From Nuclear to Coal: Germany's Misguided Energy Transition?
Raphael Penque
Providing Strategic & Robust Project Workforce Solutions to Original Equipment Manufacturers
In the year 2000, Germany made a bold decision to decommission all their nuclear plants by 2022. Fast forward to 2023, and the country saw an 8% increase in coal imports due to the Russian invasion of Ukraine and the subsequent unreliability of gas supplies. This situation was exacerbated during high-consumption weeks 48 and 49 of 2023, when Germany's energy imports surged by 70% year-over-year, with a significant portion being nuclear from France and the Nordics.
As a project workforce service provider, we witnessed a significant rise in maintenance projects across several coal-fired power stations in the country, just one of the consequences of Germany's energy transition.
?
In contrast, France has become even more bullish on nuclear energy, as evidenced by EDF Energy's recent acquisition of GE Vernova 's Nuclear Steam Turbine business Arabelle Solutions . This move not only positions France and EDF to reduce maintenance costs but also solidifies its control over the entire nuclear-value-chain, from uranium enrichment and reactor manufacturing and EPC to the production of nuclear steam turbines and their service contracts. By overseeing the nuclear lifecycle in its entirety, from materials to engineering, procurement, construction, and operations and maintenance, France is securing a firm place in the future of the energy transition and the only player with control over a zero-carbon consistent energy economy.? ?
?
Although Germany boasts impressive renewable energy production, one cannot help but wonder how the energy crisis of 2022 and 2023 would have played out if the country still had its 17 nuclear plants in operation. J.P. Morgan 's 14th annual Energy Paper, "Electravision" , highlights the significant investment opportunities in utilities, industrial, and materials sectors, particularly in nuclear's potential role in the energy transition. Judging by that paper, France is playing a spot of Energy Transition Roulette and has every number covered.
领英推荐
?
Even Elon Musk, a vocal proponent of solar energy (or "the thermal reactor in the sky" as he likes to call it), has recognized the role of nuclear power in achieving a sustainable energy economy—at least until improvements in battery technology offer a more reliable and efficient solution. Something Tesla themselves are heavily invested in.
?
As the world grapples with the challenges of energy transition, the contrasting experiences of Germany and France serve as a reminder of the importance of a balanced and diversified energy mix. The future of energy may well lie in a combination of renewables, nuclear, and other sustainable sources, with each playing a vital role in ensuring a cleaner, more resilient energy landscape.
?
Whatever happens, at PowerForce Global , we’ll still be here to serve as an indispensable cog empowering the global energy workforce!
Customer Growth | Developing Proactive Global Service & Aftermarket Strategy | Service Contract Expansion | Quality | Engineering
2 个月As you say Germany’s choice to shut down its nuclear plants was bold, but the current energy situation shows how complex these transitions can be. While Germany has made great strides with renewable energy, the recent need to import more coal and nuclear energy from other countries during high-demand periods raises concerns about energy security. On the other hand, France’s decision to stay invested in nuclear energy and control the entire process highlights the benefits of a balanced energy approach. As we move towards cleaner energy, it’s important to be careful about making quick decisions without fully understanding the long-term risks. Rushing changes could create problems down the road. A thoughtful plan that includes renewables, nuclear, and other sustainable energy sources will likely be key to building a stable and reliable energy future.
Aerospace EMC Engineering Contractor
4 个月It would help to name the person/government/or party in power that decided, this might increase the responsibility. ??
#NuclearEnergy
Every day is a challenge and one more day of overcoming, fight to achieve your dreams and you will achieve it.
5 个月Yes, it is true everything you say raphael but as is the case of Spain the transition has made Germany mandatory for other countries and not for them or linking to the decarbonization and dismantling of the same thermal power plants while Germany invests in reforms and reopening of the same power plants that forces to close and dismantle in other countries . what I see is that Germany has made a strategic move to stay with the electric market and take out competitors and not for the sake of it. the energy transition as a proposal.