Hot Take Tuesday: Should I Stay or Should I Go?

Welcome to Hot Take Tuesday, where your endearing host, Cassie Findley, gives you the hot takes on roofing materials, brands, and manufacturers every week. She works to provide her dear readers with a quick tell-all on the current roofing trends, types, and technologies, without all of that cold & clinical copy. So, sit back, relax, and enjoy!

So, your roof needs replacing. You’ve finally decided to take the plunge, and now you’re faced with a thought that might not have crossed your mind initially: should I stay or should I go? The Clash was definitely on to something!

This is an important question, and like most things, there sadly isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer. Let’s break it down so you can decide what’s best for your situation.

What Happens During a Roof Replacement?

First, it's helpful to understand what exactly happens during a roof replacement. Roofers will strip away your old shingles or materials, assess the underlayment, and make any necessary repairs before installing the new roofing materials. This is often a loud, messy, and sometimes lengthy process, depending on the size of your home and the extent of the repairs needed.

Most roof replacements take a couple of days, though larger or more complex roofs may require more time. And if the weather doesn’t cooperate? You could see some delays.

Reasons to Stay Home During a Roof Replacement

1. Oversight and Communication

When you’re on-site, you can immediately address any questions or concerns the roofing crew might have. While most professional roofers are experienced and know exactly what to do, being available can help avoid any miscommunication or clarify your preferences. You can also monitor the progress in real time and make sure everything’s moving according to plan.

Additionally, if you have any last-minute concerns about specific areas of your roof, it’s much easier to communicate them in person than trying to explain over the phone.

2. In Case of Emergencies

While roof replacements are routine for the professionals, unexpected situations can occur. Being home allows you to respond quickly in case of an emergency, whether it’s related to your home or the work being done. For example, if water starts to seep in unexpectedly during the job, you’ll be right there to manage the situation, communicate with the contractors, and protect your belongings.

3. Protecting Your Property

Roof replacements generate a lot of debris. Nails, shingles, and other materials can fall off the roof or be scattered around your yard. Some homeowners prefer to stay home so they can ensure their outdoor furniture, plants, or vehicles are protected or moved out of the way when needed.

If you have pets or children, being home also allows you to keep a closer eye on them and ensure they’re staying safe and out of harm’s way.

Reasons to Leave During a Roof Replacement

1. Noise and Disruption

Roof replacements are noisy, and there’s no way around it. Between the constant hammering, sawing, and tearing off old materials, the noise can be a significant disruption. If you work from home, need quiet for meetings, or simply don’t want the headache of hearing the noise all day, it might be best to leave during the process.

The disruption isn’t just limited to noise. Roofers will be coming and going, and your yard may be filled with ladders, tarps, and materials. If having a lot of people moving around your home makes you feel uneasy or stressed, that’s another reason to consider staying elsewhere for a few days.

2. Safety Concerns

While roofing crews take precautions to ensure the safety of both their team and homeowners, it’s still a construction zone. If you have small children or pets, keeping them away from the noise, debris, and work area can be tricky. Even adults need to be cautious around areas where roofing materials and tools are being used.

Leaving your home during a roof replacement can minimize the chance of accidental injury and allow the roofing crew to work more efficiently without worrying about people getting in the way.

3. Comfort and Convenience

Let’s be honest: living through any home improvement project can be a hassle. If you can temporarily relocate to a friend or family member’s house, or even enjoy a little staycation at a local hotel, it might be worth it for the comfort and peace of mind. You won’t have to deal with the mess, noise, or general inconvenience of having workers around your home.

Final Thoughts: Should You Stay or Should You Go?

Ultimately, whether or not you stay home during a roof replacement comes down to your personal preferences and lifestyle. If you don’t mind the noise and want to stay on top of the project, staying home makes sense. But if you value your peace and quiet, it’s probably best to pack up and spend a few days elsewhere.

No matter what you decide, make sure to communicate your plans with the roofing crew. If you’re leaving, ensure they have all the necessary contact information to reach you in case of emergencies. And if you’re staying, give them space to do their job while keeping an eye on the process from a safe distance.

At the end of the day, the goal is a brand-new roof over your head, and a little noise and inconvenience are a small price to pay for that peace of mind!