How Companies Can Interrupt Bias to Truly Create Inclusion
David Green ????
Co-Author of Excellence in People Analytics | People Analytics leader | Director, Insight222 & myHRfuture.com | Conference speaker | Host, Digital HR Leaders Podcast
Organisations have been hiring women and people of colour over and over again for decades and diversity has not increased. Why is that? It is because the culture within your organisation makes it impossible for them to thrive and they leave, over and over and over again.
This week on the Digital HR Leaders Podcast, I’m joined by Joan C. Williams, distinguished Professor of Law at the Hastings College of Law, at the University of California, and author of an eagerly anticipated new book, Bias Interrupted: Creating Inclusion for Real and for Good , which is set for publication on 16 November, 2021.
Described by the New York Times Magazine as having "something approaching rock star status" in her field, Joan has studied social inequality for 40 years and is dedicated to propagating an approach to diversity and inclusion that delivers real impact for the business and ensures real change is made.? Joan explained to me that Bias Interrupted has been: "Designed for people working in organisations, that have been working to create diversity and inclusion, many of them for over a decade, but sadly have seen very few results. The book is a roadmap to actually produce results."
According to the Washington Post, President Joe Biden carried a dog-eared copy of White Working Class , Joan's previous book, "everywhere scrawling notes on the pages and pulling out well-worn copies to share passages."As you'll hear, Joan has a refreshingly indomitable style. Here's an example from our conversation:
If a business had a problem with sales, they wouldn't address it by holding a series of deep, sincere, conversations about how much everybody values sales and declare national “celebrate sales month” and expect anything to change. That's just not how businesses do things, but unfortunately, a lot of Diversity and Inclusion efforts have been essentially that.
You can listen by clicking on the image below or by visiting the?podcast website here .?
The research shows that there is only one group in the workplace that can advocate for diversity without threatening career detriments. And that is white men.
Throughout this episode, Joan and I discuss:
- How to connect diversity and inclusion initiatives to business metrics that matter, with case studies from companies around the world: "The business case for diversity is important but the first thing to recognise is that even many companies that are convinced of the business case, flounder because it is a very complex organisational challenge to actually deliver on diversity goals. You have to be very concrete in the business case and show how diversity is crucial to your mission."
- The five patterns of bias (Prove-it-again, Tightrope, Tug-of-war, Racial stereotypes and Maternal wall biases) that repeatedly emerge across organisations and industries: "It is the same five patterns that emerge over and over, and over, and over, and over, again. In company after company and in industry after industry. The challenge for employers is that you have to interrupt all five."
You can't change your company culture by doing anything once.
- The concept of ‘bias interrupters’ – what they are and how to use them in everyday scenarios to reduce the impact of bias: "People have treated the problem of bias as something that can be trained with a one-shot training or a once-a-year training. You can't change your company culture by doing anything once."
- The ethical and legal challenges of measuring diversity data and why these challenges are not a good enough excuse for not doing the work
- Advice to Chief Diversity and Inclusion Officers on how they can get buy-in and deliver on their diversity, equity, and inclusion goals: "That is how to get buy-in, by figuring out what that metric is, and then gathering that data."
We like to think our organisations are meritocracies, but the data shows they are not
Enjoy - and please let me know in the comments section your thoughts and any questions after listening to the episode.
LISTEN TO THE PODCAST
To listen to the Podcast and read the transcript of my discussion with Joan, head over to myHRfuture by clicking on this link: Why Companies Need to Interrupt Bias to Truly Create Inclusion .?
WATCH THE VIDEOS
As well as the podcast, there will be a couple of videos available on the?myHRfuture YouTube channel ?highlighting highlighting two of the topics Joan and I cover in our conversation.?In the clip below, Joan explains why typical approaches to tackling bias in the workplace fall short :
领英推荐
THANK YOU
Thanks to Joan for sharing her immense knowledge and expertise with listeners. You can find out more about Joan and her work by visiting her website: joancwilliams.com and the Bias Interruptors website: www.biasinterrupters.org . You can also follow Joan on LinkedIn and on Twitter @JoanCWilliams .
I also recommend digging into the following resources by or co-authored by Joan to learn more about her work:
- Don’t Lose the Democratizing Effect of Remote Work (with Rachel M. Korn and Mikayla Boginsky, Harvard Business Review, Aug 2021)
- Why Corporate Diversity Programs Fail and What to do Instead (Ted, December 2020 - see below)
- How One Company Worked to Root Out Bias from Performance Reviews (with Denise Lewin Loyd, Mikayla Boginsky, and Frances Armas-Edwards, Harvard Business Review, April 2021)
- Update Your DE&I Playbook (with James D. White, Harvard Business Review, July 2020)
- How the Best Bosses Interrupt Bias on Their Teams (with Sky Mihaylo, Harvard Business Review, November 2019)
Thanks to Karen Burns, Vicky Holdsworth, Todd Tauber and the?Degreed ?team?for sponsoring Series 17 of the podcast, and also Ian Bailie, Manpreet Randhawa, Caroline Styr and the myHRfuture team for creating the Digital HR Leaders podcast and video series.?A special thank you also to Sally Ashworth for connecting us with Joan.
GET INVOLVED
If you enjoyed listening to this week's podcast episode, I'd be grateful if you could take the following steps:
- Please?subscribe to the Digital HR Leaders podcast and weekly newsletter ?to make sure you don’t miss an episode.
- Please take the time to?rate the show on iTunes . We rely on your feedback and support to make the podcast, so this is very helpful!
- Who would you like to see me interview in future episodes? Let me know in the comments below.
- Lastly, don’t forget to share on social media with your friends and colleagues, your support is always greatly appreciated!
__________________________________________________________________________
CATCH UP ON THE DIGITAL HR LEADERS PODCAST
If you haven't listened to all of the episodes of the Digital HR Leaders Podcast, you can catch up now by clicking on the links below.
- EP 81: Peter Manniche Riber - How does a great learning experience deliver value to the business?
- EP 80: Maarten van Beek -?How does ING create a culture of learning agility?
- EP 79: Ralf Buechsenschuss -?How to take a skills-based approach to workforce planning
- EP 78: Mika?l Wornoo -?How Do You Understand the Skills of Your Workforce?
- EP 77: Rob Cross -?How Can You Reduce Collaborative Overload?
- EP 76: Dave Ulrich, Jonathan Ferrar and David Green -?How to Build Excellence in People Analytics
- Bonus Episode: Kathleen Hogan -?Microsoft's Chief People Officer on Creating a Data Driven Culture in HR
- EP 75: Toon van der Veer -?How AB InBev uses Data, Analytics and AI in Talent Management
- EP 74: Joanne Kuipers -?How Tata Steel uses skills data for learning and workforce planning
- EP 73: Rick van Echtelt -?What are the benefits of measuring employee skills data?
- EP 72: Tertia Wiedenhof -?How Rabobank Has Created an Agile HR Function
- EP 71: Ron Friedman -?How Can You Reverse Engineer Success?
- EP 70: Steven Baert -?How is Novartis reimagining Performance Management?
- EP 69: Melissa Corwin -?How Does AT&T Link Business Transformation, Culture and Performance Management?
- EP 68: Greg Harris -?Why Employee Experience And Performance Management Are Two Sides Of The Same Coin
- EP 67: Jolen Anderson -?How BNY Mellon Supports Employee Wellbeing and Resilience
- EP 66: David Rock -?How neuroscience can help organisations drive meaningful change
- EP 65: Jimmy Zhang -?How Vertex has build a world-class people analytics function
- EP 64: Jignasha Grooms -?How to build a culture of trust and measure its impact
- EP 63: Ian White -?How to manage and visualise people data to create actionable insights
- EP 62: Isabel Naidoo -?How to design HR programs for impact and personalised experiences
- EP 61: Claude Silver -?Building a culture that drives business success and wellbeing
- Bonus Episode: Arianna Huffington & Donna Morris -?How Walmart is helping its associates achieve healthier habits
- EP 60: Alexis Saussinan -?Creating business impact with people data and technology
- EP 59: Karen Powell -?Getting started with a skills-based talent strategy
- EP 58: Ruslan Tobulatov -?What are the business benefits of a Talent Marketplace?
- EP 57: Jeroen Wels -?How Unilever has created a culture of internal talent mobility
- EP 56: Ina Gantcheva -?Why Are So Many Companies Building Talent Marketplaces?
- EP 55: Guru Sethupathy -?How Capital One delivers value at scale with People Analytics
- EP 54: Ethan Bernstein -?How Can HR Help Organisations Prepare for Hybrid Working?
- EP 53: Wagner Denuzzo -?How HR enables business transformation at Prudential Financial
- EP 52: Wenshan Xu -?How Singapore uses skills data to support lifelong learning
- EP 51: Dave Ulrich, Brigette McInnis-Day and Rupert Morrison -?The Future of HR: How can HR can be more value and business focused?
- BONUS EPISODE: David Green & Ian Bailie -?'All Eyes on HR' - HR Predictions for 2021
- EP 50: Renil Kumar -?How Wipro uses People Analytics to enable hyper-personalisation
- EP 49: Michael Arena -?How ONA can help understand the impact of virtual and hybrid working on innovation and wellbeing
- EP 48: Daniel West -?How to Democratise People Analytics to Drive Agile Decision Making
- EP 47: Melissa Harper -?How Bayer is redefining the workplace around Purpose, Innovation & Culture
- EP 46: Chin Yin Ong -?How people data can drive better business and employee outcomes
- EP 45: Vidya Krishnan -?Making learning a habit that matters at Ericsson
- EP 44: Simon Brown -?How Novartis promotes learning curiosity to drive business value
- EP 43: Kat Kennedy -?Improving Employee Experience through Learning, Skill Development & Mobility
- EP 42: Gianpiero Petriglieri -?How Do You Create a Learning Culture in the Workplace?
- EP 41: Lynda Gratton -?How can HR help shape the re-skilling and learning agenda?
- Bonus Episode: Diane Gherson -?How IBM is Reinventing HR with AI and People Analytics
- Summer Special #5: Sophie Rwegera Khadhraoui -?Building a People Analytics Function in a Humanitarian Organisation
- Summer Special #4: Dan Cable -?How to help people love what they do at work
- Summer Special #3: Torin Ellis -?What is HR's Role in Creating Diverse and Inclusive Organisations?
- Summer Special #2: Tomas Chamorro-Premuzic -?What is the role of leadership in times of crisis?
- Summer Special #1: Amy Edmondson -?How to create Psychological Safety at work
- EP 40: David Green -?How can People Analytics drive business value?
- EP 39: Jeremy Shapiro -?How People Analytics has progressed in the last ten years
- EP 38: Heather McGowan -?How Covid-19 is accelerating the Future of Work
- EP 37: Thomas Rasmussen -?How National Australia Bank has scaled People Analytics
- EP 36: Ravin Jesuthasan -?Six imperatives for HR in the Future of Work
- BONUS EPISODE: Amit Mohindra & Dawn Klinghoffer -?What is the future of People Analytics?
- EP 35: Peter Hinssen -?What is the role of HR in driving and enabling innovation?
- EP 34: Bruce Daisley -?What do business leaders want from HR?
- EP 33: Dirk Jonker -?Why People Analytics needs to behave like a start-up
- EP 32: Cole Nussbaumer Knaflic -?The role of storytelling in People Analytics and Data Visualisation
- EP 31: Piyush Mathur -?How Johnson & Johnson uses People Analytics to drive business outcomes
- BONUS EPISODE - Heather Whiteman, RJ Milnor & Ian Bailie (Live at PAFOW) -?How to develop the HR skills of the future
- EP 30: Katy Gray -?How Arup uses reward data to drive behavioural change
- EP 29: Uri Ort -?What is the future of talent assessment?
- EP 28: Zara Nanu -?The role of People Analytics in Gender Pay Analysis
- EP 27: Julia Shaw -?How can technology reduce bias in the workplace
- EP 26: Stela Lupushor -?How HR can be a Catalyst for Change
- BONUS EPISODE: Volker Jacobs -?How to scale Employee Experience
- EP 25: Julie Digby -?How HR Drives Transformation and Org Design at Mars
- EP 24: RJ Milnor -?How McKesson uses ONA to identify what drives high performance in sales
- EP 23: Rupert Morrison -?Rethinking Workforce Planning & Organisation Design
- EP 22: Dawn Klinghoffer -?The Evolution of People Analytics at Microsoft
- EP 21: John Boudreau -?Reinventing Jobs: The Future of Work and it's impact on HR
- EP 20: Tanuj Kapilashrami -?How Standard Chartered designed an exceptional Employee Experience
- EP 19: Anna Tavis:?What is Agile HR and how are companies adopting it?
- EP 18: Sarah Johnson:?How to use employee surveys to create strategic value
- EP 17: Leena Nair -?How HR drives business value at Unilever
- EP 16: Keith McNulty -?HR 3.0: more data driven, more agile and more business focused
- EP 15: Jason Corsello -?The Shift From HR Tech to Work Tech
- EP 14: Jill Larsen -?How does the CHRO successfully partner with the CEO
- EP 13: Frida Polli -?How AI and Behavioural Science can reduce bias in recruiting
- EP 12: Ian O'Keefe -?The Workforce Analytics journey at JP Morgan Chase
- EP 11: Dave Ulrich -?The role of HR in the Digital Age
- EP 10: Jordan Pettman -?How Nestlé uses People Analytics to measure Gender Pay Gap and Equity
- EP 9: Catalina Schveninger -?The Evolution of Corporate Learning at Vodafone
- EP 8: Richard Collins -?How is Automation, AI and Analytics changing recruiting?
- EP 7: Katarina Berg -?Spotify's CHRO on Leading HR in a digital world
- EP 6: Nick Holley -?How HR can become more business relevant ?
- EP 5: Eden Britt -?How to build a People Analytics team in a global organisation | The People Analytics journey at HSBC ?
- EP 4: Yvette Cameron -?How Blockchain will disrupt the Future of Work and HR Technology ?
- EP 3: Didier Elzinga -?How to Create a Culture First Company ?
- EP 2: Edward Houghton -?The Head of Research at the CIPD on Driving Business Performance with People Data ?
- EP 1: Sharon Doherty -?How to transform HR to be more digital and building a culture of diversity
__________________________________________________________________________
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
David is a globally respected author, speaker, conference chair, and executive consultant on people analytics, data-driven HR and the future of work.?As Managing Partner and Executive Director at?Insight222 , he has overall responsibility for the delivery of the Insight222 People Analytics Program, which supports the advancement of people analytics in over 70 global organisations.?Prior to co-founding Insight222 and taking up a board advisor role at?TrustSphere , David accumulated over 20 years experience in the human resources and people analytics fields, including as Global Director of People Analytics Solutions at IBM. As such, David has extensive experience in helping organisations increase value, impact and focus from the wise and ethical use of people analytics.?David also hosts the?Digital HR Leaders Podcast ?and is an instructor for Insight222's?myHRfuture Academy . His book, co-authored with Jonathan Ferrar,?Excellence in People Analytics: How to use Workforce Data to Create Business Value ?will be published in the summer of 2021.
SEE ME SPEAK AT THESE EVENTS
I'll be speaking about people analytics, the future of work at a number of upcoming events:
- 27 October -?People Analytics World LATAM ?| (Virtual)
People Analytics Consultant at Phoenix
3 年Sarah Horne Peter Meyler “Organisations have been hiring women and people of colour over and over again for decades and diversity has not increased. Why is that? It is because the culture within your organisation makes it impossible for them to thrive and they leave, over and over and over again.”
Cofounder of Lead In 30 ? Upgrade your leaders ? Human resources and leadership development
3 年Just added it to my podcast playlist. Thanks for the heads up, David. There's lots of noise about diversity, inclusion, and belonging. But so few companies are actually doing things that matter.
It amazed me as I read such an essential and must to adhere topic is that.
Global Human Resources Leader and Founder, Thrive HR Exchange
3 年As always, really appreciate your insights and sharing. It is very inspiring we look to build up team capabilities. Thank you David Green
Senior People Leader, Business Partner and HR/People consultant
3 年Gemma Lee Amy Milner Assoc. CIPD Sam Clegg Assoc. CIPD