Are Harmonics Real? (Part 1)
Alan Friedman Cat IV, CRL, CMRP, Author
Vibration Analysis Training and Certification
Introduction
Are harmonics “real” or just an artifact or result of processing the waveform through the FFT? This is a question that comes up a lot among vibration analysts, or anyone working with signals and signal processing.
What Are Harmonics?
A sine wave has a single amplitude and frequency. Let’s say our sine wave has a frequency of 25 Hz and a peak amplitude of 10. If you use the FFT algorithm to convert a sine wave to a spectrum, you will see a single peak at 25 Hz with a peak amplitude of 10. You can see this at the beginning of the animation above. At the starting point there is a sine wave at the top and the spectrum below with a single peak at 25 Hz.
A wave that repeats itself, but is not a sine wave results in harmonics in the spectrum. You can also see this in the animation above. As I clip or flatten the top of the wave, you can see the harmonics appearing in the spectrum. Harmonics are multiples of the base frequency. In this case they are 25 Hz x 2, 25 x 3, 25 x 4 etc. giving us peaks at 25 Hz, 50 Hz, 75 Hz, 100 Hz etc.
The Fast Fourier Transform (FFT)
The FFT is a tool that reveals the frequency components present in a signal. It breaks the signal down into a series of sine waves.
Another way of phrasing this is: The FFT essentially says “give me a wave and I will give you a bunch of sine waves. If you add all these sine waves together, it will look like the initial wave.” This is my layman’s way of understanding of it anyway.
Each peak in the spectrum represents a sine wave. If I were to add the sine waves represented by the peaks at 25, 50, 75 and 100 Hz etc at the end of the animation above, the resulting wave would look just like the clipped wave.
But Are Harmonics Real?
One view of this is that the wave I used for this explanation is not "real" in that it is something I generated in software. I also clipped it in software, so the peaks at 50, 75 and 100 Hz don't correspond to anything real in the physical world, so they must just be artifacts or things stemming from running the data through the FFT. Right?
A Physical Representation of Clipping
Let's say I move a mass and spring back and forth 30 times per second (30 Hz) with a sinusoidal force (a sine wave) but as the spring compresses, it gets more rigid and eventually stops compressing. This will create a clipped wave as in the image below. When I pull the mass out, it looks like a sine wave, when I push it in, compressing the spring, it get's flattened.
As we noted before, the clipped wave is repetitive but not a sine wave and therefore we will get harmonics. As you can see from the image above, we have peaks at 30, 60, 90 and 120 Hz.
One might look at this physical example of a clipped wave and they might say: "I see the mass moving back and forth 30 times / second. I do not see anything happening at 60 times per second or at 90 times per second, so harmonics can't be real. They must just come out of the FFT algorithm."
Repetitive Impacting
Another example of a wave that is repetitive but not a sine wave is repetitive impacts. If I take a drum stick and I hit a drum 5 times per second (as in the time waveform image below) I would see peaks in the spectrum at 5, 10, 15, 20 Hz etc. In other words, harmonics. Intuitively you know that you are only hitting the drum 5 times per second, so why would there be frequencies at 10, 15 and 20 Hz etc. in the spectrum? They must just come out of the FFT right?
The pattern above is common in machinery vibration analysis. This could be a bearing with a defect on the race and the impacts are the balls or rollers slamming into that defect one after the other. This could also a be a broken gear tooth that causes a big impact every time it comes into contact with the other gear. In both of these cases, the analyst would expect to see harmonics of the defect frequency in the spectrum.
A single Impulse or Impact
A common test in vibration analysis it to strike an object with a calibrated hammer. The calibrated hammer has a force sensor in it's tip, so it measures the actual hit. If we look at this in the time waveform, we see a single sharp, short duration pulse. When we convert this pulse to a spectrum, we get vibration at many frequencies or what is referred to as "broadband" noise.
One might say: "The FFT has a really hard time describing that single impact by adding sine waves together. The only way to do it is to add sine waves together at every frequency as shown in the image above." These frequencies don't exist in the real world though. (Or do they?)
I will ask again, using this example, are the frequencies shown in the spectrum for this single impact "real?" Do they really exist? Or are they just a result of passing that data through the FFT and the FFT trying to describe it by adding sine waves together?
Conclusion to Part 1
I want to leave this as an open question for now. Take some time, think about it, and decide for yourself if you think harmonics (and broadband noise) are real or not. In part 2 of this article, I will lay out a case for what I think. I will also admit that my thinking about this has changed over the years. I used to take one side of this issue, now I lean towards the other. But, you can decide for yourself.
I welcome your opinions in the chat. I would love to hear good arguments for both sides. In the meantime...
How About Registering for a Vibration Course?
New Course Materials
I'm excited to announce a rediscovered interest in programming and animating. I've been creating new simulators and 3D animations in my spare time. Many of these were showcased in my 2024 fall run of classes. Feedback was excellent! As my skills improve I will be taking on more ambitious simulator projects that I will be happy to share in my classes. I've also added some useful videos. It is much easier to learn the concepts when you can "See" them in animations and simulators.
In addition to improving how vibration concepts are explained, I have been updating the course materials to include the latest information on emerging technologies such as wireless vibration sensors, IIoT, Digital Transformation, Industry 4.0 etc. In this way, all of Zenco's courses continue to meet and exceed the requirements of ISO 18436-2
When choosing a vibration course, remember to support small US based businesses!
Private Courses
I am taking reservations for private courses in 2025. If you have a few people to train, it is probably more cost effective to have me come to you - OR - do a private course online. Message me for pricing and availability [email protected]
Public Course Dates
Click the links below to purchase the courses online with a Credit Card.?You do not need a PayPal account to pay with a credit card. Email me at [email protected] for other payment options. Full course schedule: zencovibrations.com/shop
Live Online January 2025
Live online courses will be conducted in a US time zone, but everyone in the world is invited to join. If you have 4 or more people contact me to arrange a private online course in your time zone and on dates of your choosing. Cat 1 and 2 are also available in Spanish.
The prices include the training (3 x 8 hr days for Cat I. 4 x 8 hr days for Cat II and III), certification exam (conducted online via a website), course manual and certificate in PDF format.
Discounts and scholarships are available for people in developing countries who are paying for the courses themselves. You'll either need a credit card or a PayPal account. Email me to inquire.
Houston, TX at EnVibe, Inc.
Please purchase from Envibe directly: [email protected] or call: 713-682-0363 or 888-473-5222. You will be able to purchase the classes directly from Envibe's website in a few weeks (currently under construction)
Miami, Florida at LUDECA, INC.
Click the links below to purchase with PayPal or a credit card. Message me for other payment options.
Mechanical Engineer
4 天前If they wouldn't be real, there won't be any differences in hearing different musical instruments playing same notes or internal combustion engines with different number of cylinders or constructions would sound similar while running constant rpms.
Scalable wireless vibration monitoring utilizing big data, machine learning, and AI
5 天前It's pretty easy to prove nowadays just take your motion amplification camera and filter at harmonics and see if there is motion.
Solutions Engineer at RISE Güvenilirlik ??zümleri
6 天前I think, harmonics are result of passing clipped wave data through the FFT but I wonder to read your Part II paper. Thank you for sharing you real knowledge and experiences