European Union Enlargement to Ukraine

Possibilities and Desirability in a New World Order

Abstract??

This essay examines the feasibility and desirability of Ukraine's EU membership amid Russia's 2022 invasion. It highlights the strategic importance of this enlargement for both Ukraine and the EU, emphasizing security benefits and economic opportunities, particularly in agriculture. The challenges of integrating Ukraine, including economic disparities, refugee crises, and internal EU divisions, are discussed and the need for EU reforms to accommodate Ukraine and provide credible defense guarantees are stressed. Ultimately, the essay concludes that despite significant obstacles, Ukraine's membership aligns with the EU’s values and strategic goals, reinforcing its commitment to democracy, security, and unity of the transatlantic alliance.?

European Union Enlargement to Ukraine: Is it Possible and/or Desirable??

The prospect of Ukraine joining the European Union (EU) has garnered significant attention, particularly in the wake of Russia’s aggressive military actions and the ensuing geopolitical shifts. Therefore, it is of utmost importance that the feasibility and desirability of Ukraine's EU membership are assessed, considering the various perspectives and potential implications for Europe, Ukraine, and the broader international community.?

The European Union was born out of a desire for peace, human rights, and democracy following the unprecedented violence and atrocities of World War II.1 The ongoing conflict in Ukraine only underscores these values, reinforcing the EU’s commitment to supporting countries that aspire to European standards of governance and human rights. Nevertheless, the geopolitical and security implications of Ukraine's EU membership are profound.??

The European Neighbourhood Policy (ENP) was designed to address new opportunities and threats posed by EU enlargement, aiming to foster stability and security on the EU's borders2 and Ukraine's integration into the EU would extend these stabilizing effects further east, providing a buffer against Russian aggression and promoting regional security.3 Economic and humanitarian considerations are also paramount, as the EU’s approach has historically combined conditionality and socialization, encouraging reforms through a mix of rewards and reputational pressure.4 For Ukraine, the potential economic benefits of EU membership are significant, offering access to the single market and fostering economic growth. However, the costs of adaptation to EU standards are high, and the EU must be prepared to support Ukraine through this transformative process.5?

Regarding political and institutional challenges, the EU’s expansion strategy involves stringent requirements for membership, including adherence to democratic principles, human rights, and good governance6. Ukraine’s path to membership, thus, requires significant reforms and alignment with the acquis communautaire, the body of EU law. The process is rigorous and designed to ensure that new members are fully prepared to meet the obligations and enjoy the benefits of EU membership. Assessing the possibility and desirability of Ukraine's integration requires, therefore, a profound understanding of the liberal values, involved strategic interests, and the significant efforts needed for Ukraine to meet membership criteria. By addressing these hurdles, the EU becomes able and prepared to support Ukraine’s European aspirations while reinforcing its own commitment to peace, stability, and prosperity in the region.?

Historical Context and Current War Situation?

Ukraine's pursuit of EU membership traces back to longstanding aspirations for closer alignment with Western democratic values, a trajectory significantly accelerated by the Russian invasion of 2022. The invasion served as a stark catalyst, galvanizing Ukraine's resolve to distance itself from Russia's authoritarian orbit and embrace the principles of liberal democracy.7 In response to Ukraine's swift application for EU membership following the invasion, the European Commission, under the leadership of Ursula von der Leyen, promptly recommended acceptance, signaling the urgency and strategic significance of this enlargement.8 Despite the exceptional circumstances characterized by ongoing occupation and persistent threats, negotiations commenced in December 2023, underscoring the imperative of integrating Ukraine into the EU fold.?

The EU's expansion to encompass Ukraine transcends mere territorial integration, constituting a strategic riposte to Russia's belligerent policies. The invasion of Ukraine laid bare Russia's ambitions to reassert hegemony over former Soviet territories, posing an existential challenge to European stability and security. Recognizing the vital to counter Putin's expansionist agenda, the EU and its allies are compelled to unite to prevent further destabilization in Eastern Europe and its periphery, driven by their commitment to liberal values.?

The conflict in Ukraine underscores the indispensability of a unified Western response, epitomized by the cohesion exhibited within the transatlantic alliance comprising the EU and NATO. This solidarity was palpably reaffirmed at the Washington Summit, where discussions revolved around enhancing Ukraine's defense capabilities through robust security packages.9 Concurrently, concerted efforts to isolate aggressive authoritarian regimes, exemplified by Russia's exclusion from key international security frameworks, underscore the West's steadfast commitment to upholding democratic norms and deterring aggression.?

Geopolitical and Security Implications?

The potential inclusion of Ukraine in the European Union also marks a significant transformation in the geopolitical dynamics of Europe, offering both prospects and threats in security and defense realms. Integrating Ukraine into the EU involves extending borders closer to Russia, necessitating a reassessment of security measures to thwart potential threats. This underscores Europe's urgency to enhance military capabilities and assert strategic autonomy.?

Consequently, the EU has initiated military modernization efforts, augmenting defense budgets, and fortifying security frameworks to effectively confront Russian encroachments.10 Notably, the adoption of exclusionary policies towards Russia underscores the EU's determination to assert itself as a robust security actor in the region. This collective stance, driven by moral obligation and strategic necessity, highlights the importance of stability and deterring further Russian expansionism. The consensus among EU member states to dedicate 2.5% of GDP towards enhancing Ukraine's military capabilities demonstrates tangible commitment to this shared security objective.11?

The security implications of Ukraine's potential EU membership are vast, necessitating comprehensive defense strategies to safeguard Eastern borders and deter potential threats, which is why strengthening military capabilities and enhancing border security emerges is key. Germany, as a pivotal EU member, plays a central role in shaping and executing these policies, as the conflict in Ukraine has prompted Germany to reassess its defense strategies, resulting in substantial investments in military modernization and a departure from traditional military intervention taboos.12 The establishment of a €100 billion fund for procuring new military equipment underscores Germany's commitment to leading Europe's defense initiatives and reinforcing the EU's security posture in a rapidly evolving geopolitical landscape.13?

Economic and Humanitarian Considerations??

The economic and social dimensions of Ukraine's potential accession to the European Union present a complex interplay of opportunities and challenges, underscoring the intricacies inherent in the incorporation process. Specifically, Ukraine's agricultural prowess, often dubbed the "breadbasket of Europe," positions it as a key player in global food security. Integration into the EU holds the promise of enhancing food security and agricultural productivity within the Union. Leveraging Ukraine's agricultural potential can bolster the EU's self-sufficiency in food production. However, this integration requires careful calibration to prevent disruptions in the EU's agricultural markets. Balancing the influx of Ukrainian agricultural products with existing member states' production capabilities is essential to prevent market destabilization and ensure equitable outcomes.14?

Conversely, humanitarian implications of Ukraine's EU membership are profound, particularly regarding the refugee crisis stemming from the conflict.15 Managing the influx of refugees and maintaining social stability present significant difficulties for the EU, exacerbated by the potential occupation of Ukraine, which could strain refugee reallocation mechanisms and social cohesion frameworks. Robust contingency planning and proactive measures are fundamental to uphold humanitarian principles and effectively manage the fallout. Additionally, addressing economic disparities between Ukraine and existing EU member states is critical for fostering inclusive growth and social cohesion.16 Ukraine's potential status as the largest and potentially the poorest EU member underscores the need for tailored support mechanisms to facilitate integration. Effective redistribution strategies and targeted investments are essential to bridge economic gaps and ensure equitable benefits from European integration.?

Political and Institutional Challenges??

Ukraine's membership to EU also brings significant political and institutional implications, requiring a comprehensive approach for sustainable integration. Progress demands rigorous political reforms in Ukraine and the EU. Despite conflict, Ukraine has made notable reform strides, earning EU praise.17 However, sustaining this and meeting accession criteria needs unwavering support. EU consensus-building faces challenges, with opposition to Ukrainian agricultural imports highlighting balancing national interests.18 Reform is essential for accommodating Ukraine, requiring adjustments in decision-making processes, budget allocations, and effective crisis management to address the refugee fallout. In this context, Germany is recalibrating its defense strategies to support Ukraine and strengthen EU solidarity, emphasizing collective action to uphold European values and security amidst Russian threats.?

Vladimir Putin's Russia embodies the emergence of "illiberal democracy," posing a direct test to the liberal democratic principles championed by the EU.19 Supporting Ukraine's EU aspirations is strategically significant, highlighting a contrast between Ukraine's democratic values and Russia's authoritarianism. Despite Putin's divisive efforts, including backing right-wing populism and exploiting energy dependencies, a united EU remains committed to Ukraine, reinforcing regional stability and democratic norms.?

Strategic Implications and Future Outlook?

Integrating Ukraine into the European Union has profound strategic implications beyond mere geographical expansion, as it fortifies Europe's eastern flank amidst resurgent Russian assertiveness and geopolitical tensions.20??

The EU's swift response to Ukraine's membership bid amid conflict signals a strategic shift, prioritizing geopolitical needs. This adaptability balances strategic interests and regional stability.??

However, effective assimilation requires maintaining internal coherence by addressing economic disparities, revisiting decision-making mechanisms, and fostering consensus among member states. Economic convergence and institutional reform are crucial for sustaining and unifying an expanded EU. Ultimately, the enlargement process serves as a litmus test for the EU's ability to reconcile diverse interests and forge a common path forward, highlighting the indispensable of collective action in confronting shared issues and advancing the Union's strategic objectives on the global stage.21 Thus, as the EU continues to navigate the intricate landscape of incorporation, it must remain steadfast in its commitment to fostering unity, resilience, and prosperity, both within its borders and its transatlantic alliances.?

Conclusion??

The prospect of Ukraine joining the European Union represents a pivotal moment in European history, one fraught with both promise and challenge. While the benefits of such an enlargement are evident, including bolstered security for the continent and affirmation of Ukraine's democratic aspirations, the journey towards integration is laden with complexities that demand careful navigation. Ukraine's integration brings significant economic adversities that necessitate substantial reforms as Ukrainian economy, while resilient, requires alignment with EU standards, including regulatory frameworks, infrastructure enhancement, creating a favorable business environment for foreign investment, addressing corruption, and improving governance are critical for both EU accession and Ukraine's own prosperity.22?

Politically, EU expansion raises concerns about maintaining cohesion while absorbing new members. Internal divisions among member states complicate matters; some advocate caution due to resource strains, while others push for swift integration to counterbalance Russian influence. Balancing these perspectives is imperative for sustainable expansion.23 Institutionally, integrating Ukraine requires addressing geopolitical implications, notably the conflict in Eastern Ukraine and Russia's annexation of Crimea.24 Enhancing defense cooperation and supporting Ukraine's sovereignty are paramount. The EU must engage with Russia cautiously, balancing mutual interests with its commitments to Ukraine.??

Beyond immediate confrontations, EU’s incorporation of Ukraine tests the Union's core values and future direction, reaffirming the EU's commitment to democracy and human rights amid authoritarian threats. Embracing Ukraine strengthens the EU geopolitically and reaffirms its role as a champion of liberal democracy globally.25??

Finally, the feasibility and desirability for enlarging EU to include Ukraine represents a defining moment for European integration. While the road ahead may be fraught with obstacles, the rewards are equally substantial. By navigating the complexities with foresight and determination, the EU can emerge stronger, more resilient, and true to its founding principles. By embracing Ukraine, the EU charts a course towards a more secure, democratic, and prosperous future for all its members. As Maryna Mykhaylenko declared at the 32nd International Meeting in Political Studies, supporting Ukraine is fortifying the European Union’s frontline in the Russo-Ukrainian war.26?

Bibliography?

1. Franco, Lívia. "A Ucrania e a Europa, dois anos depois."

2. European External Action Service. "The war against Ukraine and European security." European Union External Action Service, 23 January 2024, Retrieved June 13,2024, from?https://www.eeas.europa.eu/eeas/war-against-ukraine-and-european-security_en

3. European Bank for Reconstruction and Development. (n.d.). The reconstruction and development of Ukraine's financial sector after the war. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://www.ebrd.com/documents/oce/the-reconstruction-and-development-of-ukraines-financial-sector-after-the-war.pdf

4. European Commission. (n.d.). EU enlargement. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://commission.europa.eu/strategy-and-policy/policies/eu-enlargement_en

5. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. (n.d.). Global Fracture: The New International Disorder. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://carnegie-production-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/static/files/Tellis_Global%20Fracture_final%20(1).pdf

6. European Commission. (2022). Statement by President von der Leyen on the Commission's recommendation to open accession negotiations with Montenegro. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/hu/statement_22_3822

7. Department of Defense. (2020). Biden administration announces new security assistance for Ukraine. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://www.defense.gov/News/Releases/Release/Article/3787579/biden-administration-announces-new-security-assistance-for-ukraine/

8. European Defence Agency. (2023, November 30). Record high European defence spending boosted by procurement of new equipment. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://eda.europa.eu/news-and-events/news/2023/11/30/record-high-european-defence-spending-boosted-by-procurement-of-new-equipment

9. EPP Group. (n.d.). Give 0.25% of GDP for Ukraine's victory. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://www.eppgroup.eu/newsroom/give-0-25-of-gdp-for-ukraine-s-victory

10. Daehnhardt, P. (2024). Presented at the 32nd International Meeting in Political Studies, Estoril Conference: "Ukraine, Russia and the West"

11. German Federal Government. (n.d.). Special fund for the Federal Armed Forces. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://www.bundesregierung.de/breg-en/news/special-fund-federal-armed-forces-2047910

12. Glauben, T., Svanidze, M., G?tz, L., Prehn, S., Jamali Jaghdani, T., Duric, I., & Kuhn, L. (2022). The war in Ukraine, agricultural trade, and risks to global food security. Intereconomics, 57(3), JEL: Q13, Q17, Q18. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://www.intereconomics.eu/contents/year/2022/number/3/article/the-war-in-ukraine-agricultural-trade-and-risks-to-global-food-security.html

13. UNHCR. "Ukraine Emergency." UNHCR,?www.unrefugees.org/emergencies/ukraine/ ?

14. Akhvlediani, T., & Movchan, V. (February 2024). Policy Paper: The Impact of Ukraine’s Accession on the EU’s Economy - The Value Added of Ukraine. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://cdn.ceps.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/ICDS_Policy_Paper_The_Impact_of_Ukraines_Accession.pdf ?

15. European Commission. (November 8, 2023). Key findings of the 2023 Report on Ukraine. Brussels. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/es/qanda_23_5631 ?

16. Koffman, J. (2023). Fracturing Solidarity: The Grain Trade Dispute Between Ukraine and the European Union. Center for Strategic and International Studies. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://www.csis.org/analysis/fracturing-solidarity-grain-trade-dispute-between-ukraine-and-european-union

17. Puddington, A. (2017). Breaking Down Democracy: Goals, Strategies, and Methods of Modern Authoritarians. Freedom House. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://freedomhouse.org/report/special-report/2017/breaking-down-democracy-goals-strategies-and-methods-modern-authoritarians

18. NATO. (2023). NATO Eastern Flank Debate Highlights Alliance's Resilience Amidst Polish Independence Day Celebrations. Retrieved June 13, 2024,? from?https://shape.nato.int/news-archive/2023/nato-eastern-flank-debate-highlights-alliances-resilience-amidst-polish-independence-day-celebrations

19. Ocvirk, Ma?a. (2024, April 25). Balancing Act: Charting the Course for EU Enlargement and Reform. Wilson Center. Retrieved June 13, 2024,? from?https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/balancing-act-charting-course-eu-enlargement-and-reform

20. European Economic and Social Committee. (2024, May 31). Strong and inclusive cohesion policy is key to a successful EU enlargement. European Economic and Social Committee Press Releases. Retrieved June 13, 2024,? from?https://www.eesc.europa.eu/en/news-media/press-releases/strong-and-inclusive-cohesion-policy-key-successful-eu-enlargement

21. Encyclopedia Britannica. (2024). Ukraine: The crisis in Crimea and eastern Ukraine. In Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://www.britannica.com/place/Ukraine/The-crisis-in-Crimea-and-eastern-Ukraine

22. Freedom House. (2018). Democracy in Crisis: Freedom in the World 2018. Written by Michael J. Abramowitz, President. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/2018/democracy-crisis

23. Mykhaylenko, M. (2024). Presented at the 32nd International Meeting in Political Studies, Estoril Conference: "Ukraine, Russia and the West"

Additional Sources?

IDN - Instituto da Defesa Nacional. (2023, February). IDN Brief: Strategic publication series. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://www.idn.gov.pt/pt/publicacoes/idnbrief/Paginas/IDN-Brief-fevereiro-2023.aspx

IDN - Instituto da Defesa Nacional. (n.d.). "Portugal and the European Union's Common Security and Defence Policy." Na??o e Defesa, No. 159. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://www.idn.gov.pt/pt/publicacoes/nacao/Documents/NeD159/NeDef159.pdf

IDN - Instituto da Defesa Nacional. (n.d.). "Challenges and Opportunities in Cybersecurity: The Role of National Defense." Na??o e Defesa, No. 159. Retrieved June 13, 2024, from?https://www.idn.gov.pt/pt/publicacoes/nacao/Documents/NeD159/NeDef159.pdf