Evan, the poor have big mouths too
Food for Thought at the Paul Writer office

Evan, the poor have big mouths too

Snapchat's founder, Evan Spiegel, allegedly made a conscious decision not to enter 'poor' markets such as India and Spain a couple of years ago. From a business standpoint, for a company that relies on advertising revenue, it makes sense. Since the eyeballs in India have relatively little spending power, the money brands are willing to spend to acquire these eyeballs is also a fraction of what they spend on a rich one. And yet the effort to acquire both the eyeball and the adspend are similar. Digital ad spend in India is expected to touch $1 billion this year, while much smaller Australia's was $6.8 billion in 2016. Given that Snapchat's marketshare of that spend is small even in the US, it makes sense to avoid over-exposure. 

On the other hand saying that India is poor is clearly not a good step from a reputation perspective. Snapchat's stock fell by 1.5%, not a big deal, but I'm surprised there was an actual impact at all. Lots of people - who don't use Snapchat - seem to have a lot of time and inclination to be angsty about these things, a really big voice on social media. And so Snapchat is trying to undo the damage by denying it, and launching India-specific filters. Spain, on the other hand, seems to have kept its mouth shut and thoroughly ignored the comment. No pacifiers have been announced for the poor folks there.

One of the big challenges for corporate reputation professionals is that we all have big mouths. Including CEOs. So the organization has a vision, a mission and carefully crafts a whole strategy around it. And then the CEO opens their mouth and talks about something which wasn't discussed in any briefing! 

When you're a startup the organization relies on the founders to build its brand. Social media gives you an unprecedented platform to do so, and it rewards those who are interesting or, well, controversial. But once the organization becomes a brand in its own right this same frankness and desire for public speaking can be a detriment. You have to delink the brand's authenticity and personality from that of any one individual. Because despite certain exceptions - Richard Branson comes to mind - the bigger the mouth the more likely the foot will fit.

This is one reason Reputation (aren't they called PR any more?) professionals - and of course CEOs - need to know marketing. Every element of marketing has potential for a positive or negative impact on reputation, and unless you not just understand but have a say in it you will not be able to do much more than (a) tell the official story (b) pull the foot off the mouth and do damage control. With the decline in influence of traditional media PR professionals have had to look at online influence and eyeballs and in my view that will require them to work ever more closely with marketing. If you're wondering, yes, I've handled PR for Infosys, iGATE and Wipro Technologies, though in a much simpler age.  You can view my deck here.


要查看或添加评论,请登录

Jessie Paul的更多文章

  • New title alert - podcaster :)

    New title alert - podcaster :)

    Yo! I want to talk about my new podcast. And it is connected to jumping off the escalator life and getting onto the…

    10 条评论
  • Why Yardley smells better than Bath & Body Works today

    Why Yardley smells better than Bath & Body Works today

    Yo! My loyalty to Wipro as a former CMO made me buy Yardley handwash. Nah, not quite.

    5 条评论
  • Kanye and the Wild West of AI & Inclusivity

    Kanye and the Wild West of AI & Inclusivity

    Yo! Kanye West aired an ad during Super Bowl that had a link to a site that sold Swastika t-shirts labeled HH. The site…

    2 条评论
  • 30% less is great marketing

    30% less is great marketing

    Yo! The OpenAI rival from China has trashed share markets and pretty much broken the internet. All DeepSeek had to do…

  • I want to bill like Simon Sinek. Not Infosys.

    I want to bill like Simon Sinek. Not Infosys.

    Yo! When I joined Infosys in 1998 my salary more than doubled from my previous job at Ogilvy Advertising. Advertising…

    14 条评论
  • Instant Happiness in 2025? Not.

    Instant Happiness in 2025? Not.

    Yo! Last year AI was still shiny and full of promise. I'm already in the trough of disillusionment as a consumer.

    8 条评论
  • Is Kim Kardashian's Bot Prophetic

    Is Kim Kardashian's Bot Prophetic

    Yo! I'm in a cab and the driver suggests we deviate from the map provided by Google as his colleagues have suggested a…

  • Is Blinkit driving us to desperation

    Is Blinkit driving us to desperation

    Yo! I found the interactive print ad announcing the launch of Flipkart Minutes charming. Something the family could do…

    12 条评论
  • Elon or Dee? Let's eat strawberries.

    Elon or Dee? Let's eat strawberries.

    Yo! The teen cast an eye at Buckingham Palace as she and I drove in a modern Black Cab (so awesome!) to the Taj St…

    1 条评论
  • Blinkit Sari and the 10 minute itch

    Blinkit Sari and the 10 minute itch

    Yo! I am back from celebrating Durga Puja in Kolkata - now billed as the world's largest global public art festival…

    19 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了