How Can Enterprises Bounce Back After a Scandal?

It is not a matter of if but rather when your organization encounters such setbacks, and how you address these will ultimately dictate whether your enterprise will successfully recover and thrive or crumble and fail, following the path of numerous other entities. As concluded by Axios , customers are less forgiving of businesses with subpar product performance (39%), environmental pollution (38%), and unethical business conduct (35%).

?

Scandals are an inherent risk in any business landscape, possessing the capacity to emerge unpredictably, posing significant challenges in determining appropriate response measures and efficient damage control mechanisms.

?

“There is a continuous narrative of social responsibility embedded in the past few centuries of increasingly prevalent - and of late, increasingly shareholder-focused - capitalist enterprise.” – Geoffrey Jones for Harvard Magazine .

?

Often, the genesis of corporate scandals and fraudulent activities can be traced back to deficient governance structures and an absence of proper accountability mechanisms within the organization. More specifically, these factors encompass weak supervisory systems, a paucity of transparency, and a prevailing corporate culture that places financial gains above adherence to ethical standards. External influences such as economic volatility and the intensity of market competition can serve to exacerbate unethical practices and decision-making within a business entity.

?

So, in this context, what should businesses do amidst a scandal, and more specifically, how can board members effectively navigate these challenging circumstances?

Uncovering the Role of Board Members

Possibly just like human beings, corporations have their fair share of good and bad qualities. Independent directors are widely acknowledged as superior monitors and contributors to overall company success. Given the inherent fallibility of humans, it is nearly impossible to completely eradicate misconduct and corruption within any organization.

Board members’ leadership might shape an organizational culture that is adept at identifying misconduct promptly and addressing it assertively, thus pre-empting any potential crisis. As representatives of the company's stakeholders, they are likely to stay clear of, and prevent others from being tempted to, take risks that might damage the company's image, even if they are unaware of them on a daily basis.

?

ESG – the?New Reality for Businesses - Corporate boards must tackle key areas of interest for their stakeholders, as emphasized by the ten principles of the United Nations Global?Compact. These principles have a huge influence on the corporate sector, encouraging companies to implement sustainable and socially responsible practices in the areas of human rights, labour, environment, and anti-corruption. In the context of ESG?challenges, boards that recognize and respect the necessity of a thorough and inclusive approach to stakeholder engagement frequently find reciprocal commitment from their shareholders. Companies that make significant efforts towards sustainable practices are valued by these shareholders because of the growing awareness of the larger effect of enterprises.

?

Independence as a Core Value for Board Members - Under any circumstances, the architecture of corporate governance should be such that it guarantees the company's strategic direction, the efficient supervision of management by the board, and the board's accountability to both the company and its shareholders. Board members must act conscientiously, with full knowledge, integrity, and due diligence, ensuring their actions consistently align with the company's and its shareholders' best interests. In situations where the board's resolutions could affect different shareholder groups variably, it becomes essential for the board to guarantee fair treatment to all. The board is also expected to abide by high ethical standards, considering stakeholders' interests while making decisions.

?

Understanding the Roles & Responsibilities of Board Members - As guiding forces behind the success of any established enterprise, the board performs certain critical functions, such as reviewing and guiding the company's strategic direction, major plans of action, risk management policies, annual budgets, and business plans. This remit extends to the setting of performance goals, overseeing their execution, assessing corporate performance, and overseeing significant capital expenditures.

Assess the Problem

Scandal grounds and allegations can often present a challenging dynamic. False allegations are accusations that, upon rigorous scrutiny, are proven to be baseless or inaccurate. They often necessitate strong denial and strategic management to prevent reputational damage. On the contrary, valid allegations are those where the claimed misconduct is substantiated as true.

Finding the Cause - Addressing the root cause of the scandal and restoring consumer confidence in your organization are the paramount concerns to address. By embracing a strategic, well-informed approach, you can expedite your organization's recovery in the aftermath of a scandal, regardless of its nature or magnitude.

Dealing with False Allegations - In instances where an allegation is determined to be unfounded, the organization should issue a robust refutation. Overt denial should be disseminated when the company is inadvertently embroiled due to spillover from unrelated incidents. However, it is paramount to exercise discretion while deploying denials; when leveraged erroneously, particularly in instances where there has been no spillover, they could potentially backfire.

Responding to Valid Allegations - Conversely, when alleged misconduct is verified as accurate, its resolution becomes more complex and usually involves an amalgamation of several actions, such as elucidation, apology, reparation, and disciplinary measures. The exact combination of these elements largely hinges on the perceived level of deliberation associated with the misconduct. In other words, was the event intentional, negligent, or merely accidental?

Address the Problem

Identification & Empathy - The onus is on management to quickly identify the problem whenever they have reason to believe a scandal would affect the company. It's also important to show empathy for those who have been hurt and explain what measures your company takes to investigate the situation and prevent any additional damage.

Involving Marketing & Communication Experts - Once upper management has settled on a basic strategy for dealing with the crisis, they may seek the advice of marketing and communication experts to help strategize its execution. The next step is to determine which concerns need to be addressed, how in-depth they need to be addressed, who the best speaker is to communicate the message, and how it should be delivered.

Timing and Phases of Response?- Well, the answers to these crucial questions depend not only on the specifics of the incident but also on how consumers see the brand and its ability to help them succeed. Although a fast?response?is necessary, further specifics should be withheld until later phases of the response once the organization has had a chance to learn more about what happened. The company's representatives should limit their first remarks to updates on the investigation's progress, and executives should show they are taking measures to mitigate any damage as events develop.

Be Proactive & Transparent

Be Transparent - The short-term benefits of covering up an error aren't worth the high price of exposing one's dishonesty. Consequences are unavoidable but far less severe if your organization takes responsibility for its blunder rather than trying to cover it up.

Implement Corrective Measures - Prioritize repairing relationships with your clients. You can initiate this process by communicating the situation and the corrective measures you intend to implement to prevent recurrence. A sincere apology can be a powerful tool in the recovery process. Publicly express regret for the misconduct and its impact on stakeholders. Furthermore, demonstrate the willingness to make amends by providing appropriate compensation or restitution where applicable. Demonstrating empathy and taking concrete actions to address the consequences of the scandal can go a long way in rebuilding trust with affected parties.

Accepting the Consequences - If required, consider offering compensation to victims implicated in the scandal to demonstrate sincerity. Accept the consequences of the scandal with remorse and responsibility, whether they be fines, sanctions, or other legal actions. You might also consider offering customers special incentives, such as discounts, gifts, or promotions, to encourage them to remain loyal to your brand.

Lay Out the Path Ahead - Clarify the overarching business plans to prevent a recurrence of the incident, and keep in mind that the acceptance of punishment, along with compensation, and sincere remorse can have a greater impact on those affected.

Strengthen Ethical Culture and Governance - A successful rebound requires a company-wide commitment to ethical values and corporate governance. This entails not only revising and enforcing strict codes of conduct but also fostering a culture of integrity and ethical decision-making from the top down. Leaders should lead by example, reinforcing the importance of ethics in all aspects of business operations. Regular training and awareness programs can help embed ethical values into the organization's DNA.

Enhance Risk Management - Robust risk management practices are instrumental in preventing and mitigating potential future scandals. Enterprises should conduct a thorough risk assessment, identifying areas of vulnerability, and implement measures to address them. This proactive approach demonstrates the company's commitment to avoiding similar incidents in the future, thus reassuring stakeholders of their renewed focus on ethical governance.

Evaluate the Shortcomings & Prevent Future Occurrences

Even though, at first sight, they might only bring about negative consequences, scandals often expose deficiencies in corporate governance and leadership. Forward-thinking leaders can leverage these instances as opportunities for rigorous examination and potential rejuvenation of your organization's personnel, culture, leadership, business models, practices, partnerships, and even systems, controls, and structures.

Tolerating inappropriate conduct increases the likelihood of scandals, and failing to consider the potential societal consequences of a business' actions may put the whole business at risk. A company will not survive if its values are at odds with society's ideals that permit it to function.

As such, the typical board's perspective is beginning to widen. However, directors still need to keep an eye on high level aspects, including business strategy, risk management, financial controls, and succession preparation. It's crucial not to neglect any early warning signs as unaddressed, they could precipitate a devastating crisis.

?

Bottom Line

Sometimes?board members who, despite their best intentions, fail to ask the appropriate questions or have the confidence to say "no" to questionable business models, practices, or partners, hence allowing their enterprises to stray far from the ethical path – which might culminate with detrimental scandals.

?

While scandals are undesirable, they can function as crucibles, putting corporate governance and leadership to the test. As board directors expand their perspective, keeping an eye on strategy, risk, financial controls, and succession planning is crucial.

If you haven't already, I invite you to subscribe to the Ethical Edge newsletter and stay informed about the latest insights, trends and discussions on ethical business practices.

Through this newsletter, I hope to raise awareness about ethical governance and inspire action towards creating a better, more just world for all. Thank you for reading and joining me on this meaningful journey!

If you found this information valuable:

Feel free to SHARE it with your network.

Leave a comment to engage in a meaningful conversation.

You can also follow or connect with me .?

?

?