The Great Customer Success Showdown: A 2024 White Paper on CS Platforms
Greg Cullum
VICE PRESIDENT OF CUSTOMER SUCCESS | AWARD-WINNING TECHNOLOGY & SECURITY STRATEGY EXECUTIVE | Proven Customer Success Initiatives ? Innovative Technology Solutions ? Comprehensive Security Strategies
In Which We Compare, Contrast, and Occasionally Chuckle at the Leading Platforms in Customer Success
Introduction: The Wild World of Customer Success
In today’s business world, keeping customers happy isn’t just a "nice-to-have"; it’s a lifeline. While CRM systems handle your sales pipeline, Customer Success platforms handle the more delicate matter of retaining customers and growing accounts through proactive engagement. With so many platforms available, picking the right one can feel like choosing a life raft in a sea of options.
This white paper breaks down the most popular CS platforms—offering analysis with a side of dry wit.
Part 1: The Rankings: Based on What Really Matters
How We Rank Them
We rank these platforms based on the factors that Customer Success professionals actually care about:
?Final Rankings:
1.??? Gainsight CS
2.??? Catalyst
3.??? Totango
4.??? Planhat
5.??? ZapScale
6.??? Salesmachine
7.??? ChurnZero
8.??? ClientSuccess
9.??? Strikedeck
The Bar Graph: Visualizing the Comparison
Before diving into each platform's details, here's a visual comparison showing how these platforms rank based on their features, pricing, and user satisfaction.
1. Gainsight CS: The Swiss Army Knife for Enterprises
Overview: Gainsight is the reigning champion for large enterprises that need a platform as robust as their customer base. With features like AI-driven automation, predictive analytics, and deep CRM integration, Gainsight is built to handle the complex needs of global teams.
Customizability: Gainsight offers more customization options than a pizza menu at an artisan pizzeria. You can tweak health scores, automate customer journeys, and even build custom playbooks. Its Journey Orchestrator lets you map out multi-step customer journeys with automated actions triggered by every movement your customer makes. If you enjoy spending hours fine-tuning your processes, Gainsight will keep you entertained for days. Just be sure to have someone on your team who loves configuring systems.
Integration: Gainsight integrates deeply with Salesforce and ServiceNow, ensuring that your data flows seamlessly across platforms. Its real-time sync with Salesforce keeps your customer health scores up to date, while the ServiceNow integration pulls in support tickets to give your CS team a 360-degree view of the customer.
Simplicity vs. Complexity: Simple? No. Gainsight is a powerhouse that requires dedication and effort. It’s not for the faint of heart (or for small teams without significant resources).
Bottom Line: Gainsight is the Ivy League of Customer Success platforms. If you’re a large enterprise with deep pockets and an even deeper customer base, this is your platform. Just be prepared to invest time (and maybe a therapist) to manage the complexity.
Final Thoughts: Gainsight continues to dominate the enterprise Customer Success market with its comprehensive toolset. However, recent user reviews suggest that the platform’s complexity can be overwhelming for teams without dedicated technical support. Gartner’s latest Magic Quadrant also highlights Gainsight’s leadership, but it notes that the learning curve remains steep for newer users. Gainsight has responded by launching more user-friendly updates, but be prepared for a significant onboarding period.
?
2. Catalyst: For Medium-Sized Businesses Who Want to Look Like Giants
Overview: Catalyst strikes a balance between being powerful enough for medium-sized businesses while remaining user-friendly. It’s perfect for companies that need advanced tools without Gainsight’s complexity.
Customizability: Catalyst offers a level of customization that’s just right—custom health profiles, journey maps, and dashboards can all be tailored to your needs. But unlike Gainsight, Catalyst doesn’t require a PhD in Customer Success to set up. With Journey Mapping, you can design customer journeys specific to your business, trigger automations, and track key stages with ease. Custom dashboards give each team member access to the most relevant data points.
Integration: Catalyst’s native Salesforce integration is seamless, syncing data and workflows between systems without the complexity of larger platforms. Its integration with ServiceNow ensures that tickets are tracked and customer health scores are updated in real time.
Simplicity vs. Complexity: Catalyst is as close to plug-and-play as you can get in this space. It’s intuitive, powerful, and won’t leave you pulling your hair out over configuration.
Bottom Line: If you’re a medium-sized business looking for an easy-to-use platform that still offers customizability, Catalyst is your best bet. It’s like getting an enterprise solution without all the headaches.
Final Thoughts: Catalyst’s user base has grown steadily, especially among medium-sized companies looking for a scalable solution that doesn’t sacrifice ease of use. Reviews from TrustRadius highlight its clean interface and intuitive setup, but some users express a desire for deeper analytics and automation capabilities, which are present in platforms like Gainsight. Recent updates have improved Salesforce integration, and the company has hinted at further enhancements in automation. Catalyst remains a strong option for teams that need to strike a balance between simplicity and power.
?
3. Totango: The “Goldilocks” of Customer Success
Overview: Totango is the Goldilocks solution—not too big, not too small, but just right for startups and mid-sized companies. It’s modular, so you can start small and grow as your company scales.
Customizability: The platform’s SuccessBLOCs are highly customizable, letting you build workflows, automate engagement paths, and set metrics tailored to your business goals. Totango’s modular design means you can start with the basics and scale up without needing a major system overhaul. Journey Building is easy and flexible, allowing you to track where your customers are, what they need, and how to keep them happy.
Integration: Totango integrates with Salesforce and ServiceNow, pulling in customer data to automate workflows and update health scores. As you scale, Totango’s integrations grow with you, ensuring that all your systems are connected.
Simplicity vs. Complexity: Totango is intuitive but still has room to grow. It won’t overwhelm you, but it’s got enough depth to keep pace as your business expands.
Bottom Line: If you’re not quite ready for the enterprise-level complexity of Gainsight but need a platform that will grow with you, Totango is your Goldilocks—just right for scaling businesses.
Final Thoughts: Totango remains a favorite for businesses that need scalability and flexibility. The introduction of AI-driven success indicators has been well-received, giving businesses even more tools to predict customer needs and reduce churn. Users on G2 and Capterra consistently praise its flexibility, but some have noted that the costs increase significantly as you scale, especially for larger businesses that require advanced features. Totango’s modular approach still makes it a top choice for companies seeking a solution that grows with them without requiring a massive overhaul.
?
4. Planhat: The Revenue Geek’s Dream
Overview: If revenue is your main concern (and let’s be honest, it always is), Planhat is the revenue geek’s dream platform. It’s designed for SaaS companies and subscription-based businesses who need to track renewals, upsells, and customer health down to the last dollar.
Customizability: Planhat’s revenue tracking is where it shines. Customizable dashboards let you see exactly how each customer contributes to your bottom line, and its subscription management features allow you to build custom workflows for renewals and upsells. You can customize your customer lifecycle stages and align them with your revenue goals.
Integration: Seamless integration with Salesforce ensures that your revenue data is always in sync, while ServiceNow pulls in ticketing and support data. If you live and breathe recurring revenue, Planhat gives you the tools to do just that.
Simplicity vs. Complexity: Planhat isn’t as complex as Gainsight, but it’s still detailed. If your team is focused on revenue analytics, you’ll appreciate the depth, though it may take a little time to get everything set up just right.
Bottom Line: If subscription management and revenue tracking are your top priorities, Planhat is your platform. It’s detailed enough for serious revenue geeks, but won’t overwhelm you with unnecessary complexity.
Final Thoughts: Planhat continues to focus heavily on revenue tracking and subscription analytics, making it ideal for SaaS and subscription-based businesses. Recent user feedback highlights its powerful reporting capabilities, but also warns of a steep learning curve for teams unfamiliar with deep analytics. Salesforce integration has been a major plus for enterprise users, though smaller teams might find Planhat’s setup process to be more challenging without dedicated technical resources. Overall, Planhat is a powerhouse for businesses with a strong focus on financial performance and recurring revenue management.
?
5. ZapScale: The Automation Guru for Small Teams
Overview: ZapScale is perfect for small to medium-sized businesses that want to automate Customer Success workflows without needing a massive team. It’s built around workflow automation, making it easy to streamline your operations with minimal manual intervention.
Customizability: The platform is built around customizable workflows that allow you to automate tasks based on customer behavior, health scores, and lifecycle stages. You won’t get the in-depth analytics of Gainsight, but you’ll have the power to automate key CS processes and free up your team’s time.
Integration: ZapScale integrates well with Salesforce and ServiceNow, pulling in customer health data and support tickets to ensure your team is always up to date.
Simplicity vs. Complexity: ZapScale is all about simplicity—you won’t need an army of admins to run it, but it will handle a lot of the heavy lifting for you.
Bottom Line: If you need a platform that focuses on automation and won’t bog you down with complexity, ZapScale is your best bet for small to medium-sized businesses.
Final Thoughts: ZapScale continues to shine in the automation space, particularly for small businesses that want to streamline Customer Success processes without investing in large teams. Its recent integrations with Pipedrive and Zoho have been popular among users seeking simpler CRM connections. However, reviews on G2 mention that while ZapScale excels at automation, its reporting and analytics features are relatively basic. For teams focused on automation over deep analytics, ZapScale remains a solid, cost-effective choice.
?
6. Salesmachine: The Bare Necessities of Customer Success
Overview: For startups that need to manage Customer Success on a shoestring budget, Salesmachine offers just enough to get the job done—without any of the unnecessary bells and whistles. It’s the bare necessities platform for small businesses that need essential tools without the complexity or cost of more advanced platforms.
Customizability: Salesmachine provides basic customization options that cover the essentials. You can define customer health scores, set up lifecycle automations, and trigger churn prevention actions when customers exhibit risky behavior. However, if you're looking for deep customization of reports or dashboards, you might find Salesmachine a little light. The reporting is functional but not as detailed as larger platforms. It tracks engagement metrics and customer health, but you won’t be able to slice and dice the data in as many ways as you could with more expensive platforms.
Integration: Salesmachine offers seamless integration with Salesforce, allowing customer data to flow between platforms in real time. You can also integrate with ServiceNow to track support tickets and synchronize those insights with customer health metrics, ensuring your CS team is aware of any issues that may affect retention.
Simplicity vs. Complexity: Salesmachine excels in simplicity. It’s incredibly easy to use, and getting your team up and running takes almost no time. If you’re a startup or small business looking to manage Customer Success without overhauling your entire tech stack, Salesmachine is a great starting point.
Bottom Line: Salesmachine delivers the bare necessities for startups. It’s budget-friendly, straightforward, and covers all the basics without overwhelming you with complexity. For small teams just starting out, it’s a great way to get a handle on Customer Success without a massive investment.
Final Thoughts: Salesmachine has improved its simplicity and ease of use with recent updates that enhance its customer health scoring capabilities. TrustRadius reviews are generally positive, especially for small businesses needing a no-frills platform. However, users mention that as a company scales, Salesmachine’s lack of advanced features becomes more apparent. It’s best suited for startups and small businesses that need to manage essentials without delving into complex configurations or high-cost platforms.
?
7. ChurnZero: The Proactive Retention Expert
Overview: ChurnZero is designed for businesses focused on reducing churn and increasing customer retention through proactive measures. It helps companies predict churn risks and offers engagement tools to prevent it.
Customizability: ChurnZero provides a customizable experience with adaptable dashboards, customer health scoring, and automated workflows that are tailored to specific customer behaviors and engagement levels.
Integration: ChurnZero integrates smoothly with CRM platforms like Salesforce and HubSpot, and also offers native integrations with email marketing tools to facilitate customer engagement campaigns.
Simplicity vs. Complexity: ChurnZero strikes a balance between simplicity and depth. It offers advanced analytics, but its interface remains accessible to users without extensive technical expertise.
Bottom Line: For businesses aiming to tackle churn head-on with proactive strategies, ChurnZero is an excellent tool. It provides in-depth customer insights while remaining manageable for teams of any size.
Final Thoughts: ChurnZero has quickly become a favorite for businesses that prioritize customer retention. The platform’s predictive analytics and automation tools have been praised by users on G2, particularly for their ease of use. However, reviews mention that while ChurnZero excels in churn management, its advanced analytics and reporting capabilities fall short compared to enterprise platforms like Gainsight. Despite this, its competitive pricing and focus on proactive retention make it a strong option for small to mid-sized businesses. Recent updates to customer segmentation and engagement automation have enhanced its value for companies focused on reducing churn.
领英推荐
8. ClientSuccess: Simplicity and Scalability
Overview: ClientSuccess focuses on simplicity and ease of use while offering features that allow for scalability as a business grows. It's particularly useful for mid-sized businesses looking to scale Customer Success operations without added complexity.
Customizability: ClientSuccess is less customizable than some of the more advanced platforms, but it still allows for tailored customer journeys, health scores, and renewal tracking workflows. Its clean interface emphasizes ease of setup.
Integration: ClientSuccess integrates seamlessly with Salesforce and other popular CRMs. It also connects to support platforms like Zendesk, helping companies unify customer communications and keep all teams aligned.
Simplicity vs. Complexity: ClientSuccess is one of the easiest platforms to set up and maintain, making it an ideal solution for companies that need robust Customer Success features without a steep learning curve.
Bottom Line: If you want a platform that offers straightforward, effective Customer Success management with room for growth, ClientSuccess is a strong choice for mid-sized companies.
Final Thoughts: ClientSuccess continues to receive high marks for its simplicity and straightforward interface. Users on TrustRadius appreciate its intuitive setup, though some feel it lacks the depth required for larger businesses with more complex Customer Success needs. Recent updates to renewal management have been positively received, making it easier to track and automate the renewal process. Overall, ClientSuccess is a great choice for medium-sized businesses looking for a platform that prioritizes ease of use while still providing enough flexibility to grow with the company.
?
9. Strikedeck: Flexibility for Enterprise Needs
Overview: Strikedeck is built for enterprise-level organizations that require flexibility and scalability. With a focus on automation and customer journey mapping, Strikedeck is well-suited to companies with complex Customer Success needs.
Customizability: Strikedeck offers highly customizable workflows, dashboards, and health scores. Its automation tools can handle complex customer journey orchestration, allowing teams to build detailed, personalized engagement plans.
Integration: Strikedeck integrates deeply with CRM systems like Salesforce, and offers native API connections for more customized integration with other business systems.
Simplicity vs. Complexity: While Strikedeck offers powerful features, it can be overwhelming for smaller teams due to its complexity. For larger enterprises, however, the platform is a powerful tool for managing customer relationships at scale.
Bottom Line: For enterprises seeking a platform with powerful automation and deep customization options, Strikedeck is a solid choice. Just be prepared to invest in a dedicated team for setup and management.
Final Thoughts: Strikedeck’s latest updates focus on improving AI-driven automation, which has resonated well with its enterprise user base. G2 reviews highlight the platform’s flexibility and the depth of its customer journey mapping tools. However, some users report that without a dedicated Customer Success Operations team, Strikedeck can be challenging to set up and maintain. Its pricing skews towards the higher end, reflecting its enterprise focus, but for large organizations needing powerful automation and journey orchestration, Strikedeck is a worthwhile investment.
?
The Final Decision
Choosing the right Customer Success platform is like finding the perfect pair of shoes: it needs to fit your company’s size, style, and goals. The question isn’t which platform is the best—it’s which platform is best for you.
Choosing the right Customer Success platform is no small feat—especially with so many strong contenders. The addition of ChurnZero, ClientSuccess, and Strikedeck makes the field even more diverse, offering options for businesses of all sizes and needs.
If you’re a large enterprise, Gainsight continues to lead the pack with its deep customization, AI-driven insights, and powerful integration capabilities. However, Strikedeck is a serious contender for enterprises needing flexible automation and workflow capabilities, providing similar depth but with a sharper focus on advanced automation and journey mapping.
For medium-sized businesses, Catalyst and Totango remain excellent options, providing the perfect balance between ease of use and functionality. Meanwhile, ClientSuccess offers a more lightweight, user-friendly option that scales as your business grows, without bogging you down in unnecessary complexity.
When it comes to startups and smaller businesses, ZapScale and Salesmachine offer budget-friendly, streamlined solutions. But don’t overlook ChurnZero, which provides powerful churn management tools that are intuitive and accessible, making it a strong choice for businesses focused on customer retention.
Ultimately, the right platform depends on your company’s size, industry, and growth trajectory. Whether you prioritize automation, customization, or simplicity, there’s a platform that can meet your needs. As always, the final decision should be based on your long-term Customer Success goals—whether you're starting small or scaling to the big leagues.
Part 2: Navigating Platform Growth—Scaling vs. Migrating
As Customer Success teams grow, they often face a tough choice: stick with their current platform and scale it, or migrate to a new, more advanced system. Both approaches come with their own set of challenges, costs, and time commitments. Picking the wrong approach can lead to headaches, wasted time, and an escalating budget. This chapter will explore the real-world effort and costs involved in each scenario, ensuring you have a clear view of the best strategy for your business.
?
Scaling a Single Platform: The Good, the Bad, and the Costs
If you’ve started small but plan to grow, scaling your existing platform may seem like the most straightforward solution. And it can be! Some platforms, like Totango, Catalyst, ChurnZero, ClientSuccess, and ZapScale, are designed to grow with you. However, scaling is not without its challenges and costs.
?
1. When You’re Small But Thinking Big (Totango, Catalyst, ChurnZero, ClientSuccess, ZapScale)
Let’s say you’re a small team using Totango, Catalyst, ChurnZero, ClientSuccess, or ZapScale. These platforms are built to scale as you do, allowing you to start with basic features and expand as your needs grow. However, don’t assume that scaling is as simple as flipping a switch—it requires effort and planning.
Effort
Initial Setup: Even with a small team, the setup process can take 4-6 weeks. You’ll need to configure customer health scores, automate processes, and train your team. If you lack a dedicated Customer Success Operations person, you may need to bring in a consultant to help. Platforms like ClientSuccess and ZapScale are easier to set up, but as you grow, customization becomes more demanding, especially with ChurnZero and Catalyst.
Ongoing Scaling: As your business grows, so do your needs. Each expansion—whether it’s adding new automations, updating customer segments, or fine-tuning customer journeys—requires additional time and resources. For example, Totango’s modular SuccessBLOCs make scaling easy, but keeping everything fine-tuned as you expand requires consistent attention. ChurnZero, with its strong churn prevention focus, offers excellent retention tools, but growing requires adapting more sophisticated features, which takes time.
Costs
Subscription Fees: The basic features for Totango, Catalyst, ChurnZero, ClientSuccess, and ZapScale typically range from $50 to $200 per user per month. However, as you scale, these costs can jump to $500-$1000 per user per month, depending on the number of users and additional features.
Scaling Costs: Growing within these platforms will result in increased costs. For instance, moving from a small team to a mid-sized one on Totango or Catalyst may require an additional $5,000 to $10,000 annually. ChurnZero has a pricing model designed to remain manageable for growing businesses, but ClientSuccess can involve extra costs if you need to integrate third-party tools for advanced capabilities.
Operational Costs: As complexity grows, so does the need for resources. You may need to hire a full-time Customer Success Ops person ($100k+ salary) or rely on external consultants ($100-$250 per hour) to manage your evolving needs.
?
2. When You Hit the Big Leagues (Gainsight, Planhat, Strikedeck)
For large businesses or enterprises, scaling beyond mid-tier platforms like Catalyst, Totango, or ChurnZero often means transitioning to heavyweight platforms such as Gainsight, Planhat, or Strikedeck. These platforms are built to handle the complex needs of large teams, but scaling them is no easy feat.
Effort
Customization: Gainsight is known for its deep customization options, such as AI-driven health scores and predictive analytics. Setting up these features can take anywhere from 6 to 12 months. Planhat offers robust revenue tracking, but the initial setup can take time, especially for companies unfamiliar with advanced subscription analytics. Strikedeck, with its focus on flexible automation, also demands significant effort to configure advanced workflows and automations.
Integration: Large businesses often require seamless integration with Salesforce, ServiceNow, and other critical business systems. Integrating data from these systems into Gainsight, Planhat, or Strikedeck is not plug-and-play; it can take another 2-3 months to fully sync data and ensure workflows run smoothly.
Costs
Licensing: The enterprise-level platforms—Gainsight, Planhat, and Strikedeck—typically range from $1,500 to $3,000 per user per month. Multiply that by a large team, and you're easily looking at over $200,000 annually. Strikedeck is similarly priced but offers flexibility in automation, making it worth the cost for complex enterprises.
Customization Costs: Customization and integration for these platforms don’t come cheap. Expect to spend $50,000-$100,000 to set up everything, especially if you need to hire external consultants. Planhat can be particularly expensive to configure if your team is unfamiliar with subscription and revenue tracking models.
Ongoing Support: You’ll need dedicated personnel to manage these platforms once they’re up and running. Hiring a full-time Customer Success Ops person to handle Gainsight, Planhat, or Strikedeck could cost over $100k per year, or you may opt to keep consultants on call for $100-$300 an hour.
?
Migrating to a New Platform: Painful But Sometimes Necessary
At some point, you may find that your current platform can no longer meet your growing needs. Whether you’ve outgrown Salesmachine, ZapScale, or ClientSuccess, migrating to a mid-tier or enterprise platform can be a challenging but necessary step.
1. Moving from Small Platforms (Salesmachine, ZapScale, ClientSuccess) to Mid-Tier (Catalyst, Totango, ChurnZero)
Effort
Data Migration: While Salesmachine and ZapScale are lightweight platforms, migrating data isn’t always simple. You’ll need to export everything from your current system, reformat it, and import it into your new platform. This process can take 4-6 weeks, and if your team lacks the necessary technical skills, you may need external help.
Team Training: Once the data migration is complete, your team will need to be trained on the new platform. This typically requires 2-3 weeks of training, especially for platforms like Totango, Catalyst, or ChurnZero, which offer more advanced features.
Costs
Setup Costs: Migrating from Salesmachine, ZapScale, or ClientSuccess to Catalyst, Totango, or ChurnZero can cost anywhere from $10,000 to $30,000, depending on the complexity of your data and system requirements.
Data Migration Costs: Cleaning and importing data can run another $5,000-$15,000, depending on how much historical data you have and its condition.
Training Costs: Bringing in external trainers to get your team up to speed on the new platform will cost $2,000-$5,000, depending on the size of your team and the amount of training required.
2. Upgrading from Mid-Tier to Enterprise (Catalyst, Totango, ChurnZero to Gainsight, Planhat, Strikedeck)
Effort
Data Reorganization: If you’re migrating from Catalyst, Totango, or ChurnZero to Gainsight, Planhat, or Strikedeck, expect a full data overhaul. You’ll need to reformat customer data, reconfigure workflows, and re-establish reports in the new system. This process can take 2-3 months.
New Automations: Gainsight and Strikedeck require significant time to configure their advanced automations and workflows. Customization will need careful planning to get the most out of the new system.
Team Realignment: Larger platforms require more team members or a significantly retrained team. You’ll need to adjust your personnel strategy accordingly to manage the new system effectively.
Costs
Setup Costs: Getting Gainsight, Planhat, or Strikedeck up and running can cost anywhere from $50,000 to $150,000, depending on your requirements and the level of customization you need.
Data Migration Costs: Moving your data from a mid-tier system into an enterprise-level platform can cost between $20,000 and $50,000. It’s essential to invest in a thorough data migration to avoid months of delays and incorrect data insights.
Training and Support Costs: Training your team on an enterprise-level system like Gainsight or Strikedeck can cost between $5,000 and $15,000. Consider these platforms’ complexity when planning your training sessions.
?
Conclusion: Weighing the Costs
Deciding whether to scale or migrate your Customer Success platform comes down to your company’s size, growth trajectory, and long-term goals. If you're a small but ambitious company, starting with a scalable platform like Totango, Catalyst, ChurnZero, or ClientSuccess is your best bet. These platforms will grow with you, saving you from the headache of a future migration. However, if you're already mid-sized and have your sights set on enterprise, be prepared for the significant investment—both financially and in terms of time—that comes with platforms like Gainsight, Planhat, and Strikedeck.
Whatever path you choose, remember to budget not only for the platform itself but for the inevitable bumps along the way. Whether you’re scaling or migrating, Customer Success is a journey—one that requires the right tools for your specific needs.
?
A Last Thought: Success is a Journey, Not a Destination
Whether you’re just starting out or scaling up to the big leagues, the right platform is out there. And once you’ve got it, you’ll be one step closer to keeping your customers engaged, happy, and loyal for the long haul.
Now, go forth, and may your churn rate be ever in your favor.