The fallacy of experimental Physics

The fallacy of experimental Physics

Experiments, albeit useful from a practical perspective, have never advanced theory. The Hubble constant is being pushed, pulled and tweaked by engineers and physicists as if that is going to lead somewhere. The "standard model," was dead on arrival. It is just that tenure seeking academics and measurement driven engineers, will not let it go. Now, the "cosmological crisis," (1) apparently is going to propel the theory to the next level.

It is unlikely. Theory emanates from imagination and not from "precise," measurements. Theory is about the unknown and not the incremental. Theory is about scope and not scale. Theory is about emergence and not process. Theory is about mindless excursions and not planned travel. Theory is about finding connections among the disconnected, Theory is about freedom and not programs. Theory is not about travelling to adjacent planets but conceptualizing what may be beyond. Theory is not exploration of the tangible but the unknown. Theory does not require heavy steel, just paper and pencil. 

Humanity waits for the arrival of the next genius. For over a century, experimentalists roamed the planet with nothing to show. It showcases why the existence of a singular mind at a space-time coordinate defines the trajectory for knowledge. 

We may be stuck. Our more and more "precise," measurements will asymptotically reach complete ignorance.

(1) https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/best-yet-measurements-deepen-cosmological-crisis/

Paul K. Smith 保羅?史密斯

Financier, Producer, Physicist, Neuroscientist, Impresario, and Playwright.

5 年

As you say, "Experiments have never advanced theory."

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Gill Eapen的更多文章

  • Concentrating solar

    Concentrating solar

    Nearly zero cost energy is a real possibility for humans living in close proximity to a large fusion device with…

  • No Artificial Intelligence without Consciousness

    No Artificial Intelligence without Consciousness

    Artificial Intelligence, a nebulous area, has been around from the advent of computers. Every decade, aided by…

    1 条评论
  • Information realism and economic systems

    Information realism and economic systems

    A recent blog (1) that brings attention to information realism in physics with an abstract thought that matter is…

    1 条评论
  • AI and the weakest link

    AI and the weakest link

    The recent debacle in aircraft design is a constant reminder that software engineers and “data scientists,” excited by…

  • Micro customization

    Micro customization

    Recent news (1) that a gastric resident delivery mechanism can deliver reliable, sustainable doses of agents for the…

  • Type 2 Debate

    Type 2 Debate

    A recent article (1) brings the current diagnostic and treatment regimens for those who are deemed to be at risk for…

  • Health

    Health

    News (1) that a group of scientists is attempting to build up a health system in Madagascar from scratch, driven by…

  • Reducing software by hardware

    Reducing software by hardware

    New transistor designs (1) may help surpass the daunting constraints faced by contemporary software as we move toward…

  • AI for the brain

    AI for the brain

    Consciousness, still an undefined construct, may emerge from the brain's attempt to implement AI on its automation…

    1 条评论
  • Poop for depression

    Poop for depression

    It has long been known that the microbiome has a significant influence on the human brain. Now more tactical…

    1 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了