The High Cost of ‘Performative Inclusion’ and How to Avoid It

Is Your Inclusive Culture Performative?

While 90% of companies claim to prioritize DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion), only 25% of employees in diverse organizations feel truly included, according to a Deloitte study. This disparity highlights a crucial question: is your inclusive culture authentic, or is it performative?

What Does Genuine Inclusion Look Like?

Inclusion is more than a feel-good initiative. It's about creating an environment where diverse perspectives are heard, valued, and acted upon. Being a top company for diversity and inclusion means not only recruiting diverse employees but fostering a workplace where they thrive. Data from McKinsey shows that companies with diverse leadership are 36% more likely to outperform their less diverse peers. Inclusion isn’t simply a business imperative; it’s about building a sense of belonging.

Here’s a telling statistic: Gallup found that employees who feel included are 3 times more likely to be engaged, leading to 22% higher productivity. Without genuine inclusion, a diversity company risks missing out on its full talent potential, which could lower innovation and hinder performance.

The Inclusivity Gap: Moving Beyond Diversity Targets

Many organizations pride themselves on diversity metrics, but true inclusion can’t be measured by numbers alone. A Harvard Business Review study showed that 75% of underrepresented employees encounter microaggressions in the workplace, such as being interrupted in meetings or facing biased assumptions. These subtle actions reveal gaps in inclusive practices and indicate that the journey toward becoming a genuinely inclusive diversity company has only begun.

Common Blind Spots in Inclusion Efforts

1. Promotions Overlook Marginalized Groups: Women of color hold 18% of entry-level roles but only 4% of C-suite roles, according to McKinsey. Are your promotion practices unintentionally biased?
2. Leadership Representation: Diverse leadership isn’t just about appearances. Research reveals that companies with diverse executive teams are 70% more likely to capture new markets.
3. Invisibility in Meetings: Studies from LeanIn.Org found that 64% of women experience interruptions in meetings, while 59% of Black professionals feel their voices aren’t valued. Genuine inclusion ensures that all perspectives are heard.

Quick Self-Evaluation for Real Inclusion

1. Recruitment Channels: Are you actively sourcing talent from diverse channels, ensuring marginalized groups are included?
2. Onboarding Support: Are new hires, especially those from underrepresented backgrounds, provided with mentorship and resources to thrive?
3. Leadership Accountability: Is your leadership team committed to DEI, holding themselves accountable to foster an inclusive environment?
4. Transparent Performance Reviews: Are promotions and evaluations fair and free from bias?
5. Employee Feedback Loops: Are there safe channels for employees to voice concerns, and do you regularly gather feedback on inclusivity?

The Real Cost of Lacking Inclusion

Inclusion isn’t just about employee well-being; it’s a business advantage. The Kapor Center found that workplace exclusion costs companies $16 billion annually due to employee turnover. Organizations that fail to prioritize inclusivity are 3 times more likely to lose employees to more inclusive competitors. This isn’t just a talent drain; it erodes engagement, productivity, and ultimately, profitability.

Surprising Insights from DEI Research

• Companies with at least 30% female executives have a 15% higher profit margin, according to the Peterson Institute for International Economics.
• A 2018 McKinsey report shows that executive-level ethnic diversity can increase profitability by 33%.
• A Glassdoor survey found that 76% of job seekers evaluate companies based on diversity, meaning top companies for diversity and inclusion have a competitive advantage when attracting talent.

Moving from Performative to Real Inclusion

To become a truly inclusive diversity company, consider these actionable strategies:

• Data-Driven Decisions: Track DEI metrics at all levels, from recruitment to retention, to identify any gaps in diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts.
• Targeted Mentorship Programs: Research from Cornell University found that mentorship programs significantly boost promotion rates. Establish mentorship and sponsorship opportunities for underrepresented employees.
• Inclusive Leadership Training: Train leaders to recognize unconscious biases, promoting inclusive decision-making to ensure all voices are valued.
• Accountability and Transparency: Define and monitor your DEI goals. Publishing results internally and externally can help build trust and accountability.

?

Building an inclusive workplace requires continuous effort, data-backed evaluation, and genuine commitment. As you assess your organization, remember that inclusion is more than just a moral imperative - it’s a key to business success.

Ready to assess your organization’s inclusivity? Contact us at [email protected] to learn more.

Blog by Mansi Sharma