Facing the Future: Displacement, Upskilling, and New Career Pathways

Introduction

Research and Development (R&D) organisations are essential in driving innovation and technological progress within a company. It’s crucial in developing new technologies, enhancing existing products, and maintaining competitive advantage. In general terms, software developers, architects, testers, project/product managers, data scientists, and many critical roles in innovation are considered under R&D organisation.

R&D organisations are evolving with the rapid advancement of AI. AI technology enables companies to reconstruct their organisations, providing a powerful tool to drive progress and inspire creativity. Rather than simply adding to their existing resources, this technology empowers them to build new solutions from the ground up, unlocking potential and opening up exciting new opportunities for growth and development.

However, alongside these opportunities, pressing ethical concerns and social risks are associated with AI’s integration into organisations. This article explores both AI’s transformative potential and the crucial considerations surrounding its use. It explores how AI reshapes traditional roles and methodologies in R&D while critically examining this technological wave’s societal and ethical impacts.

While this article focuses explicitly on R&D organisations and offshoring/nearshoring business models, considering the broad impact of the AI wave, similar outcomes can be observed in developed countries and broader job markets, e.g. sales, marketing, HR, accounting, etc.

1.?????? Economic Risks for Offshoring/Nearshoring Countries

Offshoring and nearshoring are two strategies businesses use to outsource various operations, including R&D, software development, testing, and support.

Offshoring?refers to relocating business processes or services to a distant country, which offers cost advantages due to lower labour costs or more favourable economic conditions. Common offshoring destinations for R&D and software-related services include India, China, and the Philippines. These countries have large pools of skilled labour and have developed infrastructure to support these industries.

Nearshoring, on the other hand, involves transferring business processes to a nearby country, usually in the same time zone or with cultural similarities. This approach is often chosen for its ease of communication, travel, and cultural compatibility. In the context of R&D and IT services, nearshoring is common in Eastern European countries like Poland, Romania, and Ukraine for Western European businesses and in Mexico, Argentina or Uruguay for US companies.

In the developed countries, many businesses outsource roles such as customer support, data entry, software development and testing to countries where labour is more cost-effective. This business model traditionally brought a mutual benefit and helped offshoring companies and companies receiving this service. However, as AI becomes more capable of performing these services and tasks, the demand for offshoring services may decrease, resulting in reduced pricing of offshoring services and, eventually, redundancies in this space.

“The reduced demand for offshoring services due to AI could lead to job losses and economic downturns in countries and companies where offshoring services contribute a significant portion of the income.”

The economic implications of AI are not just numerical but deeply ethical. As businesses in developed countries potentially benefit from reduced operational expenses and increased profits through AI, a crucial question arises of corporate responsibility towards the global workforce.

Ethical Considerations:

The ethical dimension of this transition is complex. It raises questions about the responsibility of companies towards their global workforce and the balance between technological advancement and social responsibility.

• Global Workforce Impact and Corporate Responsibility: As AI transforms industries, companies must consider their responsibilities towards their global workforce. This includes those directly employed and those in offshoring regions who might be affected by reduced demand for traditional services. There's a moral imperative for companies to balance technological advancement with social responsibility, ensuring that the transition to AI doesn't disproportionately disadvantage certain groups.
• Inequality and Access to Upskilling: The rise of AI might deepen existing inequalities. Not all employees have equal access to upskilling opportunities, which may be influenced by socioeconomic status, education level, and geographic location. Companies and governments should collaborate to ensure equitable training and education access, particularly for vulnerable people.
• Data Privacy and Employee Supervision: With the increasing use of AI, concerns around data privacy and surveillance in the workplace become more apparent. Companies must navigate the fine line between leveraging AI for efficiency and respecting the privacy and autonomy of their employees. Ethical guidelines and regulations should be developed and attached to ensure that AI is used in ways that respect individual rights.
• Long-Term Social Impact: Beyond immediate job displacement, the long-term social impact of AI, such as changes in societal structures and the nature of work, must be considered. This includes evaluating how AI might alter human interactions, work-life balance, and the broader economic landscape. Policymakers and industry leaders need to anticipate and plan for these changes, ensuring that the benefits of AI are distributed fairly across society.
• International Collaboration for Ethical Standards: The ethical challenges of AI in the workplace are not limited to any single country or region. Therefore, encouraging international collaboration to develop and enforce global ethical standards for AI usage is crucial. This collaboration should aim to protect employees' rights, promote inclusivity, and ensure sustainable development in the AI era.

2.?????? Preparing for the Transition

The integration of AI in R&D poses a displacement risk for specific roles, particularly those involving routine and repetitive tasks, such as basic data analysis or manual testing. However, it is important to consider that while AI can automate specific tasks, this doesn’t always directly translate to job losses or reduced offshoring. There are often multiple factors at play, including economic policies, global market dynamics, and the adaptability of the workforce.

This shift also opens up opportunities for upskilling and transitioning into more advanced roles aligned with the evolving technological landscape. Organisations and individuals must focus on continuous learning and adaptability (as it always has to be) to thrive in an AI-driven environment. This involves acquiring new technical skills and developing the ability to work synergistically with AI systems in various capacities.

Impact on Job Markets and Redundancies

Routine and Repetitive Tasks:

• AI is poised to automate tasks traditionally performed by humans, particularly those repetitive or requiring minimal decision-making. Jobs like support or manual testing are prime examples.
• This automation doesn’t imply an overnight disappearance of these roles. Instead, there will be a gradual reduction as AI becomes more efficient and widespread.
• For individuals in these roles, the market will become increasingly competitive. As automation becomes more prevalent, the demand for purely manual or routine jobs will decrease, leading to a tighter job market for these roles.

Opportunities for Upskilling and Transition

• This transition is a phased process, not a sharp shift. During this period, companies and employees have the opportunity to adapt.
• Upskilling becomes mandatory. Employees in roles vulnerable to automation need to acquire new skills that complement AI systems rather than compete with them. This can include learning to work alongside AI, understanding AI systems, or moving into more strategic and analytical roles.
• Companies can play a vital role in this transition by providing training and resources to help their workforce adapt to the changing landscape.

New Career Pathways:

• Transition to AI-Related Fields: Opportunities to move into emerging AI-related roles, such as AI strategy, machine learning engineering, or AI ethics.
• Interdisciplinary Roles: Integrating AI in various fields creates new interdisciplinary roles that combine domain expertise with AI knowledge.

Organisational Support for Transition:

• Forward-thinking organisations are increasingly offering training programs to help employees adapt to changes brought about by AI.

• A prime example is EY, known for its proactive approach to empowering its workforce. EY has developed comprehensive internal training programs and a range of digital badges. These initiatives are designed to educate employees about AI and its applications, ensuring they are equipped with the latest skills and knowledge. In addition to training, EY has established its own AI environment for its employees. By providing an in-house AI environment, EY ensures that employees can leverage AI tools and technologies in a secure and controlled setting, mitigating privacy and data security risks

Conclusion

At the threshold of a new era, it is evident that the incorporation of AI in R&D marks a fundamental transformation in the approach and execution of innovation. As we have seen, this shift transcends traditional boundaries, redefining roles, processes, and organisational structures.

As AI continues to evolve, it challenges us to rethink our approach to innovation. It urges companies to foster a continuous learning and adaptability culture, ensuring their workforce is equipped to use AI and prepared to evolve. This involves promoting an attitude that regards AI as a partner in the creative process, enhancing human ingenuity.

Moreover, this journey brings with it a responsibility to navigate the ethical and societal implications of AI in R&D. As companies venture further into this AI-augmented future, they must do so with a commitment to responsible innovation - one that considers the broader impact of their AI-driven endeavours on society and the environment.

In conclusion, the future of R&D in the age of AI offers a landscape full of opportunities and challenges. However, the message is clear as we look forward: The potential is limitless.

Join the conversation

Share your experiences, insights, or concerns. How has AI reshaped your organisation’s R&D strategies? What ethical considerations do you believe are crucial in this evolving landscape? Do you see potential risks or opportunities that AI brings to traditional roles in R&D?

Disclaimer:

The views, interpretations, and opinions expressed in the article “Facing the Future: Displacement, Upskilling, and New Career Pathways” are solely those of the author and do not represent or reflect the views, policies, or positions of EY or any of its affiliates. The content provided is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as professional advice, endorsement, or recommendation. EY is not responsible for the information’s accuracy, validity, or completeness. Readers are advised to seek independent professional advice before making any decisions based on the content of this article.

References

1. 20 New And Enhanced Roles AI Could Create (forbes.com)
2. The impact of AI on UK jobs and training (publishing.service.gov.uk)
3. Artificial Intelligence’s Impact On Jobs Is Nuanced (forbes.com)
4. How Will Intelligent Automation Impact Employment? (forbes.com)
5. Improving working conditions using Artificial Intelligence (europa.eu)
6. Don’t Fear AI. It Will Lead To Long-Term Job Growth. (forbes.com)
7. c2c1d276-en.pdf (oecd-ilibrary.org)
8. Tech Firms Hold All the Power As Goldman Sachs Predicts AI Job Wipeout (businessinsider.com)
9. Artificial Intelligence Is Already Causing Disruption And Job Losses At IBM And Chegg (forbes.com)
10. The potential of gen AI in maximising cloud value (mckinsey.com)
11. Generative AI: How will it affect future jobs and workflows? | McKinsey
12. AI: 3 ways artificial intelligence will change the future of work | World Economic Forum (weforum.org)
13. AI anxiety: The workers who fear losing their jobs to artificial intelligence - BBC Worklife
14. Building an R&D strategy for modern times | McKinsey
15. The present-focused, future-ready R&D organisation | McKinsey
16. The organisation of the future: Enabled by gen AI, driven by people | McKinsey