The Future of Right to Repair: Empowering Consumers and Manufacturers
The Selling Circular Podcast
Navigating the future of business through circular economy insights, strategies, and success stories.
Starting October 2nd, Selling Circular will continue to bring our audience new circular economy focused articles and interviews from our favorite and most enlightening industry peers and colleagues. Subscribe here for more articles and on your preferred podcasting app for full episode interviews.
The following article was written using excerpts from the podcast video embedded below. Enjoy!
The right to repair movement has gained significant momentum in recent years, as consumers push for greater ability to fix and maintain the products they own. This grassroots effort aims to combat planned obsolescence, reduce electronic waste, and give people more control over their devices. But as the movement grows, it faces pushback from manufacturers and raises complex questions about product design, intellectual property, and business models.
The Origins and Growth of Right to Repair
The right to repair concept is not new - people have been fixing their own possessions for as long as products have existed. But as modern electronics and appliances have become more complex and integrated, DIY repairs have become increasingly difficult.?
Many manufacturers have restricted access to parts, tools, and repair information, pushing consumers to rely on authorized repair services or simply replace broken items.
In response, the right to repair movement emerged to advocate for laws and policies that would require companies to make repair resources more available, however, brands were willing to pivot and pilot on various initiatives. As Liz Chamberlain of iFixit explained: "Right to repair legislation was going to pass and they introduced a self repair program.” Essentially, “this is coming down the pike and we have to figure out how to make this work."
The movement has seen significant victories in recent years. In 2022, New York became the first state to pass a comprehensive right to repair law. The European Union has led the right to repair regulations since 2009 with the Biden administration of the United States directing the FTC to crack down on unfair repair restrictions as early as 2021.
Benefits for Consumers and the Environment
Proponents argue that right to repair offers numerous benefits for consumers and society:
The benefits toward manufacturers are not as well studied and fear of new product sales cannibalization often overshadows the potential to drive long-term, multi-channel repair sales opportunities. Chamberlain noted: "When people can repair their stuff, they become very loyal to a brand. We've found in surveys that the manufacturers we've worked know that when things last, people do buy it again.”?
Right to repair policies can also contribute to sustainability goals by keeping products in use longer, helping avoid further supply chain complications and resource scarcity issues. Chamberlain continued: "We can't keep mining and manufacturing as much as we are. The world just can't support it. So we need to find another way."
Challenges and Pushback from Manufacturers
Many manufacturers have resisted right to repair efforts, citing concerns about:
These are legitimate complexities to navigate. As products become more sophisticated, repairs often require specialized tools and expertise and manufacturers argue that improper repairs could compromise safety or functionality. Additionally, some companies' business models rely heavily on repair services or frequent product upgrades. Expanding repair options could disrupt these revenue streams.
The Path Forward
Despite the challenges, the right to repair movement is popular and continues to gain traction. More states and countries are likely to pass repair-friendly legislation in the coming years with some forward-thinking companies embracing repairability as a selling point. Chamberlain highlighted: "We just announced with Lenovo a laptop that scored a 9.3 repairability score out of 10. They worked with us to help make sure that you can replace the keyboard. They actually have replaceable RAM now, which hasn't been a thing in laptops for many years."
As the movement progresses, key developments to watch include:
Finding a Balance
Ultimately, the future of the right to repair movement will likely involve finding a balance between consumer rights, environmental concerns, and business interests. Thoughtful policy and industry collaboration can help address manufacturers' concerns while still expanding repair options. In the view of iFixit, “we believe that the best way to fight entropy is not to stomp on manufacturers, but to find the people within their doors that really are enthusiastic about making a better world and there are a lot of them."
By working together, we can create a future where products are built to last, repairs are accessible and affordable, and consumers have real choices in how to maintain their devices. This vision of repairability and sustainability has the potential to benefit people, businesses, and the planet.