A Guide to Income Tax Scrutiny Assessments Under Section 143(3)

Income Tax scrutiny assessments, governed primarily by Section 143 of the Income Tax Act, involve a detailed examination of an assessee’s financial declarations. Unlike routine assessments, scrutiny assessments focus on ensuring the accuracy and compliance of returns filed by taxpayers. These assessments help confirm that income is not understated, losses are not overclaimed, and tax liabilities are accurately computed.

What Is Scrutiny Assessment Under Section 143(3)?

Scrutiny assessments are detailed evaluations conducted by an Assessing Officer (AO) to verify the validity of claims, deductions, and other details disclosed in an income tax return. The main objectives include:

• Ensuring there is no understatement of income.
• Preventing excessive losses from being claimed.
• Verifying that the tax liability is correctly computed.

Unlike summary assessments, scrutiny assessments involve rigorous checks to ensure compliance with tax laws.

Conditions for Scrutiny Assessments

For a scrutiny assessment to commence, specific conditions must be fulfilled:

Filing of Return

• The taxpayer must have filed a return under Section 139, which mandates regular filing for individuals and entities with taxable income.
• Alternatively, the return may be filed in response to a notice under Section 142(1), issued when a taxpayer fails to file or additional information is required.

Necessity for Verification

The AO initiates scrutiny when there is a need to verify:

• Understated income,
• Overstated losses, or
• Less payment of tax.

The process is selective and based on predefined criteria to ensure fairness.

The Scrutiny Process Under Section 143(2)

The scrutiny assessment officially begins with the issuance of a notice under Section 143(2). The steps involved include:

1. Issuance of Notice: The AO serves a notice to initiate the process, which must be issued within a specified time to maintain procedural fairness.
2. Submission of Documents: Taxpayers are required to submit supporting documents, statements, and evidence for the claims, deductions, and exemptions reported in their return.
3. Final Assessment Order: After reviewing the submissions, the AO issues a final order under Section 143(3), detailing the assessed income or loss and the tax payable or refundable.

Types of Scrutiny Notices Under Section 143(2)

Scrutiny notices are categorized based on the scope and focus of the assessment:

1. Limited Scrutiny:
2. Complete Scrutiny:
3. Manual Scrutiny:

Authority for Scrutiny Assessment (Rule 12E)

To ensure scrutiny assessments are handled by qualified personnel, Rule 12E mandates that notices under Section 143(2) can only be issued by income tax officials not below the rank of Income Tax Officer, as authorized by the CBDT.

Validity of Notices Under Section 292BB

Section 292BB addresses situations where procedural defects occur in the issuance or service of a notice. If a taxpayer participates in the scrutiny process and cooperates with the AO, they cannot later challenge the notice’s validity due to procedural flaws.

Non-Compliance and Its Implications

Failure to comply with scrutiny notices can lead to serious consequences:

1. Ex-Parte Assessment (Section 144):
2. Penalties (Section 272A):

Prompt responses and cooperation are essential to avoid unfavorable outcomes.

Special Provisions for Trusts and Research Institutions

Charitable trusts, research institutions, and other tax-exempt entities are subject to additional scrutiny under Sections 10 and 2(15):

• Commercial Receipts Threshold: Trusts earning commercial receipts exceeding 20% of their total income lose tax exemption under Section 10(23C) for that year.
• Withdrawal of Approval: For institutions approved under Section 35, failure to meet conditions may result in the withdrawal of tax benefits after due process.

Key Takeaways

• ?Scrutiny assessments ensure accuracy and compliance in the tax system, deterring evasion and misreporting.
• Responding to notices promptly and cooperating with the AO are crucial for favorable outcomes.
• Understanding the process, types of scrutiny, and requirements can help taxpayers and professionals navigate assessments effectively. Learn More