The Financial Pressures on Private Colleges—and How Schooley Mitchell Delivers Savings

Private colleges are integral to the higher education landscape, offering personalized learning experiences and specialized programs. However, they face mounting financial challenges. Recent legal developments regarding student-athlete compensation and declining enrollment numbers have intensified the strain on their budgets. Managing costs in areas like waste management, telecom, merchant services, facility supplies, office supplies, shipping—including Less-than-Truckload (LTL) and small package shipping—and energy has become more critical than ever. Inefficiencies in these areas can consume up to 30% of a college's operating budget. Let's explore these challenges and see how Schooley Mitchell can help private colleges optimize expenses and enhance financial stability.

Additional Financial Pressures on Private Colleges

Legal Rulings on Student-Athlete Compensation

The Challenge: Recent legal rulings have reshaped the landscape of college athletics. Courts have ruled that student-athletes can profit from their Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL), and there is ongoing debate about additional compensation, which could include back pay in certain circumstances.

• Increased Costs: Colleges may face new expenses related to compensating student-athletes or providing additional benefits.
• Compliance and Administration: Implementing systems to manage NIL agreements and ensure compliance adds administrative costs.
• Competitive Pressure: Institutions may feel compelled to enhance athletic budgets to attract and retain talent.

Declining Enrollment

The Challenge: Many private colleges are experiencing declining enrollment due to demographic shifts, increased competition, and changing perceptions about the value of higher education.

• Revenue Shortfalls: Fewer students mean reduced tuition revenue, which is critical for private colleges that rely heavily on tuition for funding.
• Fixed Costs: Operating costs remain high regardless of enrollment numbers, leading to budget imbalances.
• Increased Recruitment Costs: Colleges invest more in marketing and recruitment efforts to attract students, further straining budgets.

?

?

Waste Management Woes in Higher Education

The Problem: Colleges generate significant amounts of waste, including recyclables, food waste, and hazardous materials from laboratories.

• High Disposal Costs: The average college produces 640 pounds of waste per student annually, leading to substantial disposal expenses.
• Regulatory Compliance: Proper disposal of hazardous and electronic waste is costly due to strict environmental regulations.
• Sustainability Goals: Many institutions aim for zero-waste or reduced waste footprints, which can increase short-term costs.

How Schooley Mitchell Helps:

• Contract Negotiation: Assisted in renegotiating waste disposal contracts, reducing costs by up to 40%.
• Vendor Management: Helped select cost-effective waste management providers that align with sustainability goals.

Telecom Troubles in Educational Institutions

The Problem: Reliable communication and connectivity are critical for colleges, but telecom expenses can account for 4-6% of operating budgets.

• Outdated Infrastructure: Legacy phone systems and internet services are expensive to maintain and may not meet current needs.
• Billing Errors: 80% of telecom invoices contain errors, leading to overpayments.
• Underutilized Services: Unused phone lines and data plans can account for 15-20% of telecom expenses.

How Schooley Mitchell Helps:

• Telecom Audits: Uncovered billing errors and overcharges, recovering overpayments averaging $20,000 per institution.
• Service Optimization: Recommended elimination of unnecessary services, reducing telecom expenses by 25%.
• Technology Upgrades: Assisted in transitioning to cost-effective VoIP systems and high-speed internet, improving connectivity while saving costs.

Merchant Services Mysteries for Colleges

The Problem: Private colleges process numerous transactions, including tuition payments, bookstore sales, and event ticketing, incurring significant merchant service fees.

• High Processing Fees: Colleges pay an average of 2-3% per transaction in processing fees.
• Complex Fee Structures: Hidden fees and surcharges lead to overpayments of up to 25%.
• Security Compliance: Maintaining PCI DSS compliance adds to operational costs.

How Schooley Mitchell Helps:

• Fee Analysis: Identified hidden fees and negotiated reductions, achieving average savings of 28% in merchant service fees.
• Transparent Pricing: Simplified fee structures, enhancing budgeting accuracy.
• Compliance Support: Provided strategies to maintain compliance cost-effectively, reducing associated expenses.

Facility Supplies Frustrations

The Problem: Colleges spend heavily on facility supplies, including maintenance materials, cleaning products, and classroom necessities.

• Inefficient Procurement: Decentralized purchasing leads to overpaying by 15-20%.
• Inventory Waste: Up to 15% of supplies expire or become obsolete due to overstocking.
• Supplier Fragmentation: Multiple vendors increase administrative burdens and costs.

How Schooley Mitchell Helps:

• Procurement Optimization: Streamlined purchasing processes, saving an average of 23% on facility supplies.
• Inventory Management: Implemented control systems, reducing waste by 30%.
• Supplier Negotiations: Consolidated suppliers and negotiated better terms, reducing costs by 20%.

Office Supplies Overload in Academia

The Problem: Office supplies can significantly impact budgets, consuming up to 3% of a college's non-salary expenditures.

• Uncontrolled Spending: Departments independently ordering supplies leads to inconsistent pricing and excess inventory.
• Lack of Standardization: Using various brands and products increases costs by 10-15%.
• Inefficient Ordering: Frequent small orders miss out on bulk discounts and raise administrative costs.

How Schooley Mitchell Helps:

• Standardization: Established uniform office supply policies, saving 22% on costs.
• Bulk Purchasing: Negotiated bulk purchase agreements, lowering prices by 18%.
• Usage Tracking: Implemented monitoring systems, reducing unnecessary orders by 25%.

Shipping Snafus Impacting College Operations

The Problem: Colleges rely on shipping for textbooks, equipment, lab samples, and admissions materials, with logistics costs affecting budgets.

• Rising Shipping Rates: Annual increases by carriers add pressure to budgets.
• Surcharges and Fees: Additional charges can add 20-30% to shipping costs.
• Inefficient Practices: Lack of optimized shipping strategies leads to higher expenses.

LTL (Less-than-Truckload) and Small Package Shipping Challenges

The Problem:

• LTL Shipping: Used for large equipment and bulk orders but comes with complex pricing and surcharges.
• Small Package Shipping: Frequent shipments of documents and small items incur high costs without volume discounts.

How Schooley Mitchell Helps:

• Rate Negotiation: Achieved savings of up to 22% on LTL shipping rates and 26% on small package shipping through carrier negotiations.
• Surcharge Management: Identified and eliminated unnecessary surcharges, saving an average of 15%.
• Shipping Optimization: Recommended consolidation and efficient routing, reducing costs by 12%.

Energy Costs Draining Educational Resources

The Problem: Energy consumption is a significant expense, with colleges spending $1.10 per square foot annually on energy, according to the U.S. Department of Energy.

• High Energy Usage: Aging buildings and facilities consume more energy, increasing costs by 20-30%.
• Rising Energy Prices: Energy costs have been increasing by 2-3% annually.
• Sustainability Initiatives: Investments in green technologies have upfront costs that impact budgets.

How Schooley Mitchell Helps:

• Energy Audits: Identified opportunities to reduce energy consumption by 15-25%.
• Supplier Negotiations: Secured better energy rates, reducing costs by 10-15%.
• Efficiency Upgrades: Recommended energy-efficient systems with ROI in 2-4 years.
• Demand Management: Implemented strategies to reduce peak demand charges by 18%.

The Schooley Mitchell Advantage for Private Colleges

• Addressing Financial Pressures: By uncovering cost savings, colleges can mitigate the financial impact of student-athlete compensation and declining enrollment.
• No Upfront Fees: Their performance-based model means they only get paid when you save.
• Education Sector Expertise: Experience with educational institutions ensures understanding of unique challenges.
• Comprehensive Analysis: Utilize proprietary tools to uncover hidden savings without compromising educational quality.
• Ongoing Support: Provide continuous monitoring to ensure sustained cost optimization.

?

?

Real-World Impact

• Case Study - Heritage College: Waste Management Savings: Reduced disposal costs by $150,000 annually through improved recycling and contract negotiation. Telecom Savings: Cut expenses by $100,000 per year by eliminating unused services and securing better rates. Merchant Services Savings: Lowered processing fees by $80,000 annually. Shipping Savings: Reduced costs by $70,000 through optimized shipping strategies. Energy Savings: Achieved $200,000 in savings by implementing energy efficiency measures. Total Savings: Over $600,000 saved, allowing investment in scholarships and academic programs, and offsetting financial pressures from legal obligations and enrollment challenges.

?

• Case Study - Lakeside University: Facility Supplies Savings: Saved $130,000 through procurement optimization. Office Supplies Savings: Reduced costs by $60,000 via standardization and bulk purchasing. Energy Savings: Reduced energy expenses by $220,000 through efficiency improvements. Total Savings: $410,000 in annual savings, funds redirected to campus improvements and student services, helping to alleviate budget strains caused by external financial pressures.

Additional Data Points

• Impact of Student-Athlete Compensation: Colleges may face increased costs of $500,000 to $1 million annually to support athlete compensation and compliance programs.
• Declining Enrollment Trends: National enrollment in private colleges has declined by 5% over the past five years, leading to significant revenue shortfalls.
• Rising Operational Costs: Operational costs continue to increase by 5% annually, exacerbating financial pressures.
• Sustainability Impact: Energy efficiency and waste reduction contribute to sustainability goals, enhancing institutional reputation and attracting environmentally conscious students.

Conclusion

Private colleges are navigating an increasingly complex financial landscape, facing pressures from legal rulings on student-athlete compensation and declining enrollment. However, there's significant potential for savings by addressing inefficiencies in areas like waste management, telecom, merchant services, facility supplies, shipping, and energy consumption. Institutions can reduce expenses by 20-40% in these critical areas.

Take Action: Ready to enhance your institution's financial health and invest more in education? Contact Schooley Mitchell for a complimentary, no-obligation assessment. Let data-driven strategies work for your college's bottom line and help navigate the challenges of today's higher education environment.