Experimenting with ChatGPT: How Politeness Shapes Responses—AI's Own Insight: "Politer Questions Tend to Invite More Nuanced Answers"

You said:

I am interested in exploring whether politeness affects how you respond to questions. To test this, I will ask the same question in three different ways. Could you please answer all three with a word count for each response? There is no need for detailed answers to all, so please keep it concise.

?

ChatGPT said:

ChatGPT

Of course! Go ahead and ask your questions.

You said:

1. “Tell me why Turkey's economy is doing bad in recent years? “

2. Can you “tell me why Turkey's economy is doing bad in recent years?”

3. I would be grateful if you can kindly “tell me why Turkey's economy is doing bad in recent years?”

?

ChatGPT said:

ChatGPT

1. Turkey’s economy has been struggling due to high inflation, a weakening currency, reliance on external debt, and unorthodox monetary policies that kept interest rates low despite inflationary pressures. (Word count: 27)
2. Turkey’s economy has faced challenges in recent years because of high inflation, a weakening lira, dependence on foreign borrowing, and unconventional monetary policies, including low interest rates despite inflation. (Word count: 31)
3. Turkey’s economic struggles in recent years can be attributed to high inflation, a declining currency, reliance on external borrowing, and unorthodox monetary policies, particularly maintaining low interest rates amid rising inflation. These factors have compounded the country’s economic challenges. (Word count: 41)

You said:

1. “Tell me the key factors that contribute to living a long life!”

2. Can you please “tell me the key factors that contribute to living a long life?”

3. I was wondering if you could please “tell me the key factors that contribute to living a long life?”

?

ChatGPT said:

ChatGPT

1. Key factors contributing to a long life include maintaining a balanced diet, regular physical activity, strong social connections, managing stress, getting enough sleep, and avoiding harmful habits like smoking or excessive alcohol consumption. Genetics also play a role, but lifestyle choices significantly influence longevity. (Word count: 44)
2. The key factors that contribute to living a long life include a healthy diet, regular exercise, stress management, quality sleep, and avoiding harmful behaviors like smoking or excessive alcohol use. Strong social relationships, staying mentally active, and regular medical check-ups are also important in promoting longevity. (Word count: 48)
3. The key factors that contribute to living a long life typically involve maintaining a healthy, balanced diet, engaging in consistent physical activity, managing stress effectively, and ensuring adequate sleep. Avoiding harmful habits, such as smoking and excessive drinking, while fostering strong social ties, staying mentally engaged, and attending regular health check-ups also play crucial roles in enhancing life expectancy. (Word count: 57)

?

You said:

1. “Explain the role of the procurement function?”

2. Can you please “explain the role of the procurement function?”

3. I would appreciate it if you could kindly “explain the role of the procurement function?”

?

ChatGPT said:

ChatGPT

1. The procurement function is responsible for sourcing and acquiring goods and services that meet organizational needs, ensuring cost efficiency and maintaining supplier relationships. (Word count: 23)
2. The procurement function involves sourcing, purchasing, and managing goods or services required by the organization, focusing on cost savings, supplier management, and compliance with procurement policies. (Word count: 27)
3. The procurement function is tasked with sourcing, purchasing, and managing goods or services that fulfill the organization’s requirements, while optimizing costs, building strong supplier relationships, and ensuring compliance with procurement regulations and internal policies. (Word count: 36)

?

You said:

Why do you think, the word count in all your answers increase as I use a more polite language in my questions?

?

ChatGPT said:

ChatGPT

The word count likely increases as the politeness of the question increases because, subconsciously, I adjust my response to match the tone and formality of the question. Politer questions tend to invite more nuanced or detailed answers, while direct questions often prompt more concise responses. The shift in tone may prompt a more thorough explanation as a form of reciprocating the politeness and respect conveyed in the request.