How Artificial Intelligence Will Help Settle Business and Legal Disputes

The world is experiencing a dramatic transformation thanks to the rapid advancements in artificial intelligence (AI). One area where I believe AI is going to make a significant impact is in the resolution of civil, business and criminal legal disputes. With its ability to instantly analyze vast amounts of data and draw insights from countless prior cases, AI has the potential to revolutionize the way we approach conflict and dispute resolution, saving time, money, and resources for all parties involved.

Artificial intelligence is poised to transform dispute resolution in business and law, promising rapid, data-driven settlements that save time, reduce costs, and level the playing field.

Civil Disputes

Traditionally, when businesses or individuals find themselves embroiled in a legal dispute, the process of reaching a settlement can be long, arduous, and expensive. Negotiations often involve multiple rounds of back-and-forth between lawyers, each advocating for their client's best interests. Even when the parties agree to mediation, the process can still take weeks or months, as the mediator works to find common ground and broker a mutually acceptable agreement.

However, with the power of AI, this lengthy process could soon become a thing of the past. By tapping into billions of data points consisting of prior settlements and verdicts from local, national, and global databases and cases, AI algorithms will be able to analyze similar fact patterns, issues, documents, and locality-based values and other relevant factors in a matter of seconds. This wealth of information, combined with the AI's ability to consider biases, leverage points, business trends, and even the personalities of the parties involved, will enable it to generate fair and comprehensive settlement proposals or, with the parties' consent, even provide instant final binding outcomes.

Traditional negotiation and mediation approaches rely heavily on the skills and experience of the mediator to guide the parties towards a resolution. While effective, these methods are inherently slow and often influenced by human factors such as emotions, biases, and limited knowledge of the facts, evidence and prior cases. In contrast, AI-powered dispute resolution offers a lightning-fast, data-driven approach that eliminates these limitations and provides a more consistent and objective outcome.

Imagine a scenario where two businesses are locked in a dispute over a contract breach. Instead of spending months in negotiations or mediation, or years of litigation, the parties or their counsel could simply input the relevant information into an AI-powered dispute resolution platform. The AI would then analyze the case, comparing it to millions of similar cases, and within seconds, propose a settlement or even make a binding decision that takes into account all the relevant factors and variables. This not only saves time but also ensures that the proposed or binding solution is based on objective data rather than subjective opinions or biases.

Moreover, the cost and time savings associated with AI dispute resolution cannot be overstated. Litigation is notoriously expensive, with legal fees, litigation and court costs, and expert witness expenses quickly adding up. Even alternative dispute resolution methods like arbitration and mediation can be costly and time-consuming. By leveraging AI to settle disputes in a matter of seconds, businesses and individuals can save substantial amounts of money and time, allowing them to focus on their core operations and move forward with their lives.

Another significant advantage of AI dispute resolution is its potential to level the playing field between parties with uneven resources or bargaining power. In traditional settlement venues, the party with deeper pockets or a stronger reputation often has an advantage, as they can afford to prolong the process or hire more experienced legal representation. However, with AI, the emphasis is placed on the facts and data of the case, rather than the relative strength of the parties involved. This ensures that the settlement proposal is fair and equitable, regardless of the parties' resources or influence.

Criminal Matters

To effectively apply AI in the criminal justice context, it is essential to develop comprehensive and unbiased datasets and language models. These models must be based solely on objective facts and relevant legal precedents, eliminating any form of prejudice or discrimination. By doing so, AI-generated recommendations for plea bargains or sentencing can be fair, consistent, and legally sound.

One of the primary advantages of an AI-assisted plea bargaining system is the potential for faster case resolution. Defendants who opt into this system could benefit from reduced time spent in pre-trial detention and lower associated costs. Additionally, AI could help identify cases that are suitable for plea bargains, allowing prosecutors to focus their resources on more complex or contentious matters. This increased efficiency could alleviate the overburdened criminal justice system, ensuring that justice is served in a timely manner.

However, it is vital to emphasize that participation in an AI-assisted plea bargaining system must be entirely voluntary. Defendants must retain their constitutional right to a trial by jury if they so choose, and this right should not be compromised or undermined by the introduction of AI. It is crucial that defendants are fully informed about the implications of opting into an AI-assisted system and that they have access to legal counsel to guide their decision-making process.

From the prosecution's perspective, AI could offer significant advantages in terms of case management and resource allocation. By identifying cases that are likely to result in a plea bargain, prosecutors can prioritize their efforts and ensure that more serious or complex cases receive the attention they require. Additionally, AI could assist in determining appropriate sentencing recommendations based on historical data and legal precedents, promoting consistency and fairness across cases.

Safeguards must be put in place to prevent any potential misuse or abuse of the system, and regular audits should be conducted to ensure that the AI models remain unbiased and accurate. It is also essential to maintain transparency in the decision-making process, allowing defendants and their legal counsel to understand how AI-generated recommendations and final dispositions were reached.

The integration of artificial intelligence into the civil dispute resolution process is not just a possibility, but an inevitability. As AI continues to evolve and refine its capabilities, we can expect to see a rapid shift towards AI-powered settlement solutions that offer unparalleled speed, efficiency, and fairness.

In the criminal justice system, balancing the benefits of efficiency with the paramount importance of protecting defendants' rights and ensuring a fair and just outcome is a delicate task. As AI advances, it is crucial that policymakers, legal professionals, and technologists work together to develop guidelines and regulations that prioritize fairness, transparency, and the preservation of constitutional rights.

By embracing AI dispute resolution technologies in the civil and criminal spaces, businesses, individuals and governmental entities can save time, money, and resources, while also benefiting from greater convenience, privacy, flexibility, consistency, and control over the outcome of civil and criminal matters.

Mitch Jackson | Lawyer and Private Mediator

?? 30+ years of legal experience.

?? Available for interviews, keynotes, and commentary on AI, Web3, and Metaverse/Spatial Computing (law/biz).

??? Don't miss my next post. Please ring the bell at the top of my LinkedIn profile.

??? If someone forwarded this issue, you can get your free copy of my weekly “AI, Web3 and Metaverse Update” newsletter.