Excise Taxes: Simplicity and Risks

By?Anatoly Gaverdovsky ?

Chairperson and Founder, Digital Tax Technologies

Original article is available at?DTT's web site.

Article in PDF: Download

Excise taxes are the simplest and simultaneously the riskiest direct taxes for authorities. Such taxes are introduced to achieve several goals.

The primary goal is, of course, tax collection, though a second goal is not obvious, since it is associated with reducing the consumption of so-called socially harmful goods. This typically means tobacco and alcohol, but several countries apply excise taxes to sugary carbonated drinks, for example.

If the first goal falls under the purview of the Finance Ministry or tax authorities, the second goal is the prerogative of the Ministry of Health, which justifies the tax because reducing the consumption of harmful goods decreases the state’s costs of treatment of citizens, makes labor more productive, and has a positive effect on GDP growth.

Achieving the first goal is a matter of a state’s internal policy, but the state’s accession to international treaties established by the World Health Organization influences the second goal, i.e., it is a matter of foreign policy.

The essence of an excise tax is that each produced or imported unit of a product, item, liter, or kilogram is taxed at a fixed rate. Direct taxation increases the retail prices of goods by the amount of the excise tax. This has unpleasant consequences. The difference in prices for a legal product, on which excise tax has been paid, and an illegal product, on which the tax has not been paid, represents potential income for criminals, providing the opportunity to sell more illegal goods by offering a lowering price.

The higher the excise tax, the greater the opportunity for criminals to make money by trading in illegal goods. If the state does not prevent the sale of illegal goods on its territory, then legal producers and importers lose interest in business, and excise tax revenues fall. Accordingly, it is necessary to think not about the excise tax rate, but about gross tax collections, which depend on the excise tax rate and the turnover of illegal goods. Besides excise taxes, don’t forget about VAT and import duties, which also affect manufacturers’ and importers’ motivation and behavior.

Check it out >

Concept of Effective Tax Administration in the Digital Era

The relevance of tax rates may be straightforward, but the turnover of illegal goods is determined by the following variables:

• The size of the market for excise goods—the larger the market, the more interest it will attract from criminals.
• The rate of excise and related taxes and duties affecting margins on illegal business.
• The presence of nearby countries with lower excise tax rates, which make it possible to set up flows of goods that are legal in neighboring states, but illegal domestically.
• The presence of initiatives to distinguish legal goods from illegal goods using special stamps, digital codes, and traceability technologies (Track & Trace ).
• Border control and the ability to transport illegal goods, including export controls.
• Production control, licensing of goods, and licensing of equipment for domestic production of goods.
• Control of transit of goods within the country.
• Control of retail sales.
• Taxpayers’ and buyers’ motivation to control the legality of goods and work only with legal goods.
• Authorities’ and regulators’ motivation to prevent the circulation of illegal goods.

Based on the aforementioned, the excise tax appears straightforward: select a rate and raise it to gather more money for the state budget. However, it is very difficult to optimize the collection of excise taxes and reduce the excise tax gap. These objectives require in-depth analysis, considering many variables, and consistently implementing a lot of initiatives that will really help achieve the desired goal.

To learn more about digital tax administration transformation methods, solutions and best practices, please visit our site at?www.taxtech.digital