FAHU with VRF Outdoor unit - Should we select the Outdoor at 46 C or 34 C ambient temperature

FAHU with VRF Outdoor unit - Should we select the Outdoor at 46 C or 34 C ambient temperature

Q) In case the FAHU is designed on high latent load condition of 34 C DBT / 32 C WBT – should we select the Outdoor at 46 C design ambient temperature?

A) No. Its optimum to select the Outdoor unit at 34 deg C.

I observe that many consultant engineers make the supplier select the Outdoor at 46 deg C with an assumption that “when this FAHU will run at 46 deg C, the cooling load may be higher leading to higher power input. Therefore If the Outdoor is selected at 34 deg C, it may trip or may not cover the higher cooling load”.

But let me tell you one thing that when the ambient dry bulb temperature is higher, the wet bulb is lower leading to lower latent load and eventually lower total cooling capacity (highlighted as Process 2 in fig 1). The total cooling load at 34 DBT / 32 WBT is higher due to higher latent load (highlighted as Process 1 in fig 1). The outdoor unit selected at 34 C DBT will give enough cooling capacity at 46 DBT to satisfy the load.

The question here is why should we optimise the Outdoor unit selection. By doing this, we will save on connected power input, outdoor unit space and cost as well. Most of the times Building owner in mid rise Residential Buildings suffer with higher operating power and connected Power due to AC services in common area connected to Building owners DB. FAHU becomes a major equipment influencing the connected Electrical load. Also the demand control feature in VRF helps in reducing the operating power in FAHU and at the same time maintaining the acceptable IAQ inside the building.

Your comments are welcome.

Fig 1 - Psychometric chart showing both the process.


Muhammed Afsal T K

HVAC Application Engineer at Gulf Sail General Trading Company

3 周

Selecting a VRF Outdoor Unit at 35°C is the Best Choice for FAHU in UAE. In UAE, FAHU operates under two key conditions: 1. High humidity (34°C DB / 32°C WB) – Maximum latent load, requiring the highest cooling capacity. 2. High temperature (46°C DB / 29.4°C WB) – Lower humidity, reducing the cooling coil load by ~20% to 30%. If the VRF condensing unit is selected at 35°C, it provides full capacity for peak humidity conditions. At 46°C DB, its capacity naturally drops by ~20%, which perfectly matches the FAHU’s reduced cooling load.

回复
Aalok Jain

MEP Project Manager

3 个月

Dharmesh, I agree with your write up. Honestly most of the FAHU are not properly selected in UAE. It's the right way to select FAHU at 34/32, and for selection of Chiller or VRF units , we should run the system through appropriate heat load calculation software to find out the max desired design load Most of the mechanical engineers work with a philosophy of bigger is better, because except for some really knowledge engineers having fundamentals of psychometrics are just knowledgeable on other MEP because consultancy companies don't hire HVAC specialist. There are so many issues in 95% of buildings in UAE due to the wrong selection resulting in higher power inputs to the building, higher humidity, fungus, respiratory disorders. My one criteria while interacting with most of Arabic MEP engineers used to be to assess their knowledge on psychometrics Well i can write whole lot of issues due to poor design.

Well said

回复
Naushar Nazarulla

HVAC Solutions Provider | HVAC Expert | 14 Years of Excellence in Engineering, Commissioning, and Sales | Driving Performance for Global Projects Across 4 Continents

4 个月

In the case of a Fresh Air Handling Unit (FAHU) with 100% fresh air (evaporator coil), my recommendation is to size the coil for ambient conditions of 34/32, This ensures the evaporator coil can effectively handle the latent heat associated with dehumidifying the fresh air. Designing for 46/29 is not ideal for this region due to the high humidity levels and associated latent load. For the outdoor unit, selecting condensing units rated at 34°C dry bulb will result in undercapacity during peak summer conditions. While the unit may perform adequately for 8–9 months of the year in Middle Eastern climates, at ambient temperatures of 46°C or higher, the unit’s capacity will be derated by at least 20% when compared to nominal conditions. Therefore, the ideal selection for condensing units should be based on 46°C ambient temperature. It is important to note that the cooling capacity required at 46/29 is approximately 20–25% lower than the capacity required at 34/32, primarily due to the significantly higher latent load at the latter condition. As such, there is no justification for selecting outdoor units at 34°C dry bulb, as this does not account for the derating and higher cooling demands during peak conditions.

Abdur Rawoof

HVAC ENGINEER - MEP

4 个月

Generally Ambient condition with 0.70 SHR-0.86 SHR, But in High latent condition we better go for low SHR and high LHR. So instead of choosing Peak load condition, Choose the peak Latent load to design FAHU would be a better option to avoid excessive condensation inside the facilities.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Dharmesh Sawant的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了