Harnessing AI for Smarter Resume Screening and Work Style Assessments (part of the Overcoming Fear to Harness AI in HR Series)

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is transforming how organizations approach talent acquisition. Traditional resume screening methods are becoming less efficient compared to the speed and accuracy AI-powered tools like ChatGPT4.0 can offer. Using AI strategically, recruiters and hiring managers can sift through hundreds of resumes, quickly identify the most suitable candidates for specific roles, and uphold applicants' privacy. AI also offers a way to assess work styles and job fit without relying on traditional personality assessments, paving the way for more holistic hiring processes.

The Power of AI in Resume Screening

Resume screening, long considered the most labor-intensive part of the hiring process, can be streamlined through AI by processing vast amounts of information in seconds. Where human eyes tend to start blurring the differences between candidates after a few dozen resumes, AI can look at bulk numbers of resumes in seconds, all through the same lens.

The key to leveraging AI tools like ChatGPT4.0 lies in crafting precise prompts that instruct the AI on what to look for in candidate resumes. For example, when hiring for a technical position, you should highlight the technical qualifications, leadership potential, and problem-solving abilities.

Consider the following prompt:

??????????? “Analyze these resumes and compare them to the job description for a senior software engineer. Highlight key technical skills, leadership roles, problem-solving achievements, and potential areas for development.”

This prompt type ensures that the AI identifies keywords and contextual evidence reflecting the candidate’s real-world abilities. ChatGPT can offer a more comprehensive evaluation than a standard keyword search by incorporating nuanced criteria into your prompts. The result? A more refined pool of top candidates, potentially cutting down the candidate list by over 70% (Bersin, 2021) in moments.

How to Upload Resumes to ChatGPT for Screening

For ChatGPT to assist in the resume screening process, the resumes must be uploaded in a compatible format, typically as text-based files like .txt or .docx. This is often easily accomplished by downloading the resumes in that format, but it can also be performed by saving a file as one of these file types in MS Word. Once converted, these files can be uploaded into the ChatGPT environment for analysis. Here’s a step-by-step guide for uploading and screening resumes with ChatGPT:?

1.??? Prepare the Files: Convert all resumes into text-based formats. This can be done by saving PDF resumes as .txt or .docx files, which ChatGPT can easily read.

2.??? Upload the Files: When using ChatGPT, you’ll need to provide the resumes as inputs. If using a local system, batch upload or drag-and-drop functionality can speed this process up. For more sophisticated use cases, there are third-party API integrations that streamline uploading multiple resumes for analysis.

3.??? Input the Correct Prompts: Once the resumes are uploaded, input the prompts that guide ChatGPT in evaluating the documents. Example prompts could include (more prompts later in this article):

• “Analyze these resumes for experience with Java, leadership in software teams, and relevant certifications.”
• “From these resumes, identify candidates with more than five years of project management experience and who have led cross-functional teams.”

4.??? Receive the Analysis: ChatGPT will provide a breakdown of the resumes, highlighting strengths, weaknesses, and gaps based on your specific criteria. This output can then be used to decide which candidates move forward in the recruitment process.

Privacy Considerations When Using AI for Resume Screening

AI’s ability to process personal data, particularly in recruitment, requires stringent privacy measures. Laws like the GDPR and CCPA restrict how personal data is handled, so recruiters must ensure that any use of AI complies with these regulations. Protecting applicant privacy is critical, particularly when handling sensitive personal information embedded in resumes, such as contact information, addresses, and employment history.

There are a few key strategies to ensure privacy when using ChatGPT to analyze resumes:

1. Anonymize Resumes: Before uploading resumes into the system, remove any identifiable personal information such as names, addresses, and contact information. Many AI platforms and ATSs allow for automatic anonymization, but this can also be done manually when formatting the file(s).
2. Use Data Encryption: Encrypt all resumes and related data before uploading them to the AI system. This prevents unauthorized access and maintains data security throughout the recruitment process. You may want to discuss this with your IT team!
3. Implement Role-Based Access Control (RBAC): Limit access to candidate data by assigning different levels of data access based on role. This ensures that only authorized individuals within the organization can access candidate information.
4. Establish a Data Retention Policy: Once the resume analysis process is complete, data should be stored only as necessary. Implement policies that dictate when and how candidate data is deleted to comply with data protection laws.

Key Point: Many companies are now adding a checkbox that explains that resumes may be assessed with the assistance of AI and that “checking this box indicates your understanding of this policy.” Other organizations are giving candidates the option to opt out of AI review. Either option provides the candidate with full disclosure about the use of AI and may protect your use of it in some cases.

Crafting the Right Prompts for Resume Screening

Using ChatGPT to filter through resumes is only as effective as the prompts you provide. Detailed and context-rich prompts help narrow down candidates effectively. Below are some examples that might be useful depending on the role you’re hiring for:

• For technical roles: “Please identify candidates with more than five years of experience in software development, particularly those with Python and cloud technologies skills and leadership experience in agile teams. List the candidates in order based on their alignment with the above skills and the attached job description/ requirements. Highlight each candidate’s key technical skills, leadership gaps, clear strengths, and any skills gaps with the above skills and attached job description.”
• For marketing roles: “Highlight candidates with proven experience in digital marketing, especially in SEO and content strategy. Look for those who have demonstrated growth in social media engagement and led marketing campaigns. ?List the candidates in order based on their alignment with the above skills and the attached job description/ requirements. Highlight each candidate’s key technical skills, leadership gaps, clear strengths, and any skills gaps with the above skills and attached job description.”
• For leadership roles: “Review these resumes and identify candidates with experience leading cross-functional teams, managing budgets of over $1 million, and overseeing significant organizational change. List the candidates in order based on their alignment with the above skills and the attached job description/ requirements. Highlight each candidate’s key technical skills, leadership gaps, clear strengths, and any skills gaps with the above skills and attached job description.”

Using specific prompts allows you to narrow the pool of candidates based on the skills and qualifications that are most relevant to the role.

Key Point: The information you get from any AI tool is only as good as the prompts you put into it. Be specific and assume that your AI tool does not make any assumptions or draw conclusions as a human might. This takes some practice!

Creating Work Style Assessments Without Personality Tests

While personality assessments have been a popular tool in recruitment, they can often be restrictive and open to biases. They also focus on personality rather than skills and experience. Instead, work style assessments—focused on how candidates approach tasks, solve problems, and manage teams—can provide a more meaningful understanding of how they might fit within your organization. AI can help craft these assessments by simulating real-life work scenarios and asking candidates to respond based on their experiences.

For example, if hiring for a project management role, you might ask ChatGPT to generate scenario-based questions such as:

??????????? “Develop a work style assessment for a project manager role, focusing on decision-making in high-pressure situations, resource allocation, and team dynamics. I have attached a job description; please include scenarios encouraging the applicant to respond as they would in the position.”

Such assessments allow candidates to demonstrate their critical thinking and adaptability without pigeonholing them into predefined personality types. Instead, you get a clearer picture of how they might handle the role's day-to-day challenges, providing a more accurate measure of their fit within your company culture.

Balancing Efficiency with Personalization

AI tools like ChatGPT can help recruiters process large volumes of data efficiently, but it’s essential to remember that recruitment is human-centered. While AI can reduce the number of resumes to review, be sure that humans are still a core part of the recruitment process. Once you’ve used AI to shortlist candidates, bring them into more personalized stages of the process, such as in-depth interviews and team-based assessments.

AI can do the heavy lifting, but human judgment will always be necessary to ensure that the right candidates are chosen for their skills and ability to contribute to the company’s overall mission and culture.

Embracing AI for the Future of Recruitment

Artificial intelligence is reshaping how organizations approach hiring, offering significant benefits in speed, accuracy, and depth of analysis. Tools like ChatGPT4.0 enable organizations to analyze resumes efficiently, craft job-related assessments, and protect applicant privacy. The future promises more efficient and effective recruitment processes for organizations ready to embrace AI, leading to stronger teams and better business outcomes.

To make the most of AI in your recruitment strategy, it’s essential to balance data-driven insights and human judgment. By combining AI’s ability to analyze vast amounts of data with personalized, human-led hiring processes, you can build teams that meet the role's technical requirements and align with your organization’s culture and long-term vision.

Next time, we’ll discuss how to use AI tools to help streamline your onboarding process. Improving these processes is crucial for all organizations, as recent research shows that poor onboarding experiences, particularly when informal or poorly structured, often result in disengaged employees (Sharma & Stol, 2020), poor task mastery, role ambiguity, decreased job satisfaction (Fr?géli et al., 2023), and, ultimately, higher turnover among new hires (Sharma & Stol, 2020). I hope you’ll join me!

?

?

References

Bersin, J. (2021). How AI is Reshaping Talent Acquisition and Recruitment. Deloitte Insights. https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/insights/focus/technology-and-the-future-of-work/ai-in-talent-acquisition.html.

Fr?géli, E., Jenner, B., & Gustavsson, P. (2023). Effectiveness of formal onboarding for facilitating organizational socialization: A systematic review.?PloS one,?18(2), e0281823. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0281823.

Sharma, G.G., & Stol, K.J. (2020). (2015). Sharma, G. G., & Stol, K. J. (2020). Exploring onboarding success, organizational fit, and turnover intention of software professionals.?Journal of Systems and Software,?159, 110442. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2019.110442.