From Guesswork to Certainty: Why CAI Outshines NPS for Measuring True Advocacy

When it comes to understanding customer advocacy, the Net Promoter Score? (NPS)[1] has long been a popular metric. However, it has its limitations. Admittedly, I’m not a big fan of surveys in general. Sure, they’re easy to administer and can quickly gather feedback, but they rarely provide actionable insights. While surveys can offer useful insights into attitudes and perceptions, they fall short when it comes to reliably predicting behavior.

NPS gives you a glimpse into potential future advocacy, but it doesn’t measure what your customers are actually doing in the present. Enter the Customer Advocacy Index (CAI)[2]—a metric that tracks real-world actions and offers a more accurate picture of your most loyal advocates. Let’s explore why CAI is a more reliable tool for understanding advocacy and how artificial intelligence (AI) can help you generate and refine your CAI scores.

NPS vs. CAI: Intent vs. Action

NPS asks a simple question: “How likely are you to recommend our product or service to a friend or colleague?” Based on responses, customers are categorized as promoters, passives, or detractors. It’s a forward-looking metric, purportedly predicting whether a customer might recommend your brand in the future.

However, the challenge with NPS lies in its predictive nature. People often answer surveys based on what they intend to do, not what they’ll actually do. Human behavior is tricky, influenced by circumstances like time, money, and shifting priorities. What sounds good in the moment doesn’t always translate to action. This gap between intention and reality can make NPS an unreliable predictor of true advocacy.

CAI, on the other hand, focuses on action, measuring the intensity and frequency of advocacy that has already happened. Have your customers shared positive experiences on social media? Referred new customers? Written glowing reviews? Bought something? These actions tell you much more about their loyalty than a survey about future intentions ever could. In short, CAI gives you a clear, actionable snapshot of who’s actively promoting your brand today.

The Power of Behavioral Data

CAI draws on actual behavior, not just sentiment. This distinction is critical because actions speak louder than intentions. Instead of relying solely on survey responses, CAI tracks data like referrals, social media engagement, and user-generated reviews. These actions provide a concrete view of how customers feel about your brand—and more importantly, how they’re advocating for it.

When you focus on behavior, you get a more accurate picture of customer preferences and decision-making processes. Rather than guessing who might become an advocate, CAI shows you who already is an advocate, and it’s rooted in reality. This makes it a much more reliable metric for making strategic decisions and improving customer relationships.

How AI Can Supercharge Your CAI

Building and maintaining a CAI requires tracking multiple data points, from social media mentions to customer reviews. This is where AI comes in. Artificial intelligence can help you automate the process, analyze data more effectively, and gain deeper insights. Here’s how:

1. Sentiment Analysis?

AI can analyze vast amounts of text data—reviews, social media posts, and customer interactions—to gauge customer sentiment. Natural Language Processing (NLP) helps AI understand whether a customer is an advocate, detractor, or somewhere in between. This analysis feeds directly into your CAI, showing not just what customers are saying, but how they’re saying it.

2. Predictive Modeling?

AI can help predict who is likely to become an advocate by analyzing past customer behavior. Purchase patterns, brand engagement, and customer support interactions all offer clues about future advocacy. With predictive modeling, you can identify which customers are most likely to spread the word about your brand and tailor your strategies to nurture these relationships.

3. Automated Feedback Loops?

Gathering feedback at critical touchpoints is essential for accurate CAI data. AI-powered chatbots and automated surveys can collect this data in real time, ensuring you’re always in touch with customer sentiment. The AI can also categorize responses and highlight areas where advocacy might be waning, giving you a chance to take proactive steps.

4. Voice of the Customer (VoC) Programs?

AI can elevate your VoC program by collecting feedback from multiple channels—email, social media, live chat—and analyzing it for patterns. This gives you a comprehensive view of how customers perceive your brand and where you might improve to increase advocacy. To be clear, I’m also not a big fan of VoC, as it’s still based on what customers say rather than what they do. However, with AI, you can better extract actionable insights by distinguishing customer actions from intentions.

5. Real-time Dashboards?

AI-powered dashboards offer real-time insights into your CAI score, tracking changes in advocacy levels over time. These dashboards can alert you to advocacy hotspots or potential problem areas, enabling you to act quickly to enhance the customer experience.

6. Customer Segmentation?

AI can segment your customers based on their advocacy levels, allowing you to target different groups with personalized marketing campaigns. Your most loyal advocates—those with high CAI scores—can be rewarded with special offers, while those on the fence can receive additional incentives to become stronger supporters.

Taking Action with CAI and AI

To truly leverage the power of CAI, start by integrating AI tools into your customer data processes. Here’s a simple roadmap:

1. Collect Data: Use AI to gather customer feedback from various channels—surveys, reviews, social media posts, and more.

2. Analyze Sentiment: Employ NLP and sentiment analysis to gauge the emotional tone of customer advocacy.

3. Identify Patterns: Use AI’s predictive modeling to find patterns that lead to strong advocacy.

4. Track and Measure: Implement real-time dashboards to monitor your CAI and track how it evolves.

5. Act on Insights: Take action based on AI-generated recommendations, improving customer experiences and boosting advocacy where needed.

With CAI, you’re no longer guessing about customer loyalty—you’re measuring it in real time, backed by the power of AI. This combination not only gives you more accurate insights into who your advocates are but also allows you to strengthen those relationships and fuel business growth.

Interested in learning more? Let’s do a keynote or workshop with your team!

--

Bob Roitblat

As a Transformation Navigator, Bob specializes in illuminating the path to innovative thinking, a future-proof mindset, and the leadership prowess needed to overcome today's challenges and grasp tomorrow's possibilities. He is a renowned keynote speaker, delivering powerful presentations and interactive workshops at numerous events across the globe. In addition to speaking, Bob writes extensively about organizational change and works directly with clients to implement effective strategies.

For further advice, insight, and perspective on the tools and techniques to transform your business, subscribe to this newsletter on LinkedIn: https://www.dhirubhai.net/newsletters/7099140608132358144

And Follow Bob on LinkedIn: www.dhirubhai.net/comm/mynetwork/discovery-see-all?usecase=PEOPLE_FOLLOWS&followMember=bobroitblat

Learn more at www.roitblat.com or call Bob at 847-572-3269.

Permission to reprint this article is hereby granted to all print, broadcast, and electronic media, provided that the contact information at the end of the article is included in your publication. For organizations publishing articles electronically, a live, clickable link to https://www.roitblat.com must also be included and be visible.

Permission is also granted for reasonable editing of content, including the exchange of industry-specific examples, adjustments to length, and modifications to the article title.

[1] NPS? and the NPS-related emoticons are registered trademarks of Bain & Company, Inc., NICE Systems, Inc., and Fred Reichheld.

[2] I believe CAI to be a generic term used to describe a concept rather than a protected brand or methodology.