Growth through New Product Development – Comparing Product Diversification vs. Specialization

A New Product Development Strategy is imperative for many companies to stay ahead of their competitors. From a strategic standpoint, the company's leadership team has a key question to answer - Are we going to diversify our product range, or specialize to meet the needs of different industries and customers within it? Which strategy is the right fit for our company and will move it towards exceeding the growth goals?

Resources inside the company – skills, knowledge, equipment and investment all play a part in the decision, even before the strategic marketing group has started to complete a full analysis of the market.

This critical choice can shape an organization’s future and long-term success. Below, the advantages and disadvantages of each strategy, along with examples of each and the recommended approach are presented. For the purpose of this article, it is assumed that a geographical expansion is not part of the strategic growth plan.

Product Diversification into the Same Market

This is the easiest to understand and is when a company seeks to introduce a product used in the same industry, but inherently different from what has been developed before. An example if this could be a machinery manufacturer initially focusing on conveyor systems but diversifying its product line to include robotics or automated packaging solutions for various industries. Another example is a software solutions provider that initially focused solely on customer relationship management (CRM) software but expands its offerings to include marketing automation, analytics, and e-commerce integration for their customers.

Advantages of Product Diversification

1.????? Revenue Synergy: Offering a broader range of products can lead to cross-selling opportunities with current customers. It’s well known that selling to your existing customers is easier and less resource-intensive than selling to new customers.

2.????? Market Stability: Diversification within the same market can help mitigate economic and seasonal fluctuations. When one product category experiences a decline, others may compensate.

3.????? Customer Convenience: A diversified portfolio can enhance new and current customers’ experiences by consolidating their supply chains or reducing the number of vendors that must be managed.

?

Disadvantages of Product Diversification in the Same Market:

1.????? Resource Allocation and Costs: Developing and managing diverse product categories requires significant resources in New Product Development Engineers, Product Managers, Sales and Marketing personnel, requiring more investment than a specialization strategy. Although there may be synergies within the market, the products and / or services are different.

2.????? Skills and Experience: The company should consider the skills of existing resources. Are they familiar enough with the market to determine which product should be developed? Do the Engineering team have the required expertise. For example, if it has been determined to diversify into a product heavily controlled by electronics, are those skills in the company, or will they have to be recruited?

3.????? Brand Identity: Striking the right balance is critical. Over-diversifying can blur the brand's identity and confuse customers.

Product Specialization into the Same Market

Product specialization is taking the product and customizing it for particular segments within the market – so each customer group gets a solution that exactly fits their needs. One example is Tesla. Initially the company launched production of Model S, a luxury sports car. Tesla’s next model (Model Z) was designed to meet the requirements of the SUV market and the model 3 was targeted at the mid-sized sedan market. Each model was researched and developed specifically for the market segment, while under the umbrella of electric powered vehicles.

Advantages of Product Specialization

1.????? ‘The Experts’: By specializing in specific market segments, the brand becomes synonymous with anticipating customers’ needs, and providing them with solutions that exactly meet what they were looking for.

2.????? Resource Efficiencies: Resources are directed exclusively toward the core product, leading to a lower cost of product development, market promotion and operational efficiency.

3.????? Brand Authority: Specialization strengthens the brand's authority within its niche, fostering trust and loyalty among discerning customers.

Disadvantages of Product Specialization:

1.????? Market Sensitivity: Relying on a single product can make the business vulnerable to economic and market fluctuations or shifts in consumer preferences.

2.????? Growth Constraints: Specializing in different market segments may have limited growth potential, constraining expansion opportunities.

3.????? Competition: Intense competition within the market can put pressure on profit margins, necessitating ongoing innovation. This type of strategy is vulnerable to smaller ‘local’ competitors that focus solely on that one market segment, and may have greater insights into customer needs.

Striking the right balance: Choosing the right strategy

Choosing between product diversification and specialization within the same market hinges on a profound understanding of the market dynamics, customer needs, and long-term objectives, in combination with understanding the resources the company has available and is willing to invest.

There is no one-size-fits-all answer – it will depend on the nuances of all of these elements. The strategy may even be a hybrid between diversification and specialization. Caterpillar was focused early on in construction and agriculture heavy machinery equipment. Later they started to specialize this equipment to meet the needs of the mining, forestry and energy markets. These were all new market segments (i.e. a specialist approach), however, it became clear that new products would have to be developed outside their core expertise (product diversification) to meet all the needs of that new market.

The decision between product diversification and specialization within the same market is multifaceted. It should align with the company’s unique goals and resources. By learning from examples and considering the pros and cons, the right strategic path can be chosen, ensuring sustainable growth and profitability for the business.

#strategy #growth #productstrategy #productdiversification #productspecialization