Good to Great Behavioral Interviews

Good to Great Behavioral Interviews

Michael Lewis’ new book– The Undoing Project– focuses on the work of Israeli psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky. The basic premise behind the book: Our ability to accurately forecast events or future behavior is skewed by outside biases which we might not recognize. When we render a prediction of success– whether it’s selecting an athlete in the NFL draft or a candidate for our company– we rely too much on the most recent or vivid events, accepted practices and legacy influences (think Moneyball). 

While that might work some of the time, Kahneman and Tversky’s research demonstrates it’s far less predictable than given credit for. An example: first-round NFL draft picks that turn out to be journeyman players– or in some cases, outright busts– while a fourth-round pick for the Dallas Cowboys (Dak Prescott) becomes the NFL Rookie of the Year.  (Full disclosure: as a lifelong Cowboys fan, I had to work that into this article. No apologies.)

What does this have to do with interviewing candidates? Well, I’ve been trying to connect the dots from this book with how companies make hiring decisions. Initially, it appeared the studies contradicted Behavioral Interviewing methodology. However, after reading some of the chapters (more than once), here’s my take: Behavioral Interviewing methodology is potentially incomplete without understanding the context surrounding the answers. 

Asking “Tell me about a time…” moves from a good to great question when you understand the candidate’s work environment: how his/her department is structured; where he/she fits in the overall organization; what support or resources are provided (or not).  The point: without taking time to understand these variables the Hiring Manager is taking a leap of faith with incomplete information. 

So, what’s the most efficient way to accomplish this? 

Start by asking candidates to describe where they fit in their organization– an organization chart, so to speak. This helps both parties– company and candidate– compare “apples to apples” and establishes the foundation for questions that follow. As a result, the Hiring Manager gains a much richer understanding of the candidate’s answers to behavioral questions.    

Credits: Gary Williamson, Ph.D and Managing Parter: PSP Metrics

Laura Albright, MBA

Management Consultant at RealFoundations

8 年

You hit the nail on the head here, Rodney!

回复
Will C.

Southeast/Mid-Atlantic Acquisitions and Asset Management with a focus on value-add and operational enhancement

8 年

That's a great insight. When people have (or are applying) to a position with a generic and non-discript title, knowing how that role is perceived within the company is important. Knowing the levels of oversight and the responsibilities those roles required is key to the context you're asking about.

回复
Cam Kicklighter

CEO - Resort Synergy Group

8 年

Great article Rodney and excellent advice. I read the Undoing Project and highly recommend it.Leave your thoughts here…

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Rodney Hall的更多文章

  • Four challenges one company is facing as employees return to work

    Four challenges one company is facing as employees return to work

    A client began re-populating their offices in June. It didn't take long for issues to arise.

    4 条评论
  • Back to Work Best Practices

    Back to Work Best Practices

    “In these uncertain times, how you treat your employees will be remembered for years to come. How business owners…

  • The Naked Interview

    The Naked Interview

    In his business book "Getting Naked", Patrick Lencioni advocates for transparency and authenticity as the foundation…

    1 条评论
  • Three Simple Tips to quickly improve your Interview Process

    Three Simple Tips to quickly improve your Interview Process

    These three simple tips will greatly improve your ability to understand and assess candidates. In advance of the…

  • PTO: the new currency in Job Offers

    PTO: the new currency in Job Offers

    In recent years we’ve seen Paid Time Off (PTO) rise in importance to candidates considering a job change– not far…

    4 条评论
  • Should I stay or should I go?

    Should I stay or should I go?

    The decision to make a job change can be one of the more stressful experiences a career-minded professional makes…

    1 条评论
  • Seen & Heard at PCBC 2018

    Seen & Heard at PCBC 2018

    We spent four days at PCBC and heard from industry thought leaders, saw many friends and associates and enjoyed some…

    2 条评论
  • Recruiter Confidential: What We're Seeing From Our Side of the Desk.

    Recruiter Confidential: What We're Seeing From Our Side of the Desk.

    Reaching candidates is much more difficult. Response rates to our outreach efforts– calls, emails, LinkedIn, etc.

    1 条评论
  • Amenities that deliver best ROI?

    Amenities that deliver best ROI?

    Last November I posed this question on LinkedIn: "What amenities deliver the best ROI in a residential development?"…

    2 条评论
  • Dog Catches Job Offer

    Dog Catches Job Offer

    Candidates weighing a job change often experience uncertainty and indecision once an offer is made, even after ardently…

    7 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了