisfaction, optimized MRR, and controlled CAC.

?