The Fall Of Emerald City: The Hidden Truth of Traditional Retirement Plans

The Alluring Path of False Security is well represented in this timeless story and a rabbit hole well worth investigating, wouldn't you say? Cherished by generations, The Wizard Of OZ subtly reflects the complex world of financial planning and the history of traditional retirement strategies. That's what we discussed on our last livestream, so let's dive in:

Dorothy, a humble girl from Kansas, lost in the Land of Oz, is not unlike many of us trying to navigate the often confusing and overwhelming journey of financial planning. The Yellow Brick Road, the supposed path to success and security, can be likened to traditional retirement plans, while the Wizard himself embodies the illusory promise of these plans.

But what happens when we pull back the emerald curtain? The Wizard's grand facade crumbles to reveal a stark reality, much like the devastating disappointment many face when they realize their retirement plan isn't enough. The Land of Oz with its shimmering promises of security is merely a mirage, as is the supposed certainty offered by conventional financial planning.

Buckle up for a unique tour down the yellow brick road, unveiling when and why traditional retirement plans were introduced into our world, and the lessons we can extract from the fascinating connections to the characters in this beloved tale.

Surrender Dorothy

Dorothy, our starry-eyed dreamer, embodies the average American. Just as Dorothy dreams of a life 'somewhere over the rainbow,' we all dream of a day when we can comfortably retire, whether by choice or by necessity. But how do we ensure we're on the right path?

Dorothy's journey mirrors our own. When we feel lost, we seek advice, often following the most popular or seemingly reliable suggestions without questioning if they are truly the best fit for our situation.

Throughout her journey, Dorothy carries a basket full of things given to her, much like the retirement plans and advice many of us collect along the way. Despite not needing them, we cling to them as they provide a sense of security, a comfort blanket in a complex world.

And just like Dorothy, many of us feel alone and fearful when our financial security is threatened. We place our trust in wizards - the financial advisors, retirement plans, and systems we're told to believe in.

But Dorothy's most profound lesson, and one we can all take to heart, is that she didn't need a wizard. She didn't need to follow the yellow brick road to find her answers. She just needed to become self-directed. In the end, she realized the power to get home, to reach her dreams, was within her all along. And so it is with us. We have the power to take control of our financial futures, to build our own path. We just have to recognize it.

Glinda, the Good Witch

Glittering in her bubble, floating above the rest, enters Glinda, the Good Witch. Her sparkling gown and enchanting smile paint a picture of benevolence. But is she as kind as she appears? In our tale, Glinda stands for the top 1-3% of the wealthy, those who exist in their own bubble, far removed from the mundane struggles of the everyday person.

On the surface, Glinda seems sweet, supportive, and oh-so-wise, guiding Dorothy down the Yellow Brick Road to success. But is that the path Glinda herself trod to amass her wealth? The reality is often glossed over by a veneer of charm and gentle guidance.

Glinda's advice, while well-intended, seems to stem from a place she herself wouldn't dare venture. She sends Dorothy and her companions into dangers she's well aware of, while she floats safely in her bubble. Glinda knew of the Wicked Witch's threats and the Wizard's facades. Yet, she chose to watch the drama unfold from a safe distance, offering her help only when it suited her narrative.

Her constant showering of "toxic positivity" can appear comforting, but beneath that radiant exterior is a striking indifference. She remains largely unbothered by the challenges faced by our protagonists, offering cheer but little practical assistance.

In the end, Glinda swoops in like a last-minute savior, revealing the secret Dorothy had all along. She knew Dorothy possessed the power to return home, yet chose to let her embark on a perilous journey first. Quite a performance, indeed. #ApplausePause

So, the next time you see a "Glinda" floating in her bubble, remember: not all that glitters is gold. Be wary of those who encourage you to tread a path they themselves have not walked. Your journey towards financial success lies not in following someone else's Yellow Brick Road, but in forging your own path.

Munchkin Land

In our Oz-themed tale, the Silent Generation are our metaphorical Munchkins. They reveled in the arrival of pensions and Social Security, their financial fears squashed like the Wicked Witch under Dorothy's house. From their quaint corner of Oz, Munchkinland, they embarked on the glittering Yellow Brick Road—the "American Dream" in its infancy.

Basking in Glinda's protective magic, this generation was the first to traverse the Yellow Brick Road. They proudly proclaimed their journey as a blueprint for financial success, urging others to "just put in the hard work" to enjoy the same rewards. However, their narrative—while inspiring—neglected the evolving economic landscape confronting future generations.

We see reflections of the Silent Generation everywhere today—success stories of the original Yellow Brick Road, but potentially leading others astray with their steadfast belief in its universal promise.

The Scarecrow

This familiar figure was the first "friend" to be introduced in Dorothy's journey. He stands as a symbol for the 1st individual retirement account offered to the public in 1974. Hence, it's name, the IRA. Just like the Scarecrow yearning for a brain, the IRA was seen as a solution—a way to supplement the dwindling pensions.

However, as we follow the story, we learn that the Scarecrow—like the IRA—was a bit of an illusion. It seemed promising, but it was far more beneficial for companies than their employees. Over time, IRAs were even touted as a primary retirement vehicle, a brainy solution to retirement planning.

Yet, the Scarecrow's straw-stuffed head is a perfect metaphor for the IRA's limitations. Many choose an IRA without fully understanding it, much like the Scarecrow blindly wishing for a brain. The truth is, the Scarecrow was always smart—he just needed to realize it. Similarly, people have the power to take control of their retirement—they just need to realize there are more options than the well-trodden path of the IRA.

The Tin Man

The Tin Man, with his metallic exterior and longing for a heart, mirrors the 401k, which was introduced as the second individual retirement vehicle in 1978.

Much like our rust-prone friend who seizes up without his trusty oil can, funds within a 401k feel similarly 'locked up' - rigid and inaccessible without incurring penalties until a certain age. The flexibility we crave in retirement planning often seems as elusive as the Tin Man's graceful dance moves.

In its heartless market conditions, the 401k can cause emotional unrest as we stand by, powerless to the whims of Wall Street. Yet, the promise of future financial stability - the heart that our Tin Man yearns for - keeps us funneling money into these plans, hoping for better days.

The 401k's proverbial 'oil' can be likened to the company match - a benefit not extended to the straw-stuffed Scarecrow (IRA). This match often keeps us going, moving hope just far enough, despite the uncertainty.

But beneath the Tin Man's shiny exterior lies a hidden truth - the real cost of maintaining a 401k. Between management fees, administrative costs, and the potential loss of opportunity, the upkeep of a 401k can feel like an endless oil can, draining our resources.

Cowardly Lion

In the shadowy corners of the financial forest cowers our Cowardly Lion, the embodiment of the Roth IRA – the third individual retirement vehicle introduced in 1997.

Much like the Lion, the Roth was initially eyed with suspicion. It was unfamiliar, it was different, and it seemed to promise more than it could possibly deliver. But, as Dorothy and her companions grew fond of their timorous friend, many started to appreciate the unique benefits of the Roth.

Still, the Roth, like our Lion, requires a certain bravery to face the inherent market risks. Its roars can be strong and triumphant on a profitable day, yet may whimper when the market turns fierce.

While the Roth IRA offers a protective layer against taxes on growth, it can't shield against loss. Like our Lion, who yearned for courage but still needed to confront his fears, investors must bravely face the risk of loss.

Stepping off the beaten path and onto the yellow brick road to self-directed investing might make some see you as a coward, an outsider. But remember, it was the Cowardly Lion who mustered the courage to learn, to grow, and to face his fears. Likewise, taking the initiative to educate yourself on financial literacy, to explore unfamiliar terrain, and to make informed decisions about your financial future is not an act of cowardice – it's an act of courage.

The Emerald City

As Dorothy and her friends follow the Yellow Brick Road, they eventually reach the captivating Emerald City. This glittering metropolis symbolizes the allure of celebrities, influencers, and the material possessions that distract us from achieving genuine financial security. In our story, the Emerald City represents the distractions and temptations that often pull us off course.

Just as our heroes feel closer to their goal, they become enchanted by the city's glamorous facade. They believe they must upgrade their lifestyles and focus on appearances in order to fit in and meet the Wizard. This mindset is reminiscent of the real-world temptation to "keep up with the Joneses," often leading to financial strain.

In the Emerald City, Dorothy and her companions are told they need to be "improved" before they can see the Wizard. This misguided advice reflects society's pressure to conform to certain standards, even at the cost of one's financial well-being.

Consider, for example, going into debt to maintain a certain lifestyle, only to be denied when applying for a home loan. In this case, the pursuit of material possessions and external validation has not only stalled progress but has actively set one back.

Moreover, the sense of impending doom created by the Wicked Witch's threats symbolizes the fear that arises when survival is threatened by a lack of funds. The glitz and glamour of the Emerald City can blind us to the true dangers lurking just beneath the surface.

The Wicked Witch

The Wicked Witch and her posse represent the more sinister aspects of the financial world that can derail our journey towards financial freedom. They are the players that use fear and manipulation to control and profit from the average Dorothy. Here are some examples:

1. Stock Market (Witch), High-Fee Mutual Funds (Flying Monkeys) & Unpredictable Market Conditions (Witch's Army): The stock market itself is neutral, but it's the high-fee investment products and unpredictable market conditions that can cause potential harm to investors' financial health.
2. Big Pharma (Witch), Expensive Medications (Flying Monkeys) & Healthcare System Challenges (Witch's Army): Big Pharma sets high prices for medications, creating financial stress for individuals who need those medications. The broader healthcare system, with its complexity and sometimes lack of transparency, can further exacerbate these issues.
3. IRS (Witch), Complex Tax Laws (Flying Monkeys) & Lack of Financial Literacy (Witch's Army): The IRS itself is simply an entity doing its job. However, complex tax laws can confuse individuals and a lack of financial literacy can lead to people not taking advantage of potential tax benefits.
4. Predatory Lenders (Witch), High-Interest Loans & Credit Cards (Flying Monkeys) & Financial Desperation (Witch's Army): Predatory lenders who take advantage of individuals in desperate financial situations are the real problem, offering high-interest loans and credit cards that can trap people in a cycle of debt.

The Wizard Of "Aughs"

Our journey down the Yellow Brick Road brings us face-to-face with the Wizard himself. Mirroring the large financial institutions such as Vanguard and Fidelity in our real world, the Wizard in our tale seems to hold the keys to our dreams, promising a future filled with financial security and comfort. However, when the curtain is pulled back, we might find ourselves staring at a harsh reality that doesn't quite match up to the picture painted by these financial 'wizards'.

The Grand Disappointment: Remember the disappointment on Dorothy's face when she finally meets the Wizard? The mighty, omnipotent voice turned out to be a mere man, operating an elaborate illusion. This is the very disillusionment many people feel as they approach their golden years. They've followed the advice, made their contributions, trusted the process, and yet, the retirement income they're left with often falls short of what they had envisioned. It's like the moment you see what's truly behind that emerald curtain – a reality that's far less magical than what was promised.

Surviving on Belief Alone: The Wizard's power was in his mystique, his larger-than-life persona, and the unquestioning belief of the citizens of Oz. Similarly, these financial institutions have thrived on the blind faith of countless individuals hoping for a secure future. They don't necessarily deliver superior results; their might is in the perception of their reliability.

The Power to Dictate: Just as the Wizard had the final say in granting requests, these financial institutions hold a disproportionate amount of power in deciding what you can do with your money. They set the rules, often in ways that maximize their benefits at the expense of individual investors.

A Society of Secret Keepers: The Wizard's illusion was upheld by those around him, who either didn't question him or were benefiting from the status quo. Similarly, the actions of financial institutions are often shielded by complex systems and processes, creating a society of secret keepers that maintain the status quo because they too benefit from it.

Shifting the Responsibility: When things didn't go as planned in Oz, the Wizard manipulated the situation, placing the responsibility on Dorothy and her friends to defeat the Wicked Witch. Similarly, financial institutions often shift the blame when market fluctuations affect your investments, placing the onus on you to navigate these choppy waters.

In the end, just as Dorothy and her friends realize that they had the power to achieve their dreams all along, so too do we have the potential to take control of our financial future. It starts with recognizing the true nature of the Wizard and choosing a different path. As we continue our journey 'Straight Outta Oz,' it's time we take control of our own Yellow Brick Road.

Finding Our Way Home:

There's a reason the Wizard of Oz's story has resonated with so many of us, generation after generation. It's a tale of discovery, courage, and, above all, the realization that the power to change our fate lies within us. However, our journey doesn't end here. Much like Dorothy waking up in her bed in Kansas, it's time for us to wake up to the realities of our financial systems and take control of our financial future.

Just as Dorothy had to find her way home, we too need to navigate our way through the financial tornado that has uprooted many of our dreams. It's time to step out of the devastation and into a new dawn of understanding. But how do we begin rebuilding? What tools do we need to erect our financial houses anew?

That's precisely what we'll be uncovering in part 2 of this series. Join us next Tuesday for our live stream as we explore how to wake up, assess the financial landscape, and take the first steps towards a self-directed financial future.

Remember, there's no place like a financially secure home. Let's forge our own 'Emerald Highway,' a path of financial wisdom and independence, shimmering with the promise of a secure future. See you next week, out of Oz and straight into a future of financial empowerment.

Until then, we'd love to hear from you! Your feedback is GOLD to us, so tell us... Do you enjoy this article?

?? Don't forget to follow us both ( Donnell Stidhum & Angelique Stidhum ) and hit our bell ?? to be notified when we go live.

? If you want to learn more about how to become fully self directed visit selfdirected.info