Hard Lessons Learned: Untangling the Gordian Knot of Leadership
?
In my journey of leadership, some of the hardest lessons arrived wrapped in knots—complex, confounding situations that test resolve, wisdom, and adaptability. I’ve had many such lessons through my life.? As the son of a career soldier I went the 13 schools before graduating from high school.? I became deathly ill as a teen and spent three months hospitalized with a lot of Viet Nam war patients.? So many more.? Fortunately I was a good learner.
Reflecting on my own leadership path, I’ve encountered various "knots" that required different approaches. Leading a platoon of new recruits in basic training taught me the power of establishing trust and instilling discipline in young soldiers who, like me, ?were new to the rigors of military life. Later, learning how to follow taught me humility and the value of listening to those more experienced—a vital knot to untangle in the evolution from soldier to leader. Finally, coaching others to reach their potential presented its own unique set of challenges, as I guided individuals to unlock strengths they hadn’t yet recognized in themselves.
These challenges bring to mind the ancient story of the Gordian Knot, a problem so intricate it was deemed impossible to untangle. Alexander the Great famously sliced through the knot with his sword, finding a bold solution that required not only skill but a willingness to redefine the rules of engagement.
The Gordian Knot in leadership is not a single problem to "cut through" but a continuous process of learning and unlearning. Each situation demands a unique approach—sometimes as a mentor, sometimes as a motivator, and sometimes as a disciplined follower. Through these experiences, I’ve come to realize that the lessons we learn in these moments define our leadership style and set the stage for achieving excellence.
?Seek Perfection, Achieve Excellence
One of Vince Lombardi’s most iconic philosophies, "Seek perfection, achieve excellence," perfectly captures the spirit of hard lessons in leadership. Lombardi wasn’t advocating for an impossible ideal, but rather for a relentless pursuit that drives excellence in the process. This mindset is critical when facing leadership’s Gordian Knots, where achieving excellence is about continuously striving, learning, and improving.
?
?Recognizing When to Cut the Knot
In sports and business alike, there are times when "playing by the rules" may hold back an organization. Leaders need to know when to adhere to tradition and when to challenge it—when to preserve a process and when to “cut through” it. In the 1960s, Green Bay Packers coach Vince Lombardi inherited a team that was struggling to perform. Lombardi didn’t shy away from drastic action; he focused on basics, discipline, and an entirely new culture of resilience and pursuit of excellence. This radical shift in approach transformed the team, propelling them to championship success.
Likewise, in the workplace, a leader who sees their team bogged down by outdated methods or policies may need to “cut through” the complexity with decisive action. It could mean restructuring, setting new expectations, or re-evaluating the team’s objectives. While these actions may initially seem harsh or risky, they are often necessary for long-term growth and improvement.
?
?Building a Resilient Team Culture
The challenges in leadership don’t end with a single knot or obstacle; they keep coming. Just as teams face new opponents each season, leaders face fresh hurdles regularly. To navigate these challenges successfully, leaders must instill resilience and adaptability in their teams. This is akin to sports teams that study their mistakes, recalibrate, and develop new strategies. As John Wooden, another legendary coach, once said, "Failure is not fatal, but failure to change might be." Leaders who embrace hard lessons—and encourage their teams to do the same—build a culture where every setback becomes an opportunity to grow.
Certainly! One compelling example of a business leader who tackled a Gordian Knot in his career is Howard Schultz of Starbucks. Schultz’s leadership story is a testament to resilience, decisive action, and a commitment to both employees and customers.
In the late 2000s, Starbucks was facing a crisis: rapid expansion had diluted its brand, customer loyalty was declining, and the company’s profitability was at risk. Schultz, who had previously served as CEO and then stepped back from daily operations, was called upon to return and address these challenges head-on. The situation resembled a Gordian Knot, with no straightforward solutions—just an entanglement of issues affecting operations, culture, and customer perception.
?Schultz's Approach
Much like Alexander cutting through the knot, Schultz took bold, unconventional actions to turn Starbucks around. He closed over 7,000 U.S. stores for a day to retrain baristas on the art of making espresso. This move was seen as radical and costly, but Schultz understood it was essential to restore quality and reinforce Starbucks’ core values. He also made other significant changes, like slowing expansion, redesigning stores, and investing in employee benefits and training to reinvigorate the company culture.
Lessons in Excellence and Resilience
?
Schultz’s approach echoes Vince Lombardi’s principle: "seek perfection, achieve excellence." He understood that to get the company back on track, Starbucks needed to re-embrace its original mission and focus on delivering a premium customer experience, even if that meant scaling back or pausing growth.
?
Schultz’s journey offers valuable lessons in handling complex, seemingly insurmountable challenges with clarity and commitment. His ability to see through the chaos, realign Starbucks with its core mission, and lead the company back to profitability is a masterclass in untangling a modern Gordian Knot. His story reinforces that sometimes, achieving excellence means recognizing when to step back, refocus, and make bold, transformative decisions—even when they go against conventional wisdom.
The Inner Game of Leadership
In the late 80”s I had the opportunity to take a management lesson from Timothy Gallwey, author of “The Inner Game of Tennis”.? It was an “AHA” learning moment.
?Gallwey’s Inner Game philosophy provides another lens for approaching leadership’s Gordian Knots. Gallwey, best known for his work in sports psychology, emphasized that the biggest obstacles to success are often internal rather than external. In his view, the "inner game" involves overcoming self-doubt, fear of failure, and the inner critic that can sabotage performance. For leaders, this means recognizing that untangling complex challenges often requires first untangling the internal dialogue that clouds judgment or saps confidence.
?
Gallwey’s principle—quieting the mind to let natural ability and intuition take over—reminds us that effective leadership is not just about bold decisions or external strategies but also about mastering self-awareness. By aligning their internal state with their external actions, leaders can approach even the toughest challenges with clarity and poise, slicing through the complexity with a balanced and focused mindset. This alignment is often the key to unlocking not only personal potential but also the potential of their teams.
?
?Practicing Accountability and Learning from Losses
Every leader experiences setbacks; the difference lies in how we respond. In sports, losses are dissected, analyzed, and learned from. Great teams emerge stronger by identifying weaknesses and addressing them head-on. The same applies in business. Leaders who take responsibility, own up to mistakes, and model accountability inspire a culture of continuous improvement. Rather than deflecting blame or rationalizing failure, they focus on what can be learned and implemented differently next time.
?
?The Enduring Impact of Hard Lessons
The lessons learned in overcoming these Gordian Knots of leadership are invaluable. They foster resilience, innovation, and a commitment to excellence. By “seeking perfection,” leaders and their teams ?achieve excellence, no matter how formidable the obstacles. Hard lessons do not signal defeat but, rather, open new paths forward. It’s in this crucible that true leaders emerge, those who are unafraid to cut through the complexities and lead their teams to greatness.
?
As leaders, let us approach each knot, each complex problem, with both our experience and wisdom to understand it and the courage to untangle it, knowing that each challenge makes us sharper, more insightful, and ultimately, more effective. With the spirit of Lombardi, we may not achieve perfection—but in seeking it, we will achieve excellence.
#GordianKnot#HowardSchulz@JohnWooden#TimothyGalwey#Starbucks#Sanantonioexecutivecoaching#Leadership#teams#humandevelopment