Hot Topic Highlight - Yields, Risk, Rent and Value

Building a better you 

Property Elite’s sole aim is to build better property professionals - supporting your career every step of the way, whether you are completing a RICS accredited degree course, your RICS APC/AssocRICS or simply seeking engaging CPD. 

This week, we have partnered with Maria Wiedner CFA MPhil (Cantab) of Cambridge Finance to talk about the relationship between yields, risk, rents and price/value in property. You can find out more about Maria's journey in property and finance here.

If you are an RICS APC candidate, be sure to check out our RICS APC support services, including RICS APC question packs, revision quizzes and mock interviews. 

You can read what some of our happy 2017 candidates had to say here.

Also make sure you check our our APC preparation blog if you are sitting this Spring!

If you have any concerns, contact us on 07491 252 025 or email [email protected] - we offer every candidate a free & friendly 30 minute RICS APC consultation.

Why is this important?

Yields have many different meanings in finance – yield to maturity, running yield, dividend yield, interest yield – and in property finance, the case is very similar. 

We can talk about initial yield, equivalent yield, reversionary yield etc. It is, therefore, really easy to get lost in a “yield” conversation, unless you stop the other person and ask: “which yield?!”.

If you are emotionally intelligent enough (and I bet you are if you are reading this!), you won’t do this so blatantly. So, let’s break down this “yield” conversation first to ascertain the relationship between yields, risk etc.

First, it is safe to assume that “yield” refers to initial yield (at least most of the time I asked the “which yield” question, that was the answer). Otherwise, people would have said “equivalent yield”, “reversionary yield” and so on.

Second, we need to know that the initial yield is the year one return, in other words, the income in the form of passing rent as a percentage of the price you paid or the estimated market value. 

In a mathematical form...

Initial Yield = Passing Rent / Estimated Value or Price

Very simplistically, if an office building is being sold for ￡5 million and the passing rent is ￡500,000 p.a., the initial yield is ￡500,000 / 5,000,000 or 10%.

Now you can ask yourself: is 10% too high? Too low? Is ￡5 million too much for this property? Or should it be less? Or more?

It will depend on the property, of course. But mainly, on location, tenant and lease length. 

If this property was located in the London’s West End, you can say that it is a bargain, since office yields are on average 3.5% in Mayfair (according to Colliers). That means that if the property had a rent income of ￡500,000, you’d expect to pay around ￡14 million (500k / 3.5% = 14 m) instead of ￡5 million.

West End is considered a low-risk sub-market because it has strong demand (everyone wants to be there) and limited supply (you can only build new stock if you demolish something first).

Higher demand = higher rent

Now, let us imagine you have one building (size, specification) and you can put it in two places with similar amenities (close to the tube station, Starbucks nearby etc). However, one such place is in the West End and other, the City of London. Where do you think you will get more rent from? 

You will be right if you said West End. Why? Because the relationship demand psf vs supply psf is greater in the West End than in the City, so rents are higher in the former.

Let’s look at the Colliers (2018) rents map.

London West End Office Rent is ￡118 psf p.a., whereas London City Office Rent is ￡70 psf p.a.

As rent is a function of supply and demand, from the prices alone, we can infer that West End office property has a greater relative demand than City office property. Growth, in both markets, is similar and negative (-6% to -7%); at this moment, they cancel each other out.

If we say that the demand is stronger for the West End, we will immediately think that this market is less risky, because the likelihood of finding tenants is higher than in the City.

Also, if the rent drops by ￡5 in the West End, this would mean a decline of around 4.3% (￡5/￡118) in the rent, whereas a rent drop by ￡5 in the City would mean a decline of around 7.1% (￡5/￡70). Thus, the impact of a ￡5 rent drop in the City is greater than in the West End. Now, how does risk translate into property price?

Higher risk, higher yield?

Normally (in financial theory, we call it ‘rationally’), you require a higher return for a riskier investment. Translating the risk into price, you say that you will pay less for the City office property on a per square foot basis because a) you will receive less rent; and b) it is riskier.

Thus, higher risk, higher yield, lower price

In fact, Colliers London Offices Snapshot Report as of January 2018 (below), gives an average of prime yield in West End (Mayfair / St James) of 3.5%, whereas City (core) is 4.0%. It means that West End has lower yield because it has less risk (more demand, less supply, same growth) than the City. Let’s look at the Colliers (2018) yield table.

Now back to the equation, you can find the Price or Value per square foot as:

City value per square foot (Value City)

4% = 70/Value City

Value City= 70 / 4% = ￡1,750 psf

West End value per square foot (Value West End)

3.5% = 118/Value West End

Value West End = 70 / 3.5% = ￡3,371 psf

Conclusion

• Higher rents mean a market where demand is high comparatively to other similar sub-markets (we compared West End and the City of London)
• Higher demand means less risk
• Less risk means lower yields
• Lower yields mean higher prices

How can I prepare effectively for my final assessment submission and interview this Spring?

• Sign up for a complimentary copy of our Ebook Guide to the APC (UK and MENA editions)/AssocRICS or our new APC Hot Topic Guide for Spring 2018 - full of even more helpful advice and tips to pass your RICS APC or AssocRICS with flying colours first time
• Sign up for our bespoke support services, such as our final assessment review & feedback service, RICS APC question packs (c. 1,000 questions/30 pages based on your submission), e-mock interviews and revision quizzes. Don't forget that we offer some great value discounted packages if you purchase more than one support service
• If you're confused about anything, just contact us on 07491 252 025 / [email protected]. We offer all candidates a free & friendly 30 minute RICS APC consultation

You can read what some of our happy candidates had to say here.

Stay tuned for our next blog post to help build a better you

N.b. nothing in this article constitutes legal or financial advice.