Historical parallels of Trump second Term VS 1930s Germany

There are some historical parallels between Trump's executive orders and Adolf Hitler's early actions when he rose to power in the 1930s, but with important differences due to the democratic system in the U.S. vs. Nazi Germany’s totalitarian structure.

Below is a side-by-side comparison of key actions taken by Trump (2025) and Hitler (1933-1934) in the early stages of their leadership.


1. Federal Workforce Purge vs. Hitler's "Gleichschaltung" (Coordination of Government)

?? Trump’s Plan (2025)

  • Through Project 2025, Trump and his allies plan to fire tens of thousands of federal employees and replace them with loyalists.
  • Would dismantle the "Deep State" (i.e., neutral bureaucrats) and centralize control over agencies like the DOJ, FBI, and IRS.

?? Hitler’s Plan (1933-34)

  • Gleichschaltung ("Coordination"): Hitler purged government institutions, replacing officials with Nazi loyalists.
  • Civil Service Law (1933): Forced Jewish and non-Nazi officials out of government jobs.
  • Destroyed checks and balances, making government agencies tools of the Nazi Party.

?? Similarity? Both involve removing independent government workers and replacing them with loyalists, weakening institutional resistance. However, Trump’s plan is being done within a democratic framework, while Hitler ruled by decree.


2. Immigration & Citizenship Laws vs. Nazi Race Laws

?? Trump’s Plan (2025)

  • End birthright citizenship, stripping millions of people of legal status.
  • Mass deportations of undocumented immigrants and those deemed "undesirable."

?? Hitler’s Actions (1935)

  • Nuremberg Laws stripped German Jews of citizenship.
  • Defined who could and couldn't be a citizen based on race.
  • Marked the beginning of systematic persecution.

?? Similarity? Both policies redefine citizenship to exclude certain groups, although Hitler’s was based on race, while Trump’s is based on immigration status. Legal challenges in the U.S. system make full enforcement unlikely.


3. Expanding Fossil Fuels vs. Nazi Autarky (Economic Self-Sufficiency)

?? Trump’s Plan (2025)

  • Deregulating fossil fuel industries to boost American energy independence and cut environmental protections.
  • Rejecting climate agreements and prioritizing coal, oil, and gas over renewables.

?? Hitler’s Plan (1930s)

  • Autarky (Self-Sufficiency): Pushed for economic independence from foreign imports.
  • Focused on rearmament and energy production (e.g., synthetic fuel programs) to prepare for war.

?? Similarity? Both involve economic nationalism and rejecting global cooperation, but Hitler’s policies were designed for military expansion, while Trump’s are framed as energy independence.


4. Anti-LGBTQ+ Policies vs. Persecution of LGBTQ+ People

?? Trump’s Plan (2025)

  • Banning transgender people from the military, sports, and legal recognition.
  • Rolling back federal LGBTQ+ protections.

?? Hitler’s Actions (1933-1945)

  • Targeted LGBTQ+ people as "degenerates" under Nazi racial policies.
  • Shut down LGBTQ+ organizations, sent gay men to concentration camps, and conducted forced sterilizations.

?? Similarity? Both target LGBTQ+ communities, but Hitler’s policies were violent and genocidal, while Trump’s are focused on legal discrimination and exclusion.


5. Consolidating Power Over the Military & Police

?? Trump’s Plan (2025)

  • Wants to federalize the National Guard and expand executive control over law enforcement.
  • Purging military leaders who oppose his policies.
  • Encouraging police crackdowns on protests and riots.

?? Hitler’s Actions (1934)

  • Night of the Long Knives (1934): Purged military and political rivals.
  • SS & Gestapo expansion: Gave Nazi-controlled police unchecked power.
  • Used "law and order" rhetoric to justify cracking down on dissent.

?? Similarity? Both involve expanding executive power over military and police, but Hitler abolished democracy entirely, while Trump still operates within the U.S. legal system.


?? Key Differences Between Trump & Hitler’s Rise to Power

While there are some parallels, major differences prevent a direct comparison:

  1. The U.S. Has Democratic Guardrails
  2. Trump Faces Strong Opposition
  3. The U.S. Has a Two-Party System


?? Conclusion: Should We Be Worried?

?? Trump is not Hitler, but some of his strategies mirror early Nazi tactics—especially when it comes to consolidating power, removing government opposition, and targeting minority groups.

?? The biggest danger? If democratic institutions fail to hold him accountable. If courts or Congress allow Trump to:

  • Fire federal employees at will
  • Strip people of citizenship
  • Use the military against domestic opposition

Then the risk of authoritarianism increases dramatically.

Your reference to people being fired and the nazi purge dont come close. Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, Saddam hussein were the kings of Purgeing their system. Please comment on victims who were purged by Trump. As the US is a democricy it should be easy to find where they are buried !

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Robert Price的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了