Growth: The Unicorn's Dream or a Startup's Nightmare?

“Growth for the sake of growth is the ideology of the cancer cell,” – Edward Abbey once warned.?

Yet in the consumer products world, growth remains the holy grail, driving shareholder value and industry prestige.?

In a world obsessed with scaling fast and hitting unicorn status, growth remains the default goal for most new-age companies, as well.

But is growth always good??

Let’s dive into this question, not by looking at giants like Unilever, but by spotlighting D2C startups and new global players who’ve either thrived or crashed, chasing unapproachable targets.

In Favour: Growth Drives Progress & Opportunity

1. Investor Expectations As startup guru Paul Graham noted, “Startups grow quickly because they have to.”?

Razorpay, a fintech unicorn out of India, exemplifies this. Growing over 300% in just three years, it aggressively expanded its offerings from payment gateways to corporate banking solutions.?

For investors, this kind of growth is the magic formula—rapid expansion, broader market share, and sky-high valuations.

2. D2C Innovation & Consumer Alignment

Look at Glossier, a beauty D2C brand that grew explosively by putting its community at the heart of its product development.?

They leveraged customer feedback loops, which skyrocketed brand loyalty and sales.

In just a few years, Glossier went from a blog to a billion-dollar brand by tapping into consumer preferences, shifting channel strategies to online-first, and creating cult-like demand.

3. Employee Growth & Opportunity High-growth companies often attract top-tier talent.?

Brex, the startup offering corporate credit cards, scaled fast by appealing to small businesses and startups with unique financial needs. Their aggressive growth opened doors for their employees, who found themselves on the ground floor of fintech innovation, leading to exponential career opportunities.

Counter-Argument: Growth Can Be Dangerous Without Sustainability

While rapid growth is exciting, it can lead to burnout, operational strain, and an eventual collapse if not managed carefully.

1. Overexpansion & Failure to Pivot

Take Zilingo, a once-promising Southeast Asian e-commerce and retail tech startup.?

It grew aggressively, expanding into multiple markets without fully stabilizing its core offering. Eventually, it buckled under internal management conflicts and operational inefficiencies. The faster they grew, the quicker the cracks started to show.?

“Growth is never by mere chance; it is the result of forces working together,” as James Cash Penney, founder of JCPenney, put it—Zilingo’s downfall reminds us that the wrong forces can push growth over the edge.

2. Operational Strain & Unsustainable Growth Growth often puts a strain on operations.?

Peloton, the at-home fitness equipment company, grew phenomenally during the pandemic but faced serious challenges post-COVID. They overestimated demand, leading to layoffs, excess inventory, and a plunge in stock value.?

As Ben Horowitz of Andreessen Horowitz said, “The company that grows at all costs, in the end, will pay the highest price.”

Peloton’s struggle with balancing growth and sustainability is a stark warning for startups chasing unrealistic targets.

3. Market Misalignment & Burnout

Companies that fail to adapt to shifting consumer behaviours suffer the consequences.?

Fast, a fintech startup offering one-click checkout solutions was all about hyper-growth.?

They expanded rapidly without solidifying their product-market fit, and in 2022, they shut down after burning through millions in VC funding. Fast chased growth without understanding the actual demand, leading to internal chaos and eventual failure.

In addition, factoring in the role of AI in this debate :

AI helps brands anticipate consumer preferences, streamline supply chains, and enhance customer service, fueling faster, smarter expansion.

Yet, unchecked, AI can also accelerate unsustainable growth by scaling too quickly without human oversight.

In this AI-driven era, growth must be intentional—leveraging AI’s power without losing sight of operational and market realities. The key is to balance the dream of scaling fast with the discipline of sustainable growth.

The Bottom Line: Startups must balance the drive for rapid growth with a clear understanding of sustainability and market fit. Growth for the sake of growth can be a ticking time bomb.

So, is growth always good, or should startups rethink their approach?

Share your thoughts below.?? #D2C #Startups #GrowthStrategy #BusinessLeadership #Sustainability

?? React to support

?? Comment with your views and tips

?? Please also share this post to help others

? Follow me, Ashish jain??for more strategy.