Harnessing the Power of the Diaspora for National Development

The Jamaican diaspora is a significant resource for the development of Jamaica, not only through remittances but also by means of investment, business acumen, and philanthropic efforts.? A workshop held in Kingston, Jamaica, on April 19-20, 2017, titled "Migration and Development in Jamaica: Effectively Managing Diaspora Contributions to Maximize their Development Impact" delved into various facets of diaspora contributions and outlined strategic approaches to harness these resources effectively.

Investment and Trade Facilitation through Diaspora Policy

A key takeaway was the role of diaspora policy in enhancing investment and trade. The diaspora can act as a bridge to international markets and bring in not only capital but also valuable business practices and connections. To leverage this, the workshop emphasized the need for policies that facilitate diaspora investment and create favorable conditions for diaspora entrepreneurs. This includes streamlining bureaucratic processes, providing incentives, and ensuring legal protections for diaspora investors.

Empowering Migrant and Diaspora-led Investments

The potential of migrant and diaspora-led investments was highlighted, with a focus on innovative financial instruments such as diaspora bonds and remittance-backed loans. These tools can mobilize the savings of the diaspora for developmental projects within Jamaica. The government and financial institutions are encouraged to develop products that are tailored to the needs of the diaspora, ensuring their investments contribute directly to local development.

Streamlining Remittance Transfers and Boosting Stakeholder Empowerment

Remittances are a lifeline for many families in Jamaica, and improving the infrastructure for remittance transfers can have a substantial economic impact. Reducing transaction costs, enhancing the security of transfers, and increasing the transparency of remittance flows were identified as critical areas for action. Additionally, empowering remittance recipients through financial literacy programmes can help ensure that remittances are used effectively, fostering economic independence and sustainability.

Expanding the Scope of Diaspora Philanthropy

Diaspora philanthropy extends beyond financial donations, encompassing volunteerism, mentorship, and the provision of expertise. The workshop advocated for structured programmes to channel these resources effectively, including the establishment of platforms that connect diaspora philanthropists with local projects. Encouraging donor aggregation through online platforms and hometown associations can amplify the impact of smaller contributions.

Role of the Government in Diaspora Engagement

The government's role as a facilitator of diaspora engagement is crucial. It was recommended that the government adopt a flexible approach, recognizing the diverse needs and capabilities of the diaspora. This involves not only creating conducive policies but also fostering a trust-based relationship with diaspora communities, ensuring their involvement is meaningful and impactful.

Access to Remittance Services and Financial Inclusion

To further capitalize on remittances, there is a need for rigorous research into financial behaviors and needs. This research can inform the development of services that cater specifically to the diaspora and remittance recipients, such as mobile banking solutions and financial products that meet their unique circumstances. By easing access to financial services, broader financial inclusion can be achieved, benefiting not just individual recipients but the Jamaican economy as a whole.

The workshop concluded with a strong call to action for all stakeholders involved—from government agencies to financial institutions and the diaspora themselves—to collaborate in creating an environment where the diaspora's full potential for contributing to Jamaica’s development can be realized.

Emphasizing the intrinsic value of financial inclusion and the strategic use of diaspora resources, a comprehensive framework for action was set in train to be developed.

?

Modernizing Jamaica’s Remittance Industry

Stemming from the 2017 workshop, a comprehensive framework for modernizing the remittance industry was recently completed under the auspices of the National Working Group on International Migration and Development, of which I have been a member for close to a decade, and the International Organization for Migration.

Remittances represent a significant financial inflow for Jamaica, providing essential support to the national economy and countless households. Recognizing the crucial role of remittances, the framework emphasized the need for a systematic overhaul to enhance the efficiency, accessibility, and cost-effectiveness of remittance services in Jamaica.

Regulatory Challenges

The regulatory environment governing remittances in Jamaica can be restrictive and outdated, posing significant barriers to entry for new players and stifling innovation. This limitation affects competition and keeps transaction costs high for end users.

Technological Limitations

The lack of advanced technological integration in remittance services results in inefficiencies and increased costs. Many areas in Jamaica still suffer from inadequate access to digital remittance platforms, relying instead on traditional, more costly methods.

Financial Inclusion

?A substantial portion of the population lacks easy access to formal banking services, which limits their ability to send and receive remittances. The reliance on physical pickup points can be cumbersome and insecure.

High Costs

Jamaica's remittance fees remain among the highest globally, consuming a significant portion of the remittance value, which impacts the financial support that families receive.

Consumer Protection

Current consumer protection measures are insufficient to address the transparency and fairness in fees and exchange rates for remittances. Consumers often face hidden charges and unclear terms.

Recommendations for Modernization

1. Reform Regulatory Frameworks: Streamline regulations to encourage more competition among remittance service providers. This could involve simplifying licensing processes for new entrants and reducing compliance costs to foster a more competitive market environment.

Anti-Money Laundering (AML) Practices and Counter-Terrorism Financing (CTF)

A supportive regulatory environment is necessary to foster trust and encourage the flow of remittances. This includes ensuring robust AML practices and CTF while also streamlining processes to make investments easier and more attractive.? Enhancements in AML/CFT practices are suggested to adapt to the digital age, including provisions for advanced analytics and real-time monitoring of transactions to prevent illegal activities.

Implementing tiered customer due diligence based on the risk profile of transactions, allowing for simplified processes for lower-risk transactions which are common in remittance services.

Licensing and Oversight

Modifications to licensing regimes to accommodate new types of financial service providers, including non-bank entities that offer digital remittance services.

Regular audits and compliance checks would be integrated to ensure these services operate within the legal boundaries and maintain high standards of customer protection.

Consumer Protection

With the transition to digital platforms, there is an increased focus on consumer protection. This includes ensuring transparency in the fees for digital transactions and the rights of consumers in case of disputes.

Regulations would ensure that all digital remittance services provide comprehensive information to users about transaction costs, processing times, and terms of service.

2. Invest in Technology: Promote the adoption of mobile technology and online platforms to facilitate remittances. Support initiatives like mobile wallets and blockchain technology that can offer secure, low-cost transactions accessible from anywhere in the country.

Introduction of Digital Platforms

There should be the widespread adoption of digital platforms like Electronic Wallet Services (EWS) and E-Money Transaction Accounts (EMTA). These platforms allow users to manage and transfer funds electronically without the need for traditional physical banking infrastructure.

This shift not only caters to the convenience of users but also reduces the costs associated with physical transactions and improves the speed of transfer.

3. Enhance Financial Inclusion: Develop programmes that increase banking penetration, such as introducing basic bank accounts with no fees for remittance recipients. Collaborate with local communities to educate and onboard users onto digital platforms.

Implications of Digital Inclusivity

Increased Access: Digital platforms can extend financial services to underserved and rural areas where traditional banking infrastructure is limited. This is particularly beneficial for Jamaica, where remote areas may not have easy access to banking facilities.

Economic Efficiency: Lower transaction costs and improved speed of remittances can enhance economic efficiency. It allows more funds to be used effectively by recipients rather than being absorbed by transaction costs.

Enhanced Security: Digital transactions can be more easily traced and monitored, which enhances the security of financial transfers and reduces the risk of theft or loss.

Overall, the push for digital inclusivity in remittance services aligns with global trends towards digital financial services and responds to the diaspora's need for efficient, secure, and flexible methods of sending money home. These regulatory reforms are crucial for modernizing Jamaica's financial services landscape, making it more competitive, inclusive, and resilient.

4. Lower Transaction Costs: Encourage transparency in pricing among service providers and introduce regulatory caps on fees where necessary to make remittances more affordable.

Market Entry and Expansion

Encouraging new entrants and allowing current agents to expand their services to foster competition. This could involve relaxing certain licensing requirements or providing incentives for new players to enter the market.

Fee Structures

Encouraging agents to offer competitive fee structures by promoting transparency and comparison-shopping among consumers. Regulators could facilitate this by mandating that fees be clearly posted and easily accessible to customers both online and at transaction points.

5. Strengthen Partnerships: Facilitate partnerships between banks, fintech companies, and telecom providers to leverage each other's strengths in technology, customer base, and service delivery, enhancing the overall efficiency of the remittance process.

6. Boost Consumer Protection: Implement stricter regulations that ensure full transparency of remittance costs and exchange rates. Establish a consumer ombudsman dedicated to handling complaints related to remittance services to protect users' rights effectively.

By improving protection measures and the reliability of agents, consumer confidence in the remittance system is likely to increase, which could lead to a higher volume of transactions processed through formal channels.

Transparency in Transactions: Beyond basic protections, there should be clearer disclosures about all aspects of remittance transactions. This includes detailed breakdowns of exchange rates, fees, and expected delivery times for funds. Transparent disclosures help build trust and empower customers to make informed decisions.

Error Resolution Standards: Setting up standardized protocols for error resolution that are easy for customers to access and navigate. This would involve establishing clear timelines for resolving disputes and explicit procedures for customers to report and rectify issues with transactions.

Insurance and Guarantees: Introducing insurance products or guarantee schemes to protect consumers against potential losses due to fraud or operational failures. This can reassure users and increase their confidence in using formal channels for remittances.

Development of a Matrix of Investment

The development of a matrix of investment products aimed at transforming remittance flows into growth-oriented investments is a strategic approach designed to leverage the financial contributions from the Jamaican diaspora to foster economic growth and development.

Concept of the Investment Matrix

The investment matrix categorizes and prioritizes potential investment opportunities based on their viability, the benefits they offer to both senders (diaspora) and receivers (local residents), and their impact on the national economy. This matrix is instrumental in identifying and structuring investment products that can absorb discretionary remittances effectively.

Key Features of the Investment Matrix

Diverse Investment Opportunities:

The matrix includes a range of investment products such as real estate, health insurance, educational programmes, infrastructure projects, and small and medium enterprise (SME) support.

Each product is designed to align with the interests and financial goals of the diaspora while contributing to critical sectors within Jamaica.

Benefits to Senders and Receivers:

For senders, these investments offer a return on investment (ROI), potentially higher than traditional savings or investment options in their countries of residence.

Receivers benefit through improved infrastructure, access to services (like healthcare and education), and job creation, which can elevate their quality of life.

Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs):

Many of the investment products in the matrix can be operationalized through PPPs, where the government collaborates with private sector entities to fund and manage projects.

This approach can reduce risk for individual investors and ensure that projects are executed efficiently and sustainably.

Implementation through the Matrix

Strategic Allocation: Investment products are ranked and prioritized based on various criteria, including economic impact, feasibility, and interest from the diaspora. This helps in directing funds to the most beneficial projects.

Risk Assessment and Management: Each investment opportunity is assessed for risks related to market conditions, political stability, and economic forecasts. Risk mitigation strategies are integral to the matrix, providing reassurance to investors.

Marketing and Outreach: The matrix also guides the promotional strategies to attract diaspora investors. This involves communicating the potential benefits and impacts of their investments on their home country, thus aligning their financial goals with emotional and nationalistic sentiments.

Economic Impact

By effectively channeling remittances into structured investment products, Jamaica can harness these funds for significant economic development. Investments driven by the matrix can lead to:

?·???????? Enhanced infrastructure, which can improve business conditions and attract more foreign investment.

?·???????? Job creation, particularly in sectors targeted by investment products, reducing unemployment and increasing overall productivity.

?·???????? Strengthened sectors such as real estate, healthcare, and education, which are foundational to economic stability and growth.

?

Overall, the investment matrix is a sophisticated tool that helps to convert remittances from mere financial transfers into powerful drivers of economic development, aligning the financial power of the diaspora with the development needs of Jamaica.

Conclusion

Modernizing Jamaica's remittance industry is crucial for economic growth and social welfare. By addressing regulatory hurdles, embracing technology, expanding financial inclusion, reducing costs, and enhancing consumer protection, Jamaica can ensure that remittances continue to serve as a vital lifeline for families and a significant contributor to the national economy. These strategic measures will not only benefit recipients but also strengthen the broader financial system, paving the way for more inclusive and sustainable economic development.

It is important to remember that remittances are private monetary transfers, that have mixed effects at various levels:

? Remittances can contribute to national development strategies and public investment;

? Remittances alone cannot redress structural inequalities that hinder people’s human development;

? Besides their economic impacts, remittances affect social dynamics (solidarity, reciprocity, obligations, hierarchies, power relations, etc.)

Rather than aiming at influencing remittance senders’ and beneficiaries’ decisions, from a development perspective, it might be more useful to enable greater financial inclusion to benefit the population in general:

? Financial inclusion has intrinsic value as a development goal; enlarging all people’s access to financial services would benefit remittance senders and recipients too.