The Hiring Process: Your Secret Weapon or Your Achilles Heel?

Hiring is a strategically important process for any company. It's about finding the right candidate for the job and the right fit for your team. A successful hire can bring growth and success to your company, and a wrong one can lead to setbacks, reduced profitability, and cause harm to your brand image. The hiring process comprises several stages, each of which can work in your favor or against you.?

So, as a hiring manager, executive leader, or employer, how can you ensure you do it right? In this blog post, I will guide you through each step of the hiring process and share insights on how it can work for you or against you.

Job Postings

Your job posting is the first touchpoint with potential candidates, making it crucial to work in your favor. A well-crafted job posting should include the job description and give insight into your company's culture, values, and expectations. Show which requirements are must-haves, then list others that would be preferable, but not necessarily required. Match the tone of your job description to your company culture and start connecting with candidates from the start.

"71% of job seekers say it's 'very' or 'extremely important' to see details about company culture" Indeed.com

How it can work in your favor: A clear job description and company culture representation can help attract suitable candidates. Your job posting is your chance to differentiate yourself from other companies and give an idea of what someone joining your organization can expect regarding professional growth, work-life balance, and team culture.

How it can work against you: A poorly written or unclear job description can lead to the wrong candidates applying for the job or not getting any applicants. It could also give a bad impression of your company culture, leading candidates to look for other options.

Top Tip: When writing your copy, make sure to use language that is inclusive and doesn't exclude anyone from applying. LinkedIn recommends promoting your job postings on Mondays since more than half of all applications occur at the start of the work week.

Review Resumes

Once your job posting receives applications, the next step is screening resumes. A study by The Ladders found that, on average, a recruiter spends 7.4 seconds reviewing a resume. However, I suggest you spend more time reviewing them, paying particular attention to keywords critical to the job and transferable skills. Read between the lines: what does the resume suggest about candidates' capabilities and potential culture fit?

How it can work in your favor: Reviewing the resumes you've received for your job opening can help you find the right candidate. Pay attention to the experience, education, job history, and achievements. Identify top candidates by identifying the best match to your must-have requirements culture. Ensure that they align with the job description and your company values.

How it can work against you: Rushing through the resume screening process can cause you to miss out on essential details or overlook a great candidate. Not paying attention to details on the resume may result in hiring the wrong person who does not fit the job description accurately.

Top Tip: When screening resumes, look not only for the qualifications and experience of the candidate but also their written communication ability. Good written communication skills are essential in many roles today. Look for clear writing, sentence structure, grammar, spelling, and overall presentation.

Initial Screening

After reviewing resumes, the next step is to conduct an initial screening by video, phone, or at an in-person meeting. It's crucial to get to know the candidates better and showcase your company culture and values.

How it can work in your favor: A well-planned initial screening can allow you to consider the candidate's personality, communication skills, and overall fit for the organization. This step is essential in filtering the best candidates and moving forward with the most qualified ones.

How it can work against you: An unstructured initial screening can lead to an ineffective evaluation of the candidate's abilities and may harm the candidate experience, causing them to withdraw their application and leading to you losing out on a potentially great candidate. This is the first impression a candidate will have of your company. Be prepared, considerate, and engaging.

Top Tip: Avoid asking leading questions or making assumptions about a candidate's qualifications or interests based on their resume information alone. Boldly screen out candidates who are not additive to your company culture.

In-Person Interviews

The in-person interview is an opportunity to dig deeper into the candidate's skills and experience and evaluate how well they fit into the organization. It is essential to have a well-thought-out interview process to ensure that you extract the information needed to assess the candidate effectively. This step can help determine how the candidate would perform on your team.

How it can work in your favor: A thorough and well-planned interview process, including behavioral-based questions, can help you assess the candidate's critical thinking abilities and competencies, which are essential for the role.

How it can work against you: An unstructured or unprepared interview process can result in an ineffective evaluation of the candidate's competencies and cause a great candidate to leave the process prematurely.

Top Tip: Asking open-ended questions will allow candidates to explain further and often provide deeper insight into their personality, motivation, goals, skills, experience, and values. Use a friendly and professional tone.

Reference and Background Checks

It is essential to assess the candidate's work history and any other information that could impact their ability to perform the job. This is a good time to once again challenge your company about what requirements are non-negotiable and which are simply preferences. For example, you might have a long-standing policy about only hiring degreed professionals, but what if a non-degreed candidate has a perfect culture match and many years of experience?

How it can work in your favor: A thorough reference and background check can provide information about the candidate's work history and confirm the claims made on their resume. The information gathered during this stage can help you make an informed decision on the candidate's ability to perform their job competently.

How it can work against you: Failing to conduct a thorough reference and background check can be detrimental and have lasting consequences, including harm to the company image and loss of profits.

Top Tip: Make sure to ask for confirmation of dates of employment when speaking with a reference, and remember to ask if there are any areas where the applicant can improve upon or develop further in their work performance.

Onboarding

Onboarding in recruitment is the process of integrating new hires into your organization and providing them with the necessary knowledge, tools, and support to succeed. It is vital to have a structured and engaging onboarding process that fosters learning, connection, and retention.

How it can work in your favor: Effective onboarding can help you ensure that new hires are well-prepared, motivated, and productive from day one. It can also help you build a strong bond with new hires and make them feel valued, respected, and engaged, which leads to increased motivation and improved job satisfaction. Start communicating with new hires before their first day so that they confirm their decision to work for your company and so that they remain excited to join the team.

How it can work against you: Poor onboarding can result in loss of time, money, and low employee morale. It can also lead to a high turnover rate, as new hires may not feel supported or ready for success. It can also create a negative impression and increased turnover if you do not provide adequate training, resources, or guidance to new hires. Organizations must understand the importance of onboarding and make it a priority to do it right.?

Top Tip: Set up an onboarding schedule and timeline for the new employee before their start date and provide clear job expectations and performance goals from the outset. Help them feel welcome, supported, and satisfied in their decision to join the company.

Concluding Thoughts

A successful hiring process is critical to finding the right talent for your organization for long-term success. From job postings to onboarding, each stage presents an opportunity to attract, select, and retain the right candidate and build your team's culture.?

By paying attention to each hiring process step, employers and hiring managers can identify suitable candidates while avoiding mistakes that could cost them time, money, and harm the company's reputation.?

Investing in a streamlined and effective hiring process will pay off in the long run, as you will build a solid and diverse team that can help you achieve your business goals. I look forward to hearing about your success stories or challenges with implementing these hiring tips in the comments.

What are some of the challenges or successes you have faced with your hiring process? What tips or tricks do you use to make your hiring process work for you?

P.S. Be sure to subscribe to get notified about upcoming editions of this newsletter!