Freedom and Responsibility within a Framework

Freedom and Responsibility within a Framework

Throughout my career I have struggled to balance the competing needs for entrepreneurial thinking, innovation, and initiative and the necessities of organization, structure, consistency, and control.?How does one create and sustain a nimble organization that can quickly respond to new technologies, changing member wants and desires, and the competition of the marketplace while maintaining an efficient operation and conscientiously meeting regulatory requirements?

No thinking businessperson wants to saddle their operation with a bureaucratic mindset, yet efficient operations need systems to function properly and avoid risk, liability, and regulatory problems.?The very word “bureaucracy” carries the negative connotation of inefficiency and stultifying processes where crossing the t’s and dotting the i’s seems to become the organization’s reason for being.?

In examining this never-ending challenge for businesses, Jim Collins and his research team at Stanford University found that the good to great companies they examined gave people the freedom to do whatever was necessary to succeed within a highly developed system or framework.?Then their people were held strictly accountable for their results.

The analogy that he gave was a commercial airline pilot who works within rigid air traffic control and safety systems on the ground and in the air, but who has the ultimate responsibility for success – that is, the safe delivery of plane and passengers from location to location.?That singular responsibility allows a pilot, at his or her discretion, to remove unruly passengers, abort landings, fly to alternate airports, and take any other action deemed necessary for the safety of the flight.

But essential to bestowing such freedom and responsibility is the necessity of defining the system and clearly identifying constraints.?In the airline industry the Federal Aviation Administration establishes all standards, policies, and procedures for both commercial and private pilots and ensures their ongoing understanding of the system through licensure, certifications, simulator and cockpit training, as well as continual flight and safety bulletins.?To quote from the book:

“The good to great companies build a consistent system with clear constraints, but they also gave people the freedom and responsibility within the framework of that system.?They hired self-disciplined people who didn’t need to be managed, and then managed the system, not the people.”

As a club manager at any level of the organization, you cannot do it all yourself.?Holding the reins tightly creates a bottleneck where all decisions must come through you, thereby stifling the initiative and creativity of your subordinates.?It also puts a tremendous burden on you to perform, requires you to be on property at all hours, and leads to burnout.?

The only way to be truly successful in any complex enterprise is to empower those under you and give them the freedom and responsibility to succeed in their portion of the operation.?But to do this successfully you need to fully develop the framework for their empowerment and the means to hold them accountable.?This requires you to spell out expectations, provide well-defined organizational values, and document how you will conduct your operations with written standards, policies, and procedures (the Club Operations Plan).?Lastly, you must hold your subordinates responsible with measurable accountabilities for performance.

With these in place you have started on the path to greatness in your enterprise, but it’s only the start – Collins offers much more proven guidance for those willing to invest the time in this well-researched and written, as well as insightful and entertaining, book. I wholeheartedly recommend it to every club senior manager.

The book is Good to Great – Why Some Companies Make the Leap . . . and Others Don’t, Harper Business, New York, NY, 2001.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Ed Rehkopf的更多文章

  • Last Call!

    Last Call!

    Private clubs face many challenges in attempting to deliver high levels of service to their members. As with any…

    1 条评论
  • The Soft Stuff

    The Soft Stuff

    Roger Enrico, former chairman at PepsiCo, famously said, “The soft stuff is always harder than the hard stuff.” As one…

  • Overcoming the Impediments to Quality

    Overcoming the Impediments to Quality

    The bottom line for any private club is to consistently meet or exceed the expectations of its members. Given that the…

  • It Ain’t the Employees!

    It Ain’t the Employees!

    If you want to improve quality and service at your operation, don’t start with your line employees. According to the…

    2 条评论
  • Tropical Storm Helene Impacts Announcement

    Tropical Storm Helene Impacts Announcement

    When I announced my retirement in August, I said that I would continue to operate the PCPM Marketplace Store through…

  • Benchmarking Your Way to Improved Performance

    Benchmarking Your Way to Improved Performance

    William Thomson, Lord Kelvin, one of the leading lights of 19th century science said, “If you cannot measure it, you…

  • Holding Our Team to the Highest Standards – A Manager’s Code of Ethics

    Holding Our Team to the Highest Standards – A Manager’s Code of Ethics

    In an ideal world we could trust everyone to do the right things, but such a world does not exist. The unfortunate fact…

  • Real Time Accounting in Food Service Operations

    Real Time Accounting in Food Service Operations

    The attitude in some clubs seems to be that monitoring the financial performance of the club and all its departments is…

  • Food Service in Private Clubs Miscellany

    Food Service in Private Clubs Miscellany

    Let us recognize that the club business is not rocket science. The basics of what we do are well-known to any club…

    1 条评论
  • Becoming a Service-Based Leader

    Becoming a Service-Based Leader

    Developing leadership skills is not memorizing a list of things to do or not to do, though such lists are useful in…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了