From Trust to Deception: Navigating the World of Financial Frauds

In a world driven by money and trust, the threat of deceit and manipulation looms large. Financial fraud has the power to disrupt economies, devastate businesses, and shatter lives. From high-profile scandals that make headlines to the subtle schemes that quietly erode fortunes, the landscape of financial fraud is ever evolving and increasingly sophisticated. We gather to shed light on this pervasive issue, to understand the tactics employed by fraudsters, and to explore the critical strategies for prevention and detection. This paper tries to uncover the secrets of financial fraud and empower ourselves with knowledge to protect our interests in an ever-changing financial landscape.

?

What is Financial Fraud?

Financial fraud refers to the intentional deception or manipulation of financial information or transactions with the aim of gaining an unfair advantage, usually for personal or organizational financial gain. It involves deceitful or illegal activities that distort the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of financial records, statements, or reports. Financial fraud can be committed by individuals, businesses, or even within complex financial systems

?

It is difficult to give one exhaustive definition of financial fraud. One may define financial fraud as an illegal act intended to deprive you of your money for personal gains. Financial fraud means:

·??????The intentional act of deception involving financial transactions for personal gains.

·??????Taking money/other assets from someone through deception.

·??????Illegal and unethical management of financial resources.

·??????Manipulation, falsification alteration of accounting records.

·??????Misrepresentation or intentional omission of amounts, misapplication of accounting principles, and marking misleading or false disclosures.

Typically, there exists an element of deceit, subterfuge, or abuse of a position of trust in cases of financial fraud.?

?

Examples of financial fraud can include:

1.????Ponzi schemes

?In this type of fraud, the clients are promised huge profits with little to no risk. The focus of the fraudster companies is on attracting new clients whose investments are then used to pay off earlier investors. Once the flow of money by way of investments from new clients stops, the whole scheme falls apart.

For instance, in 1920, Charles Ponzi made approximately $15 million in about 8 months by convincing lenders that he could make them rich with investments in international postal reply coupons.?

2.????Pyramid schemes

Also known as a chain referral scheme, a pyramid scheme is a fraudulent business model wherein members are recruited with their payments tied to their ability to enrol new members. As the membership expands, there comes a point where further recruitment becomes impossible which consequently makes the whole thing unsustainable. A pyramid scheme might appear as legitimate multi-level marketing (MLM) practice. But the scheme involves no legitimate sales as the earlier investors are paid from the funds received from new investors. There is no product sold and there are no true profits.

?

The Speak Asia Scam is one example of the fraud committed through a pyramid scheme. A Singapore based company Speak Asia Online Ltd. asked investors to pay Rs. 11,000 and fill up online surveys to earn Rs. 52,000 a year. The company promised additional rewards for those who enrolled other people into the scheme. The fraudsters made away with Rs. 2,276 crores from 24 lakh investors.

3.????Identity theft and identity fraud

In simple terms, identity theft is the use of someone’s identifying information without their permission. Identity theft occurs when someone steals your personal financial information such as your bank account number by way of deception and uses that information for economic gain. This can happen in a number of ways, say in a public place via shoulder-surfing wherein a fraudster catches you typing your CVV code into your phone, etc., or when you opt to reply to a spam email that promises you a reward but first asks for identifying information and personal details. Identity theft can be committed simply by guessing your passwords or accessing your details from your social media or it might involve complex methods such as installing malware, etc. Your personal data such as bank account number or credit card number is then used to make fraudulent withdrawals from your account. Fraudsters might use your information to open a credit account in your name leaving you liable for the charges. Identity theft leads to identity fraud when the fraudster impersonates you using your stolen information in order to access accounts and obtain financial services.?

Examples of identity theft include theft of ATM card, stealing your bank information and example of identity fraud includes making fake ID, passport, false credit card etc. and using it for personal unlawful gains.

4.????Embezzlement

Embezzlement refers to the act of stealing, misappropriation, or retention of funds by a person who has been entrusted with those funds by an employer or an organisation. Typically, the person who embezzles money is the one who has legal access to another person’s money or funds such as an employee. This white-collar crime is seen as a form of property theft. Examples of embezzlement can be overbilling of customers, forging of cheques, refusal of the conductor to issue tickets to customers after collecting the fare etc.?

5.????Tax fraud

Tax fraud refers to the falsification of tax returns in order to evade the payment of tax to the government. For example, claiming false deductions by classifying personal expenditure as business expenditure or non-disclosure of income. When you pay less tax than what is due by hiding or understating or false reporting of your income, you are committing tax fraud.

6.????Credit card fraud

Credit card fraud is the unauthorised use of someone’s credit card. Credit card numbers can be obtained through credit card theft or unsecured internet connections or by hacking into your system etc. It is advised that in case you lose your credit card or debit card, you should get your card cancelled immediately. Examples of credit card fraud include counterfeit and skimming frauds, card not received frauds, lost and stolen credit card fraud and incorrect card application fraud etc.

7.????Insurance fraud

Insurance fraud occurs when a claimant wrongfully tries to obtain a claim from the insurance company that he is not entitled to or when the insurance company deliberately denies the claim legally due to the claimant. Insurance fraud can also occur in other forms such as selling policies from fake insurance companies, falsifying the medical history, impersonating other people for claims, cause of death being changed for accidental claims, etc.

8.????KYC fraud

In this type of fraud, fraudsters usually send you an unsolicited SMS saying that your card or account will be blocked. The customer in a state of panic ends up responding to the message without considering its legitimacy. Now when you/customer calls that number given in the message, the fraudster pretends to be speaking from your bank and entices you to give your personal details such as debit card information, bank account details, OTP, etc. under the pretext of KYC verification. Sometimes, the fraudster might ask you to install some app on your phone which will give him full access to your phone. Before you know, withdrawals are made from your account and you will get a message that such and such amount has been debited from your account.

9.????Phishing

This is an online scam wherein the users/customers receive tricky emails or pop-ups that appear to be from a legitimate source, say a bank or an insurance company or an internet service provider, etc. The fraudster will ask for your personal information through these emails and thereafter use that information for their unlawful gains. Phishing attacks include phishing emails, link manipulation, session hijacking, smishing, vishing, installing malware etc.?

10.?Advance fee scams

In advance fee scams, the fraudster will ask you to make an advance payment or upfront payment for goods and services that do not materialise. This includes career opportunity fraud, loan scams, lottery scams, work-from-home opportunity scams, etc.

?

11.?Mortgage fraud

Mortgage fraud is any sort of material misstatement, misrepresentation, or omission relating to the property or potential mortgage relied on by an underwriter or lender to fund, purchase, or insure a loan. For example, intentionally falsifying the particulars on mortgage applications.

12.?Bank fraud

Banking fraud is an attempt to syphon or take funds or other assets from a financial institution. RBI defines fraud as,?“A deliberate act of omission or commission by any person, carried out in the course of a banking transaction or the books of accounts maintained manually or under computer system in banks, resulting into wrongful gain to any person for a temporary period or otherwise, with or without any monetary loss to the bank”.?Some of the famous bank fraud cases are the PNB-Nirav Modi Scam, ABG Shipyard Fraud, Vijay Mallya scam etc.

13.?UPI-related frauds

About 80,000 UPI frauds occur in India, every month. Fraudsters send you a ‘request money’ link and once you click on it and authorise the transaction, money gets deducted from your account. Also, sometimes the fraudsters will send you a fake URL and once you click on it, it infects your phone with malware designed to steal all your financial information. UPI-related frauds can occur in forms of phishing attacks, screen mirroring tools and through deceptive UPI handles.

14.?Corporate fraud

Corporate fraud involves falsification or misrepresentation or hiding of a company’s financial information and accounts to make profits illegally and to mislead the public. For example, insider trading, falsification of accounts to show a healthy picture in order to attract lenders and investors, misappropriation of assets, etc.

15.?Securities Fraud

Misleading investors or manipulating securities markets by providing false or misleading information about investments, insider trading, market manipulation, or Ponzi schemes.

16.?Mortgage Fraud:

Misrepresenting or falsifying information on mortgage applications, appraisals, or other documents to obtain loans or properties under false pretences.

17.?Insurance Fraud

Deliberately deceiving insurers by providing false information or making fraudulent insurance claims to receive undeserved insurance pay-outs.

18.?Money Laundering

Concealing the origins of illegally obtained funds by making them appear as legitimate through a series of transactions, making it difficult to trace the illicit proceeds.

?

Financial fraud can have significant consequences, including financial losses for individuals, organizations, or investors, erosion of public trust, legal penalties, reputational damage, and economic instability. Detecting and preventing financial fraud often involves robust internal controls, diligent auditing, regulatory oversight, and compliance with legal and ethical standards.?

?

?

?

?

?

?

?

“From Courtrooms to Convictions: Exploring Landmark Case Laws of Financial Fraud"

?

In the realm of financial fraud, landmark case laws have played a pivotal role in shaping legal precedents and setting significant benchmarks in the pursuit of justice. These cases have served as cautionary tales, exposing the intricate webs woven by fraudsters and illuminating the dire consequences of their actions. From high-profile scandals to complex Ponzi schemes, these landmark cases have not only captured public attention but also guided legal frameworks and enforcement strategies. They have showcased the resilience of the legal system in unravelling sophisticated fraud schemes and holding accountable those who engage in deceptive practices for personal gain. By examining these notable cases, we gain invaluable insights into the evolving nature of financial fraud and the vital role of case laws in safeguarding financial integrity

?

·??????Enron Scandal

One of the largest corporate fraud cases of the 21st century is Enron, dubbed "America's Most Innovative Company" by Fortune magazine every year from 1996 to 2001. Formed in 1985, the former dot-com supernova made a fortune trading natural gas and other commodities and even rolled out its own digital commodity trading platform in 1999.

In August 2000, Enron shares reached a high of $90, but only a year later Sherron Watkins, an Enron finance executive, warned CEO Ken Lay that a massive accounting scandal was brewing that could take down the entire company.

Amidst SEC inquiries into its finances, in November 2001 Enron admitted it overstated profits by nearly $600 million. Within roughly two months, the company declared bankruptcy and the Justice Department launched a criminal investigation of Enron. Before announcing the bankruptcy, Enron cut 4,000 jobs, and many ex-employees saw their pension plans drained.

The one upside to the Enron saga it was the passage of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, which established stricter accounting rules for public companies.

?

?

·??????Bernie Madoff

The Bernie Madoff accounting scandal remains one of the most shameful events in the history of the financial industry. For at least 17 years, Bernard Lawrence “Bernie” Madoff operated a Ponzi scheme that bilked 37,011 investors out of tens of billions of dollars.

?

?

Madoff founded his first investment company in 1960 at the age of 22. He was instrumental in promoting electronic trading systems, and by the late 1980s, he was earning about $100 million a year. Madoff served as chairman of the Nasdaq stock market in 1990, 1991 and 1993.

The Ponzi scheme Madoff perpetrated paid early investors “profits” that were actually sums that more recent investors had given him to invest. Like all Ponzi schemes, the incoming investments eventually failed to cover the fake profits that previous investors came to expect. Rather than investing the money he received from clients, Madoff deposited it in banks and pocketed as much as $483 million in interest.

Investors Carl Shapiro, Jeffry Picower, Stanley Chais and Norm Levy were longtime associates of Madoff’s who each received hundreds of millions of dollars as a result of Madoff’s crimes; several other investment-fund managers whose greed was greater than their ethics were also longtime associates of Madoff’s.

It wasn’t until 2005 that Markopolos was able to convince the SEC of Madoff’s crimes until which it was ignored. In 2009, Madoff was sentenced to 150 years in prison and required to forfeit $170 billion. By December 2008, $2.7 billion had been repaid to the victims of Madoff’s. In 2020, Madoff requested compassionate release due to failing health but was denied; he passed away in prison on April 14, 2021.

?

·??????WorldCom

The WorldCom case, also known as the WorldCom accounting scandal, was a significant financial fraud case that unfolded in 2002. WorldCom was a telecommunications company based in the United States and was at that time one of the largest long-distance phone service providers in the country.

The fraud at WorldCom involved the manipulation of financial statements to inflate the company's earnings and hide expenses. The primary method used was the improper capitalization of costs, where ordinary operating expenses were classified as long-term investments or assets. By doing so, WorldCom was able to overstate its profits and give the appearance of financial stability.

The fraud came to light when an internal auditor at WorldCom, Cynthia Cooper, discovered irregularities while investigating certain accounting entries. She brought her concerns to the company's management, but when her concerns were not adequately addressed, she eventually informed the board of directors.

Following the disclosure of the fraud, WorldCom filed for bankruptcy in July 2002, which was at that time the largest bankruptcy filing in U.S. history. The scandal had a significant impact on the telecommunications industry and sent shockwaves through the financial markets, exacerbating the decline in investor confidence following the dot-com bubble burst.

The WorldCom case resulted in multiple legal actions, including civil lawsuits and criminal charges against key executives involved in the fraud. In 2005, former WorldCom CEO Bernard

Ebbers was found guilty of fraud, conspiracy, and filing false documents with regulators. He was sentenced to 25 years in prison.

The case also led to regulatory reforms, such as the passage of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act in 2002. This legislation aimed to strengthen corporate governance, enhance financial reporting standards, and improve the oversight of publicly traded companies.

The WorldCom case serves as a prominent example of corporate accounting fraud and the repercussions that can arise when ethical boundaries are crossed in the pursuit of financial gain. It highlights the importance of transparency, integrity, and effective corporate governance in maintaining trust and stability within the financial markets.?

·??????Satyam Computer (2006-2008)

Satyam Computer Services Ltd. was founded in the year 1987 by Ramalinga Raju and his brother Rama Raju and soon the company became a significant IT player from India.Also called the mother of all scams, Satyam Computers Scam broke in the year 2009 when the founder and CEO of Satyam Computers, Ramalinga Raju confessed that the company has been falsifying its accounts and overstating its revenues for years.?On January 7, 2009, Ramalinga Raju sent a 5-page letter to the SEBI and stock exchanges admitting a fraud of Rs. 7000 crores. The company committed fraud by overstating its revenues, forging bank statements, and manipulating the books by non-inclusion of certain receipts. Over the period of 5-6 years, the company’s revenue was overstated by Rs. 4783 crores and as per the SEBI’s probe, misstatements to the tune of Rs. 12,320 crores were found. On April 9, 2015, the CBI Special Court sentenced Ramalinga Raju and 9 others to imprisonment for 7 years. A fine of Rs. 5.5 crores was imposed on the Raju brothers.

·?????Harshad Mehta Scam 1992

The man behind the massive Securities Scam in 1992 was the well-known and experienced stockbroker, Mr. Harshad Shantilal Mehta from India . Being a skilled broker, Harshad Mehta misused his knowledge of the stock market to cause manipulations and made huge profits. The scam involved the diversion of bank funds worth Rs 3,500 crore to a group of stockbrokers, led by none other than Harshad Mehta. These funds were then put into the stock market selectively, causing it to surge to over 4,500 points.?The scam was first exposed by journalist Sucheta Dalal in April 1992.Thereafter, the banks realised that they were holding on to worthless bank receipts and the stock market too came crashing down. Harshad Mehta was charged with about 72 criminal offences including cheating, bribery, forgery, criminal conspiracy, falsification of accounts, etc., and over 600 civil suits were initiated against him. In September 1999, the Bombay High Court convicted Harshad Mehta and three others in an Rs. 380.97 million MUL fraud case (one of the many cases within the larger scam) and they were sentenced to rigorous imprisonment of 5 years. Harshad Mehta was out on bail in all cases including his conviction in the MUL The SEC first began investigating Madoff in 1999. In 2000, financial analyst Harry Markopolos filed a whistleblower case. But later, he was again arrested in 2001?for misappropriating Rs 2.5 billion from 2.7 million “missing shares” of 90 blue-chip companies.?This time bail was denied to him. On 31st December 2001, Harshad Mehta passed away in Tihar Jail. His appeal against conviction in the MUL case was dismissed in 2003 and the rest of the criminal cases against him abated on his death.

·??????DanskeBank Scam

Danske Bank money laundering scandal is one of the largest money laundering scandals in European history. It began in 2007 following the acquisition from Danske Bank of Finnish Sampo Bank, which also had an Estonian branch. Between 2007 and 2015 over €200bn of suspicious transactions originating from Russia, former Soviet states and elsewhere flowed through its Estonian branch non-resident portfolio. Danske Bank stock price has been declining since March 2017 when the newspaper Berlingske first issued a series of articles on money laundering claims resulting in a significant destruction of shareholder value. Media reports widely misinterpreted the €200bn figure as representing entirely money laundering rather than a combination of legal and illicit transactions.

In September 2018, Danske Bank admitted that its procedures for oversight failed completely in this case and that its money laundering controls in Estonia has been insufficient. As a result, the CEO and the Chairman of the Board of Directors stepped down and a number of employees both at the Estonian branch and at Group level were found not in compliance with legal obligations forming part of their employment with the bank and therefore dismissed. On February 2019 the Estonian Financial Supervisory Authority (FSA) intimated Danske Bank to cease its activities in Estonia. At the same time, independently of the notification from the Estonian FSA, Danske Bank decided to cease its activities in Latvia, Lithuania and Russia in line with its strategy of focusing on its Nordic core market.

Ten former employees in the local branch of the bank were arrested by Estonian authorities in December 2018, and the bank was required by the Estonian government to close its Estonian branch in 2019.The CEO Thomas Borgen resigned in 2018 following the scandal. Danish authorities charged him in May 2019 with neglecting his responsibilities.At the same time, Danish prosecutors charged Henrik Ramlau-Hansen, the bank's former finance director, with failing to prevent the suspicious transactions. The Danish Parliament increased penalties for money laundering eight-fold, making them some of the toughest in Europe.All charges against Danske bankers (Thomas Borgen, Henrik Ramlau-Hansen, and Lars Morch) were dropped in April 2021. Thomas Borgen was also acquitted in a civil lawsuit related to the Danske money laundering scandal in November 2022.

The value of Danske Bank shares was halved in 2018.The bank has said it will donate 1.5 billion kroner (c. US$225 million) to a charity. It expects to pay fines of several billion dollars to financial regulators in Denmark, the U.S. and other European countries. In December 2022, Danske Bank pled guilty and agreed to a $2 billion fine in a case from the United States Department of Justice.

In conclusion, financial fraud case studies play a crucial role in safeguarding the integrity of our financial systems and protecting individuals and organizations from fraudulent activities. These laws serve as a deterrent to potential fraudsters and provide a legal framework for prosecuting and punishing those who engage in deceptive and illegal financial practice.

Financial fraud case laws not only establish the boundaries of acceptable behavior's but also provide avenues for victims to seek redress and compensation for their losses. They empower regulatory bodies, law enforcement agencies, and prosecutors to investigate, prosecute, and penalize individuals and organizations involved in financial fraud.

It is essential for individuals, businesses, and organizations to familiarize themselves with financial fraud case laws, comply with the regulations, and implement robust internal controls and risk management measures to mitigate the risk of fraud. Additionally, public awareness and education about financial fraud and its consequences can help prevent and detect fraudulent activities, ensuring a more secure and trustworthy financial environment.

By holding perpetrators accountable and deterring fraudulent practices, these laws contribute to the fair and sustainable growth of economies, protect investors and consumers, and foster trust and transparency in financial transactions.

Regards

CA Mounica Reddy