Financial Product Engineering: How Banks Turn Ideas into Cash Flow
Debroop K.
Financial & Process Analyst- Data Management | MIS Reporting | XBRL Adoption | IFRS & US GAAP | Fund Accounting | Operations Excellence | Financial Analysis & Modelling | Extraction with SQL & Python | VBA Automation
As finance professionals, we often focus on numbers, ratios, and forecasts.
However, have we considered the interconnectedness between departments in a bank or financial institution when introducing new products?
In the world of banking and financial services, the creation of a new product is not simply about designing a physical item to be sold. Instead, it's about transforming financial concepts into services that can generate, manage, and redistribute wealth. This process involves more than just numbers—it's about crafting an offer that balances risk, revenue, and customer demand while ensuring the bank’s overall financial health.
Let’s take a deep dive into how financial products are designed, developed, and launched, all while staying grounded in the practical realities of how money flows within the system and the broader economy.
The process begins with a deep understanding of the bank’s capacity to lend or offer services. Unlike a product that requires physical manufacturing, a financial product, such as a loan or an investment product, uses the bank’s existing capital base and customer deposits as the raw materials for creation. The bank must carefully assess how much money it has available to lend or invest, considering its capital reserves and the regulatory requirements set by authorities.
At its core, the bank’s ability to lend is determined by how much liquidity it holds. Liquidity comes from customer deposits, which are the foundation of the funds the bank uses to issue loans, extend lines of credit, or offer other financial services. However, the money is not just coming from a single source; it’s part of a much larger system where each department—sales, operations, marketing, and customer service—plays a crucial role in creating, promoting, and managing these financial offerings.
Role in Financial Services
When the product development team at a bank embarks on creating a new service—be it a personal loan, mortgage, or investment vehicle—the first thing they need to consider is feasibility.
But unlike traditional products, designing a financial service product involves multiple calculations and assumptions about customer behavior, market demand, and the overall financial landscape. The team does not simply decide on an interest rate or fee structure in isolation; they must evaluate the bank’s existing costs, customer needs, and the competitive environment.
For example-
The product development team must also anticipate the risk of defaults. Since financial products are built around money, and money doesn’t come with guarantees, the risk management team plays a key role.
By assessing the creditworthiness of potential customers and creating systems for automated repayment reminders, they ensure the product is designed with mitigation strategies in place.
A credit score helps in determining who qualifies for the product and at what terms—reducing the likelihood that customers with higher chances of default will be offered larger loan amounts.
How Product Development Works – Designing a Personal Loan ?
When the bank's Product Development team designs a new personal loan, they base the design on several factors that align with market demand and customer preferences. Here’s how they go about it:
Customer Needs and Preferences:
Competitor Offerings:
Financial Feasibility (Interest Rate, Fees, Loan Amounts):
How It Works Practically: When the product development team designs a loan, they need to ensure that the loan is profitable for the bank. This means they need to carefully calculate:
Methods and Tools Used for Calculating Feasibility:
Loan Pricing Model:
Example Calculation:
Many banks use tools like Excel or financial software to perform these calculations. In Excel, the team might build models that calculate:
The team could create a spreadsheet with loan amounts in one column (e.g., $5,000, $10,000, $20,000) and calculate the total interest earned based on different interest rates (5%, 5.5%, etc.) and repayment terms (1 year, 3 years, etc.).
Regulatory Compliance:
Risk Management (Preventing Defaults):
How It Works Practically: Risk management is about reducing the chance that customers will fail to repay their loans. Banks use several methods to manage this risk:
Credit Scoring:
Automated Repayment Reminders:
Loan Covenants or Collateral:
Methods to Calculate Risk:
Credit Risk Models: Banks often use credit risk models to predict the likelihood of defaults based on data. These models can calculate the risk by considering:
Stress Testing:Banks also perform stress testing to see how the loan portfolio would behave under extreme conditions, like a recession or a significant rise in unemployment. This helps ensure the bank can handle potential loan defaults.
Note:
By using these methods and tools, banks ensure that they can offer loans that meet customer demand while protecting themselves from financial losses.
Putting It All Together:
In order to calculate the total operational cost and revenue from a loan, the bank will:
Example Summary:
Let’s consider a $10,000 personal loan:
Since the total revenue of $800 is greater than the operational cost of $570, the loan is profitable for the bank. The profit in this case would be: Profit=800?570=230.
This process ensures the bank can cover its costs and generate a profit, while also considering the risks involved in lending.
It might be wondering how these will be computed before a loan is introduced to customers......
While it is not directly tied to a specific customer at the product development stage,even before specific customers are identified, the bank estimates the default risk based on historical data and industry trends. The risk is then factored into the pricing model of the product, like setting a higher interest rate or adding risk premiums.
Based on this, the bank will add a risk premium (additional charges) or set a higher interest rate to account for these defaults, even though no customer has yet applied for the loan.
Credit scoring doesn’t apply directly to a specific customer at the product development stage. However, the bank still designs the product with certain credit score requirements in mind.When designing a new product, the bank sets criteria (e.g., minimum credit score) based on historical patterns of how borrowers with certain credit scores tend to perform. These criteria help the bank anticipate how risky the loan product will be.before it is introduced to individual customers.
How Much Money Can the Bank Loan (Lending Capacity)?
A bank’s lending capacity depends on a variety of factors, including its capital, reserves, and regulatory requirements. Let’s break it down step-by-step:
Capital Reserves (Equity Capital)
Example:
Deposits (Customer Accounts)
Banks primarily use the money deposited by customers (checking accounts, savings accounts, and fixed deposits) as a source of funds for lending.
Example:
Interbank Loans (Borrowing from Other Banks)
In addition to deposits, banks can borrow money from other banks in the interbank market. If a bank needs more funds to lend, it can borrow money from other banks that have excess reserves.
Securitization and Bond Issuance
Banks can also raise money by selling securities or issuing bonds. These funds can then be used for lending. When the bank issues a bond, it’s essentially borrowing money from investors, promising to pay them back with interest over time.
Sources of Funds for Lending:
Now, let's address the specific question of where the money comes from for loans. There are several sources:
a) Customer Deposits
The most common source of funds for a bank is customer deposits. For example, when you deposit money in a savings account, the bank can use a portion of that deposit to lend money to others (subject to the reserve requirements).
b) Capital Reserves
Banks also rely on their own equity capital (shareholders’ investment and retained earnings). This capital acts as a cushion for the bank in case of loan defaults or other financial risks.
c) Borrowing from Other Financial Institutions
Banks can also borrow money from other banks, especially in the short-term interbank lending market. This is a common practice for managing liquidity and ensuring that the bank has enough money to cover its loans.
d) Issuing Bonds and Securitization
Banks can also issue bonds to raise funds. Investors buy the bonds, providing the bank with funds that it can then use for lending purposes. Similarly, banks can bundle loans into securities and sell them to investors, allowing the bank to free up capital and lend again.
How Much Money a Bank Can Loan:
Example of Lending Capacity Calculation:
Let’s assume a simple scenario where the bank has:
Here’s how we calculate the lending capacity:
Deposits Available for Lending:
Capital Adequacy:
Thus, the bank’s total lending capacity is $125 million, which includes customer deposits, capital reserves, and any borrowing the bank can access to support its lending.
Banks calculate how much money they can safely lend by ensuring they maintain the required capital reserves and meet regulatory requirements to prevent too much risk exposure.
By balancing these factors, a bank can ensure that it has enough money to lend out while still being able to cover its costs, manage risks, and remain financially stable.
Note:
In both cases, the ultimate aim is to launch a product that attracts customers, generates revenue for the bank, and balances the bank’s financial system by managing risks effectively.
Risk Assessment and Loan Loss Provisions:
To account for the possibility of defaults, banks must calculate the Expected Credit Loss (ECL), which affects financial products like loans.
Example Calculation for ECL: The ECL is a way to estimate the amount a bank could lose from loan defaults over time. It's a forward-looking measure that ensures banks account for potential losses on their loan books.
The ECL can be calculated as:
ECL = EAD × PD × LGD
ECL =10,000 × 0.02 × 0.50 =100
So, the bank expects to lose $100 due to loan defaults.
The provision for loan losses of $100 impacts the Balance Sheet as an increase in Allowance for Loan Losses under Assets and reduces the Net Income in the Income Statement.
Impact on Financial Statements:
Accounting Entry:
Research and Development (R&D):
During this phase, banks conduct market research and assess customer needs to refine the product's features (e.g., loan tenure, flexibility in repayments). If the product is complex (such as structured finance products, mortgages, or investment vehicles), R&D expenses may be incurred.
These costs would be capitalized or expensed depending on the accounting standards used. Under IFRS, certain development costs could be capitalized if they meet specific criteria.
Impact on Financial Statements:
Creating a Sustainable Financial Offering
But designing the product is only part of the equation. The sales, marketing, and customer service teams are equally important in ensuring the financial product reaches the right audience and performs as expected in the market.
Once the product is designed, the sales team kicks into action. Their role is to ensure that the right customers are targeted—those who need the product the most and have the ability to repay. With loans, for instance, the bank might focus on individuals with stable incomes or a good credit history, ensuring that the risk of defaults is minimized. The sales team also helps customers understand the terms—how much they will pay in interest, the fees involved, and the loan tenure. Clear communication here is critical to maintaining trust and minimizing confusion or frustration.
Meanwhile, the marketing team works on positioning the product in a way that appeals to customers. A 5% interest rate might sound like a great offer to potential borrowers, but the marketing team needs to frame this offering in a way that highlights its advantages over other products in the market. The promotional messaging emphasizes the simplicity of the loan application process, quick disbursement, and easy repayment structure. Cross-selling other bank products, like credit cards or insurance, also becomes an essential part of the overall marketing strategy. By integrating these additional services, the bank can drive higher customer lifetime value and increase overall profitability.
Launching and Marketing Financial Products
The product launch involves sales, marketing, and customer acquisition costs.
If the product is a personal loan, and the marketing campaign drives 500 new loan applications, of which 400 are approved, the bank incurs costs in acquiring customers.
Impact on Financial Statements:
The Interplay Between Operations and Risk Management
As the financial product hits the market, the operations team ensures the product runs smoothly in day-to-day banking. Unlike physical products, a financial service involves constant transactional flows, such as loan repayments, interest accrual, and customer inquiries. To ensure everything runs seamlessly, the operations team oversees systems integration—updating customer records, monitoring repayments, and handling exceptions like delayed payments or missed deadlines.
This operational management has direct implications for financial forecasting. For example, how many customers are expected to repay their loans on time? What happens if there’s an increase in default rates? By continuously tracking these metrics, the bank can adjust its risk premiums or modify the loan offer to ensure that it continues to be profitable.
On the risk management side, understanding default risk isn’t just about assessing customers at the point of sale; it’s a continuous process. Banks use automated tools and algorithms to monitor the performance of the loan book in real-time, flagging potential issues early on. The risk management team may adjust interest rates or even introduce loan modification programs if they see trends that indicate a higher likelihood of defaults.
This dynamic interplay between operations and risk management ensures that the financial services product adapts to market conditions, remains financially viable, and continues to drive the bank’s revenue growth.
Execution and Consumer Use of Product
Once the product is launched and available to consumers, the bank will begin to incur costs related to servicing the financial product (e.g., loan servicing, account maintenance, processing payments) and monitoring risks (e.g., defaults, customer complaints).
Costs Involved:
Example:
Impact on Financial Statements:
Over time, the loan interest of 5% (annual) will be recognized in the Income Statement as revenue:
Interest?Income?(Year?1) =10,000 × 5% = 500
Risk Management During Loan Lifecycle:
As the loan life cycle progresses, the bank needs to continually assess the credit risk and adjust provisions if the likelihood of default changes.
If the Probability of Default (PD) increases, the bank needs to increase its ECL provision.
Example Change in Default Risk:
If the PD increases from 2% to 5%, the ECL calculation changes.
Using the same ECL formula the ECL would adjust:
ECL = 10,000 × 0.05 × 0.50 = 250
Now, the bank expects to lose $250 instead of $100.
Impact on Financial Statements:
Accounting Entry:
Note:
Key Accounting Entries for Each Scenario:
Debit: Provision for Loan Losses (Expense) $100
Credit: Allowance for Loan Losses $100
Debit: Provision for Loan Losses (Expense) $150
Credit: Allowance for Loan Losses $150
Revenue Management: – Analyzing Market Demand
In financial services, revenue management is about ensuring that the products bring in enough to cover costs, manage risks, and make profits.
Revenue management is about estimating and maximizing the amount of money the bank can earn, mainly through interest, fees, and other charges from products like loans. To do this, banks analyze market demand using several methods and processes:
Methods and Processes to Analyze Market Demand for Loans:
Market Research and Surveys:
Competitive Analysis:
Historical Data Analysis (Trend Analysis):
Customer Segmentation:
Once the product is active in the market, revenue begins to flow in through fees (e.g., loan processing fees, service fees), interest income (from loans or investment products), and other charges (e.g., penalty fees, late payment fees).
Let’s break this down with a simple calculation:
Accounting Treatment:
Debit: Loan Receivable $500 | Credit: Interest Income $500 (Yr.1) so on..
Debit: Cash/Bank $200 | Credit: Fee Income $200
Financial Statement Impact:
Together, these fees and interest payments generate the bank’s income. The key here is balancing the interest rates, loan amounts, and fees so that the bank’s revenue covers its costs while still being attractive to customers.
Banks must also forecast how many loans will be paid off early, the effect of prepayments on interest income, and the impact of defaults. Proper revenue management ensures that products like personal loans or mortgages continue to generate profits.
Example:
Loan Forecasting: A loan portfolio with $1 million in loans may generate interest income of $50,000 annually (at 5% interest).If the bank expects 10% of loans to be paid off early, it needs to adjust its revenue forecasts:
Adjusted?Interest?Income= 50,000 × (1?0.10)= 45,000
Impact on Financial Statements:
Impact on Financial Statements for Other Financial Products
Mortgage:
Investment Vehicles:
Credit Cards:
and many more to list down...
Note:
For financial products and services, costs related to research and development are often expensed unless the costs meet capitalization criteria (under IFRS). Once the product is launched and customers start availing the service, interest income and fees are recognized as revenue, while operational costs are expensed. The balance sheet reflects changes in intangible assets, receivables, and cash as the product is developed, launched, and used by consumers.
In banks and financial institutions, the people responsible for designing financial products and services are part of specialized teams that operate much like a product development or innovation team in a manufacturing business. Here’s how it works:
Who Designs Financial Products?
The creation and design of financial products involve several departments working together. Each plays a critical role in ensuring the product is feasible, profitable, and compliant with regulations. These roles include:
Pre-Designed :
Most financial products are pre-designed with standardized terms, pricing models, and risk parameters. Examples include:
On-the-Spot Customization:
Certain financial services, especially for large clients, are customized during client interactions:
For example:
Note:
In essence, the factory of a bank involves these specialists working together:
This holistic team creates, customizes, and manages the financial services and products banks offer.
However, these professionals often form the core of specialized teams responsible for modeling, pricing, and managing the financial intricacies of products-
In financial institutions, collaboration among different roles (financial engineers, analysts, actuaries, lawyers, and compliance professionals) is critical. Products and strategies can be predesigned for retail use but are heavily customized for institutional clients or complex transactions.
In reality, the launch and management of a new loan product are far from a one-off process. It involves constant feedback loops between departments—product development, sales, marketing, operations, risk management, and customer service—to ensure the product remains competitive, profitable, and aligned with customer needs.
Banks must continuously assess market demand, adapt pricing strategies, manage risk, and optimize customer service to drive sustainable revenue and ensure financial stability.
In today’s rapidly evolving financial services sector, understanding how multiple departments collaborate to drive revenue management and balance the bank’s financial health is crucial. Whether you’re in product development, sales, or operations, being part of this cross-functional process gives us all valuable insights into how financial products and banking operations really work.
As we look to the future, this multi-departmental approach will continue to evolve, with more sophisticated tools and data-driven insights guiding how banks create and manage financial products. The digitization of financial services is already changing the way these products are conceived, launched, and managed, and understanding these connections is essential for anyone looking to succeed in the modern banking and financial landscape.
Key Takeaways
By carefully managing the product development and tracking these metrics across all three financial statements, banks can ensure that the products not only meet customer needs but also contribute significantly to profitability and long-term financial health.