From Problem Solver to Leader: Why Technical Managers Struggle to Step Up & How To Succeed

Why Technical Managers Find the Shift to Leadership So Challenging

Technical experts thrive on solving problems. You’ve spent years becoming highly skilled at identifying issues, diving deep to find solutions, and mastering the intricacies of your field. When you take on a managerial role, on paper, it’s a reward for your expertise. But in reality, the shift from a hands-on problem solver to a leader of people can be a lot harder than anyone expects.

If you or anyone in your team are struggling with this transition, you’re not alone. It’s a challenge faced by countless technical leaders across industries. Here’s why the shift to leadership is so difficult, especially for those who love solving problems, and what can be done to make it smoother.

1. From Solving Problems to Guiding Others: A Hard Habit to Break

For technical experts, solving problems isn’t just a skill—it’s a core part of who they are. There’s a thrill in diagnosing issues, diving into complexities, and finding a solution that no one else can see. It’s a source of pride, accomplishment, and value.

But leadership requires a fundamental shift. Instead of diving in to solve every problem themselves, technical managers now need to guide their team to solve problems independently. This means stepping back, asking questions instead of providing answers, and letting others figure it out—even if they don’t do it as quickly or perfectly as the leader could.

For someone whose success has been defined by their technical skills, this feels counterintuitive. The instinct to jump in and fix things is strong, and letting go of that control can feel like letting go of what makes them effective.

2. The Emotional Shift: Redefining Success

The move from technical problem-solving to leadership also involves a significant emotional shift. Success is no longer about what you can do; it’s about what your team can achieve. This means your value as a leader is not measured by your ability to find a solution but by your ability to help others find their own.

For many technical managers, this transition is tough. There’s a deep-seated habit of taking pride in the work they do personally. When faced with a team that’s struggling, the instinct is often to step in and solve the issue rather than coach someone through it. It feels easier and more rewarding in the short term, but it ultimately stunts the team’s growth and keeps the manager stuck in the weeds.

Leaders must learn to take pride in the success of others. They need to understand that their job is no longer about being the smartest person in the room, but about creating an environment where others can thrive.

3. The Challenge of Delegation: Trusting the Team

Another reason the shift is challenging is the need to delegate effectively. Delegation requires trust—trust that your team has the ability to solve problems, make decisions, and deliver results. For technical managers used to being the "go-to" person, it can be hard to let go of control and believe that others can match their standards.

But delegation doesn't mean letting things go unchecked or allowing mistakes that could be costly. Instead, it’s about structured oversight: setting clear expectations, having checkpoints in place to review progress, and giving enough space for team members to work independently while still being there as a safety net. It’s not about stepping away entirely but creating the right balance between guiding and letting them find their own solutions. This way, you can avoid major pitfalls while still developing their problem-solving abilities.

Delegation also means dealing with mistakes. Technical managers, who often value precision and correctness, can struggle when they see team members making errors that they could have avoided if they had just done it themselves. But good leadership means allowing those mistakes, using them as learning opportunities, and trusting that the long-term outcome will be a more capable, independent team.

4. From Doing to Leading: Developing Soft Skills

Technical experts spend their careers honing technical skills—coding, engineering, analytics, troubleshooting. Leadership, on the other hand, is a game of soft skills: communication, empathy, coaching, motivation. These skills aren’t learned in the same way as technical skills; they require practice, patience, and often a fair amount of discomfort.

For technical managers, learning to navigate different personalities, manage conflicts, and inspire their team can feel like stepping into unknown territory. Unlike solving technical problems, where there’s often a right answer, leading people involves ambiguity, emotional intelligence, and a lot of listening—skills that may feel less familiar and less rewarding at first.

5. Shifting from Short-Term Solutions to Long-Term Growth

Technical managers are used to solving immediate problems—something breaks, and they fix it. Leadership, however, is about taking a long-term view. It’s about building the capabilities of your team, creating processes that prevent issues, and developing strategies that drive growth over time.

This shift from reactive problem-solving to proactive leadership requires a change in mindset. It’s not about putting out fires anymore; it’s about building a team that can prevent those fires in the first place. It’s about recognising that spending time coaching a team member today will pay dividends tomorrow in terms of independence and overall team strength.

How to Make the Shift Easier

If you’re a technical manager finding the shift to leadership challenging, here are a few steps you can take:

1. Start Small with Delegation: Begin by delegating tasks that are slightly outside your comfort zone. Resist the urge to step in unless absolutely necessary. Use these opportunities to coach rather than solve.
2. Redefine Success: Shift your perspective on success. Celebrate the wins of your team, and recognise your role in making those wins possible. Remember, your job is now to empower, not to do.
3. Embrace Mistakes as Learning Opportunities: Letting go means accepting that things might not always be perfect. Instead of stepping in, use mistakes as moments to teach and help your team grow.
4. Focus on the Long-Term Impact: Remind yourself that while it might be easier and faster to solve the problem yourself today, investing in your team’s ability to solve it will yield far greater rewards for the business—and for your own time and sanity—in the long run.

The Bottom Line

The shift from technical problem-solving to leadership isn’t easy. It requires breaking habits that have been the foundation of your success and embracing a whole new set of skills. But it’s also the key to unlocking the next stage of growth—both for yourself and for your business.

If you or your management team are struggling to make this transition, it’s important to know that you’re not alone, and there are ways to make it easier. It starts with understanding why the shift is so hard and then taking the steps needed to develop the skills that make great leaders.

To learn more about why managers often struggle with leadership roles—and what you can do to fix it fast—grab my new guide: "5 Reasons Your Managers Aren’t Managing—and How to Fix It Fast". It’s full of insights that can help you and your team grow effectively.

Click here to download