The Hidden Disparity: How 3% of India’s Middle-Class Pays More in Direct Taxes Than All Corporates Combined

In a country as vast and diverse as India, the tax system serves as a vital mechanism for economic redistribution and development. However, a startling disparity has emerged in the way direct taxes are levied and collected. Recent data suggests that a mere 3% of India’s middle-class population contributes more in direct taxes than the entirety of corporate India. This revelation raises critical questions about the equity and fairness of the Indian tax system and exposes an underlying issue that demands urgent attention.

The Taxation Landscape in India

India’s taxation structure is divided into direct and indirect taxes. Direct taxes include income tax, corporate tax, and wealth tax, among others. Indirect taxes, such as GST, are levied on goods and services. While the burden of indirect taxes falls uniformly on consumers, direct taxes are intended to be more progressive, with higher earners paying a greater share.

However, the Indian tax system has long been criticized for its complexities and loopholes, particularly in corporate taxation. The effective tax rate for many corporations is significantly lower than the statutory rate, thanks to various exemptions, deductions, and incentives. In contrast, the middle class, particularly salaried individuals, face a relatively straightforward tax regime with limited scope for deductions, resulting in a disproportionately high tax burden.

The Disproportionate Burden on the Middle Class

The middle class in India, often defined as those earning between ?5 lakh to ?25 lakh per annum, constitutes a significant portion of the country’s population. However, only a small fraction of this demographic, approximately 3%, falls into the higher income brackets and thus contributes a substantial portion of the country’s direct tax revenue. This elite segment of the middle class is responsible for paying more in direct taxes than the entire corporate sector.

This disparity is rooted in the tax code itself. Corporate tax rates, which theoretically range between 15% and 30%, are often mitigated by various legal avenues for tax minimization. Companies exploit deductions for depreciation, research and development, and other business expenses to reduce their taxable income. In contrast, individual taxpayers, particularly those in the salaried class, have limited deductions available, primarily related to housing loans, education loans, and insurance premiums. The lack of extensive deductions and the rigid tax brackets ensure that these individuals end up contributing a significant portion of their income to taxes.

Corporate Tax Avoidance: A Growing Concern

Corporate tax avoidance is a global phenomenon, and India is no exception. Multinational corporations, in particular, have mastered the art of tax planning, using complex structures such as shell companies, transfer pricing, and profit shifting to minimize their tax liabilities. According to various reports, the effective tax rate for some of the largest corporations in India is well below the statutory rate, sometimes as low as 10% or even lower.

The Indian government has made efforts to address these issues through measures like the introduction of the Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) and the General Anti-Avoidance Rule (GAAR). However, these measures have not fully closed the loopholes, and corporate tax avoidance remains a significant issue.

Implications of the Tax Disparity

The disproportionate tax burden on a small segment of the middle class has far-reaching implications. Firstly, it undermines the principle of tax equity, which holds that those with greater financial means should contribute a larger share of taxes. The current scenario suggests that this principle is not being upheld in India, leading to an unfair distribution of the tax burden.

Secondly, the over-reliance on middle-class taxpayers for direct tax revenue can have social and economic repercussions. The middle class, already grappling with rising living costs, inflation, and limited wage growth, is increasingly feeling the pinch. This could lead to reduced consumption, lower savings rates, and decreased investment in education and healthcare, further exacerbating income inequality.

Lastly, the inefficiency in corporate tax collection limits the government’s ability to fund public services and infrastructure projects, which are crucial for long-term economic growth. If corporations were to pay their fair share of taxes, the government could potentially increase its revenue base, reduce the fiscal deficit, and invest more in critical areas like healthcare, education, and social welfare.

The Way Forward

Addressing this disparity requires a multi-pronged approach. Firstly, the Indian government must simplify and rationalize the tax code, particularly for corporations. Closing loopholes and ensuring that all companies, regardless of size, pay their fair share of taxes is crucial. This could be achieved by reducing the scope for exemptions and deductions, tightening transfer pricing regulations, and increasing transparency in corporate reporting.

Secondly, there needs to be a broader conversation about the tax burden on individuals, particularly the middle class. The government could consider increasing the standard deduction, introducing more tax-saving options, and revising tax slabs to reduce the burden on salaried individuals.

Thirdly, strengthening the enforcement of existing tax laws is essential. The Income Tax Department should be empowered with the necessary tools and resources to combat tax evasion and ensure that all taxpayers, both individual and corporate, comply with their tax obligations.

Lastly, public awareness and engagement are key. Educating taxpayers about their rights and responsibilities, as well as the importance of tax compliance, can help build a more equitable and efficient tax system.

Conclusion

The fact that 3% of India’s middle class is paying more in direct taxes than all corporate entities combined is a stark reminder of the imbalances within the country’s tax system. While the middle class bears the brunt of direct taxation, corporations continue to benefit from a system riddled with exemptions and loopholes. To create a more just and equitable society, it is imperative that India’s tax system is reformed to ensure that all segments of society, particularly those with greater financial resources, contribute their fair share. Only then can the true potential of India’s economy be realized, with benefits accruing to all citizens, not just a privileged few.

For Guest Lectures & Sustainability Requirements Contact

Dr Rakesh Varma Ex-IAS (VR)

+91-9415334449

Founder/CEO ESGmitra? www.esgmitra.com

[email protected]

Certified ESG Professional |Certified GRI Standards Sustainability Professional (CGSSP) | Govt. EGOsystem & ECOsystem Coder | ESG BRSR GRI Leader | MBA, LLB, Public Policy Maker & Analyst