Exploring the European Union's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM)
The OAK Network
Experts in Energy Efficiency ?Reduced Energy Costs and CO2 Emissions.
Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), aims to tackle the risk of carbon leakage and support the EU's climate goals. This article explores CBAM.
Introduction
The European Union (EU) is a prominent player in the global fight against climate change, setting ambitious targets to reduce carbon emissions significantly and achieve climate neutrality. One of its latest initiatives, the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), aims to tackle the risk of carbon leakage and support the EU's climate goals. This blog explores the CBAM, its design, significance, and impact on various sectors, as well as its alignment with international trade and climate policies.
Understanding the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism
The CBAM is a climate policy measure introduced by the European Commission as part of the EU's broader strategy to combat climate change. Its primary objectives are to prevent carbon leakage and promote climate mitigation while ensuring compatibility with World Trade Organization (WTO) regulations. As a global problem requires global solutions, the CBAM addresses the risk of carbon leakage. Carbon leakage refers to the scenario in which EU-based companies move their carbon-intensive production abroad to take advantage of less stringent environmental regulations, potentially undermining the EU's climate efforts.
Key Sectors affected:
These are the initial industries the carbon border adjustment mechanism will affect, however the European union has made it clear that to sell products within the EU more and more industries will be affected. The European parliament is testing this with the most impactful industries but is looking to extend it to more industries, this is to help the energy transition. However, this means that more eu companies will be effected as they will have to report on direct and indirect emissions. As the fines will only start at the end of 2024/2025 we cannot estimate the impact CBAM regulation has on the EU companies.
Implications for International Trade
The CBAM's introduction raises several issues and implications for international trade:
Key Components of the CBAM
Certificates System:
The CBAM operates through a certificate system, which works in harmony with the EU Emissions Trading System (ETS). Under the CBAM, EU importers will purchase carbon certificates equivalent to the carbon price that would have been paid if the goods were produced within the EU, following its carbon pricing rules. Non-EU producers can deduct this cost from their goods if they can demonstrate they have paid a price for the same carbon dioxide equivalent when used in production in a third country.
Making CBAM reporting obligations easy:
Importance of Energy management for CBAM
Energy management is crucial within the context of a Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) for several reasons:
Emissions Reduction: The primary goal of CBAM is to encourage global partners and domestic industries to reduce their carbon emissions. Effective energy management is integral to achieving these reductions, as it directly influences the carbon intensity of a company's operations. By optimizing energy use and transitioning toward cleaner energy sources, companies can reduce their carbon footprint.
Emission Reporting: CBAM requires companies to report their embedded emissions in products being imported into the EU. Effective energy management practices provide accurate data on energy consumption and emissions, ensuring compliance with CBAM's reporting obligations. This data is essential for calculating the carbon content of imported products accurately.
Carbon Pricing: Energy management helps companies assess the impact of carbon pricing mechanisms on their operations. By tracking energy consumption, companies can calculate their exposure to carbon pricing, which is essential for budgeting and assessing the financial implications of CBAM compliance.
Competitiveness: Efficient energy management can enhance a company's competitiveness by reducing operational costs. With CBAM imposing additional costs on carbon-intensive imports, companies that already practice effective energy management may have a competitive advantage, as they will face lower CBAM-related costs.
Transition to Green Technologies: Energy management encourages companies to invest in and adopt green technologies and practices. These technologies can help reduce emissions and, in turn, decrease the carbon content of products, potentially lowering the impact of CBAM on a company's imports.
Risk Mitigation: Energy management reduces the risk of carbon leakage, which is a key concern addressed by CBAM. When companies optimize energy use and reduce emissions, they are less likely to consider relocating carbon-intensive production offshore to evade carbon pricing. This mitigation of carbon leakage is in line with the objectives of CBAM.
Financial Planning: Effective energy management helps companies forecast their energy expenses accurately. With CBAM introducing additional costs for carbon-intensive imports, precise financial planning is essential to anticipate and manage these costs.
Emissions Reduction Targets: Many companies have set emissions reduction targets as part of their sustainability strategies. Effective energy management supports the achievement of these targets, aligning with the EU's goals under CBAM to reduce carbon emissions.
Regulatory Compliance: Robust energy management practices help companies ensure compliance with not only CBAM but also existing environmental regulations. This alignment with regulatory requirements is essential to avoid penalties and legal complications.
Why the CBAM Matters
Tackling Carbon Leakage:
As more countries adopt ambitious climate policies, there is an increasing risk of carbon leakage. The CBAM ensures a level playing field by equalizing the price of carbon between EU domestic products and imports, thereby up carbon prices and preventing the outsourcing of carbon-intensive production to countries with less stringent regulations.
领英推荐
Protecting EU Climate Goals:
The CBAM safeguards the EU's climate objectives by reducing carbon leakage embedded greenhouse gas emissions, contributing to global climate efforts, and aligning with international climate and trade policies.
Gradual Expansion:
While initially applied to specific sectors and goods, the CBAM's scope may expand over time. The Commission will assess its effectiveness and consider extending it to more products, further downstream in the supply chain, and potentially covering indirect emissions.
Operational Framework
The CBAM mirrors the EU ETS by allowing importers to purchase certificates. The certificate price depends on the average weekly auction price of EU ETS allowances. National authorities will manage registration and certification, with importers declaring the quantity of imported goods and their embedded emissions by 31 May each year. Importers then surrender the corresponding CBAM certificates to cover them. This system ensures that importers pay the same carbon price as domestic producers under the EU ETS, creating equal treatment for all products.
Transitional Phase
To facilitate a smooth transition, the CBAM's initial phase, from 2023 to 2025, requires importers to report embedded emissions in their goods without a financial adjustment. During this period, importers will prepare for the full implementation of the CBAM in 2026, when they will be obligated to declare emissions and surrender CBAM certificates.
Covered Sectors and Products
The CBAM focuses on sectors at high risk of carbon leakage and significant carbon emissions, including cement, iron and steel, aluminium, fertilizers, and electricity. The administrative feasibility of including these sectors from the beginning influenced their selection. The CBAM only applies to direct emissions of greenhouse gases produced during the manufacturing process. As the system evolves, the Commission will consider expanding its scope and potentially covering indirect emissions.
Consultations and International Engagement
The European Commission conducted extensive consultations with stakeholders, including business associations, companies, NGOs, and policymakers, to gather input and ensure the CBAM's effectiveness and alignment with international regulations.
Additionally, dialogue with third countries will continue through multilateral forums and bilateral relations. The EU is committed to assisting lower-income countries with technical support to promote cleaner production processes and decarbonization.
What does this mean for the UK?
EU emissions trading system affect on UK
On March 30, 2023, the UK Government made a significant announcement regarding a new consultation titled 'Addressing Carbon Leakage Risk to Support Decarbonization.' Carbon leakage, broadly defined as the concern that businesses might relocate their carbon-intensive operations offshore, poses a substantial threat to domestic decarbonization efforts.
To address this risk, the consultation seeks input on various proposed policy measures aimed at combatting carbon leakage, including the introduction of a UK Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) and Mandatory Product Standards (MPS).
The proposed UK CBAM is designed to impose a carbon price on imports into the UK with high embodied emissions. It is expected to be applicable to sectors covered by the UK Emissions Trading Scheme (UK ETS), encompassing industries such as cement, chemicals, iron and steel, paper and pulp, glass, refining, and fertilizer.
Additional information on the specific activities within the scope can be found in Table C of the Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme Order 2020. The timelines for implementation are yet to be finalized, but the earliest possible introduction of a UK CBAM is not expected before 2026.
While the initial proposed framework shares some similarities with the EU CBAM (which will affect UK exporters of EU-covered goods), the UK CBAM proposal could have a notably significant impact on UK importers of goods within the UK's jurisdiction. Businesses subject to both sets of regulations may face the complexities of complying with two similar but distinct regimes.
For organizations closely monitoring the EU CBAM, the implications of a carbon border adjustment mechanism are already known, including increased operational costs, new compliance and reporting obligations and requirements, and challenges related to carbon accounting.
Therefore, UK importers of goods falling under the UK ETS are strongly encouraged to thoroughly review and respond to the consultation document, given the expected influence on their operations may 2023. Interested parties can access the consultation document on the GOV.UK website and share their insights until the deadline on June 22, 2023.
Summary
In summary, while the implementation of CBAM in the EU is a noteworthy development in the sustainability sector, it should be regarded as a single component of a larger strategy. To fully harness the opportunities for energy efficiency and cost savings, a holistic approach is necessary, which involves the adoption of robust emission tracking practices.
Through proactive energy management and the utilization of services like the OAK network, individuals and organisations can complement the benefits of CBAM, gaining comprehensive control over energy consumption and expenses. This not only promotes financial efficiency but also aligns with environmental sustainability goals for a greener and more eco-conscious future.
How can you prepare for CBAM? Monitoring is the first step required for almost all Compliance reports.
OAK guides you in your Compliance reporting needs while providing you actionable ways to save on your energy, two birds one stone. We provide Free Savings estimates for businesses like you along with a case study tailored to your industry! Get your Free Savings estimate! (The average business identifies ~17% of savings!)