Harnessing the Potential: The Best States for Owning Dispatchable Power in the U.S.

"Dispatchable power is not just a component of the energy system; it's the backbone that ensures reliability when renewable sources aren't available." - Anonymous

Understanding Dispatchable vs. Non-Dispatchable Power

In the world of power generation, energy sources are often categorized into two main types: dispatchable and non-dispatchable power. Understanding the distinction between these two is crucial for grasping the dynamics of energy management and grid stability.

Dispatchable Power: This type of power generation is characterized by its flexibility and controllability. Dispatchable power sources, such as natural gas plants, coal-fired plants, hydroelectric dams, and nuclear power stations, can be turned on or off, or adjusted to meet varying electricity demands. The ability to control the output makes dispatchable power a critical component in balancing the electricity supply with the demand and maintaining grid reliability, especially during times when consumption peaks or other sources are unavailable.

Key Characteristics:

• Adjustability: Ability to increase or decrease power output as needed.
• Reliability: Provides a steady, predictable source of power.
• Flexibility: Can quickly respond to fluctuations in demand or supply from other sources.

Non-Dispatchable Power: Contrary to dispatchable sources, non-dispatchable power is largely dependent on natural conditions and cannot be controlled in the same way. Solar and wind energy are prime examples of non-dispatchable sources, as their energy production depends on the sun shining and the wind blowing, which are not within human control. While these sources are crucial for reducing reliance on fossil fuels and decreasing greenhouse gas emissions, their intermittency poses challenges for grid operators in ensuring a constant, stable power supply.

Key Characteristics:

• Dependency on Conditions: Power output is dependent on environmental factors like weather.
• Intermittency: Can lead to fluctuations in power availability, affecting grid stability.
• Unpredictability: Less ability to forecast power output accurately, which can complicate grid management.

Integrating Both Power Types:

Effective energy management often requires integrating both dispatchable and non-dispatchable power sources. Dispatchable power can compensate for the variability and unpredictability of non-dispatchable sources, ensuring that the energy supply meets the demand at all times. This integration is vital for maintaining the reliability of the grid while accommodating a growing share of renewable energy sources.

The complexity of the U.S. energy market plays an important role in the management of dispatchable power energy sources. The ability to adjust on demand has become increasingly crucial. As the country leans into renewable energy, the intermittency of sources like wind and solar elevates the importance of having reliable, on-demand power to stabilize the grid. But not all states are created equal when it comes to the potential profitability and strategic advantage of owning dispatchable power assets. This article shares what we consider to be the best states for owning and operating dispatchable power, considering factors like regulatory environments, market dynamics, and economic incentives.

1. Texas: The Frontier of Flexibility

The Texas electricity market, operated by the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT), is unique due to its deregulated nature and isolation from the rest of the U.S. power grid. This independence allows for a more direct interaction between supply and demand, creating opportunities for significant profitability during periods of high demand and price spikes, which are common during Texas’ sweltering summers. The state’s market design incentivizes the development of fast-ramping, dispatchable resources that can quickly come online when renewable generation is low or demand peaks unexpectedly.

Key Advantages:

• High Demand Volatility: Increases the profitability of peaking power plants.
• Market Flexibility: Allows plant owners to capitalize on wholesale price fluctuations.
• Growing Renewable Penetration: Enhances the value of dispatchable power to counteract intermittency.

2. Pennsylvania and Illinois: Capitalizing on Capacity Markets

Participating in the PJM Interconnection, which covers multiple states including Pennsylvania and Illinois, offers unique advantages due to the presence of a capacity market. This market compensates power plants simply for being available, regardless of how much electricity they generate. Such markets are designed to ensure there is enough power capacity to meet peak demands, providing a steady revenue stream to dispatchable power plants that can guarantee availability during critical times.

Key Advantages:

• Capacity Payments: Provide a predictable revenue stream and help justify investments in dispatchable technologies.
• Strategic Geographic Location: Allows serving both dense urban centers and interconnected states.
• Regulatory Support: Often favorable towards maintaining grid reliability and capacity assurance.

3. California: Meeting the Challenges of Renewables Integration

California’s aggressive renewable energy targets and environmental regulations create a complex but potentially rewarding environment for dispatchable power. The state leads in solar and wind installations, which results in significant power generation variability. California’s market structures, such as the Resource Adequacy program and ancillary services markets, offer additional revenue streams for assets that can provide quick ramp-up capabilities and flexibility.

Key Advantages:

• High Renewable Penetration: Increases the necessity and value of dispatchable power for grid stability.
• Innovative Market Structures: Pay for both capacity and flexibility, crucial for balancing the grid.
• Environmental Regulations: Push for cleaner dispatchable options, opening up niches for advanced technologies like energy storage and gas turbines with lower emissions.

4. New York: Aligning Capacity with Climate Goals

New York's ambitious climate goals and the reforming energy vision under the Reforming the Energy Vision (REV) strategy enhance the role of dispatchable power in the state. Like California, New York faces the challenge of integrating large amounts of intermittent renewable energy while maintaining grid reliability. The state’s capacity markets and programs incentivizing clean energy and grid flexibility make it an attractive environment for dispatchable power solutions that can offer reliability without compromising environmental goals.

Key Advantages:

• Supportive State Policies: Encourage both renewable integration and grid reliability.
• Capacity and Ancillary Services Markets: Provide multiple revenue streams.
• Focus on Clean Energy: Promotes innovative, low-emission dispatchable power technologies.

There is Enormous Opportunity for the Savvy

Owning dispatchable power in the right state can not only be lucrative but also crucial for the transition to a more sustainable energy future. States like Texas, Pennsylvania, Illinois, California, and New York offer distinct advantages that can be leveraged by savvy investors and operators. Each state presents unique opportunities and challenges, shaped by their regulatory frameworks, market designs, and overall energy goals. As the U.S. continues to evolve its energy ecosystem, the strategic importance of dispatchable power cannot be understated, making it a key player in ensuring grid stability and economic viability in the renewable age.

The Indispensable Role of Expert Energy Advisors

"The expertise of a knowledgeable energy advisor is more critical than ever. As the complexities of the global energy market increase, organizations need advisors who can provide cross-functional expertise, navigate both regulated and deregulated markets, and ensure that all elements of the power stack work seamlessly together. By doing so, they can optimize their energy strategy, maximize cost-effectiveness, and meet the growing demands of carbon intensity and sustainability." - Energy Ninja

Need Help with Your Natural Gas and/or Power Procurement, Real-time Energy Analytics, and/or Utility & Energy Infrastructure?

Ralph Rodriguez, LEED AP OM is the Energy Ninja and Legend Energy Advisors manages:

1. Over $2 Billion in commodity risk for our clients.
2. Real-time Energy Analytics (PUE) in some of the most energy intense industries in N. America.
3. Utility & Energy Infrastructure Advisory at a level that is different than traditional advisors, consultants, and engineers.

"??????'?? ???????? ?????? ???????????? ????????????, ?????? ???????????? ????????????!"

Website: Legend Energy Advisors