Gen Z Struggles Are Not Related To Interest Rates

Gen Z Struggles Are Not Related To Interest Rates

I was reading a post in Recruitonomics that said, that GenZ is struggling to find solid work and has higher unemployment than older generations because interest rates are higher. I don't think that is the right conclusion to draw from the data.

Younger workers are less experienced, automation and AI are changing the nature of entry-level roles and many 20-somethings are still trying to figure out what they want to do and tend to hop around a bit. Unemployment in this group has pretty much been consistently higher than other groups regardless of interest rates.

Each one of these factors confounds early career opportunities and when you put them all together, it makes sense that there would be less employment here. Additionally, GenZ is -globally speaking - the largest of current working-age generations in the workforce. So there are more people overall looking for work, which is going to have an effect on the rate of participation in the workforce and unemployment rate.

  1. Lack of Experience: Younger workers often have limited work experience, making it difficult for them to compete with more seasoned candidates. This lack of experience doesn't help them and employers hiring for roles that require immediate proficiency are going to look for someone with experience if they have the choice.
  2. Automation of Entry-Level Jobs: I don't know how prime-time AI agents are yet, but basic automation through software and robotics has started to reduce the number of people companies need to hire. Many entry-level positions, particularly those involving routine or low-skill tasks, are increasingly susceptible to automation. Studies suggest that artificial intelligence could eliminate a significant percentage of entry-level jobs soon, underscoring the need for upskilling among young workers.
  3. Job-Hopping Tendencies: Younger employees may change jobs more frequently as they explore different career paths and seek better opportunities. This tendency can lead to perceptions of instability, making employers hesitant to invest in training and development for these workers.

Another possible connection here that is a drag on GenZ is the pandemic. Which fundamentally changed things for this group. School was dramatically different, if you were graduating in 2020 or 2021 you were walking into a terrible market. If you were in school, might have had delays, you might have left school or it might have taken longer to graduate, so those folks are not ready for corporate life. Also, a factor to consider..remote work was on the rise and now it's not, and those positions might not be coming back.

There are other trends at work here too. Companies are using gig work and contingent workers more. Why hire full-time people when I can get things done for less cost & less risk? Jobs to be done today - that might have been internship level in the past - are fewer, in part because of this trend.

I accept that elevated interest rates could influence hiring practices by increasing the cost of borrowing for businesses, but I don't think you can draw such a strong causal connection. Overall economic indicators, such as GDP show growth, regardless of the increased interest rates. Factors such as lack of experience, automation of entry-level roles, and job-hopping behaviors are primary contributors to the employment challenges is well-supported by existing research.


Steve McClenon

Enterprise Solution Consultant at ADP Advisor | Teacher

1 个月

You've made great observation. I too "...accept that elevated interest rates could influence hiring practices by increasing the cost of borrowing for businesses, but I don't think you can draw such a strong causal connection" that the points of lack of experience, AI, and job hopping tendencies play a bigger role than is discussed.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Jesse Ofner的更多文章

  • Breaking Systems Is Hard

    Breaking Systems Is Hard

    Students of medical history will be familiar with the name Ignaz Semmelweis, but for many others, his story remains…

  • It's a System

    It's a System

    All things are systems. And systems like the status quo.

  • Never Say This

    Never Say This

    "I didn't think that THIS could happen", has often been uttered in the aftermath of some unlikely or even likely event…

  • Playing With A Chip on Your Shoulder

    Playing With A Chip on Your Shoulder

    In early summer 2024, before USA Basketball had announced the Women’s Basketball roster, there was a buzz of…

    1 条评论
  • Should Corporations Have Values?

    Should Corporations Have Values?

    Ever since he who must not be named won the US election, I've seen a host of business leaders and corporations doing…

  • Ways to Lower Your Recruitment Costs

    Ways to Lower Your Recruitment Costs

    It's hard to define the economy right now. A wide variety of opinions and ideas on what is or is not going to happen…

  • Be grateful, even for the bad stuff

    Be grateful, even for the bad stuff

    I think I posted a while back related to an article or post I had read about how sometimes you don't want to be…

    1 条评论
  • Presence

    Presence

    As part of Daily Stoic's New Years challenge, we were asked to pick a word that would be our word for the year. After…

  • On Meditation

    On Meditation

    Around oh say 2015/2016 I started getting more interested in Meditation. More and more people were talking about it as…

  • This is most of what I'm listening to

    This is most of what I'm listening to

    What you give your attention to is what will determine the quality of your life and thinking. Be mindful of what you…

    1 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了