The High Cost of Tolerating "Bad Apples" in the Workplace

Why Tolerating Negative Influences Hurts Your Team

We've all encountered those "bad apples" in the workplace—individuals who, through negativity, disrespect, or toxic attitudes, drag everyone else down. While they might still hit their personal targets, their presence can be corrosive to the team's overall productivity and morale.

Research shows that the cost of tolerating these bad apples is far greater than we often realize (See the citation below for more info). Allowing them to remain in your team doesn’t just impact interpersonal relationships; it can lead to decreased team effectiveness, lower cohesion, and an increase in conflict. These impacts ripple outwards, reducing overall job satisfaction and diminishing the collective output of the team.

How to Address the Impact of "Bad Apples" in Practice

1. ?? Recognize the Hidden Costs: Understand that the damage caused by bad apples extends beyond their immediate interactions. Their negativity can seep into team dynamics, eroding trust, collaboration, and cohesion. Even if they meet their personal goals, their presence can lower the performance of everyone around them, leading to a net loss for the organization. I have seen it often - keeping those individuals on board because the organisation might be afraid of conflict, unsure of how to address it, or minimizing the risk - expecting "someone else" to deal with it. Ask yourself: Are you currently having someone in your team/organisation where such behaviour needs to be addressed?
2. ?? Take Swift Action to Address Toxic Behaviors: Do not wait for negativity to spiral out of control. Address disrespectful or toxic behavior as soon as it emerges. This might involve difficult conversations, but early intervention can prevent further damage and send a clear message that such behavior will not be tolerated. Difficult conversation will have to happen - the question is just how much more difficult the situation will become - and how big the impact of those behaviours will become. Ask yourself: What is stopping me from addressing the situation right now?
3. ?? Promote a Culture of Respect and Accountability: Create an environment where respect is non-negotiable, and accountability is a shared value. When team members know that negative behavior will be addressed and that everyone is responsible for maintaining a positive work environment, they are more likely to contribute constructively. Especially if you are a lead or founder, make sure that you are a role model in that. Ask yourself: What can I do to help and support the culture where respect is not only a word, but actually lived?
4. ?? Foster Open Communication and Feedback: Encourage team members to speak up when they feel a colleague's behavior is harming the team. This doesn't mean promoting gossip, but rather establishing a culture of constructive feedback where issues can be discussed openly and resolved before they escalate. Ask yourself: What channels and processes do we have in place that encourage everyone to speak up? Is it trully safe for those that speak up, or are they penalised for raising concerns?
5. ?? Evaluate Fit Beyond Performance Metrics: When assessing team members, look beyond their individual achievements - you can think of it as "culture fit". Consider impact of hired individuals on team dynamics, relationships, and overall team morale. A star performer who drags others down might not be as valuable as someone who lifts the entire team up, even if their individual metrics are slightly lower.

Bring it all together: Tolerating bad apples in the workplace is a costly mistake. Their negative influence can undermine team cohesion, reduce productivity, and increase conflict, ultimately dragging the entire team down.

By recognizing the broader impact of these toxic behaviors and taking proactive steps to address them, leaders can protect their teams, foster a positive work environment, and ensure that everyone can perform at their best.

From 1-10 how good are you and your organisation in dealing with "bad apples"?

Stay tuned for #HRMonday and subscribe to the newsletter. Follow me and Lighthouse ARA for more insights.

This LinkedIn article cites the following article for further reading: Chapman, Kenneth & Meuter, Matthew. (2023). The influence and mitigation of bad apples on group dynamics and outcomes. Journal of Education for Business. 98. 1-8. 10.1080/08832323.2023.2208812.