The Ethical Dilemma in New India: Worshipping the Government While Questioning Parents

The Ethical Dilemma in New India: Worshipping the Government While Questioning Parents

In recent years, there has been a noticeable shift in societal values in India, particularly among the younger generation. An emerging trend seems to be the reverence and uncritical admiration for the government while simultaneously questioning the role and efforts of parents. This raises a fundamental ethical dilemma: Should we be worshipping the government, a service provider funded by taxpayers, while questioning our parents, the very people who nurtured and raised us? Let’s explore why this paradigm is both problematic and counterproductive and why we should recalibrate our approach to reflect a more balanced and ethical perspective.

The Role of Government: A Service Provider, Not a Deity

The government, by its very nature, is a service provider. It exists to manage public resources, ensure security, enforce laws, provide basic services like healthcare and education, and create an environment conducive to economic and social development. These functions are funded by taxpayers, including the citizens who pay their hard-earned money with the expectation of receiving these services efficiently and transparently.

Governments are not beyond criticism. In fact, questioning the government is an essential feature of a democratic society. Democracy thrives on accountability, transparency, and the ability of citizens to ask, "What are you doing with our money?" or "Are you upholding our constitutional rights?" Governments must be held accountable for their actions and decisions, especially when those actions affect the lives of millions.

However, in the current socio-political landscape of India, we are witnessing a disturbing trend where questioning the government is often labeled as anti-national or subversive. This conflation of patriotism with blind allegiance to government policies is not only detrimental to the democratic ethos but also stifles constructive criticism and debate. True patriotism involves questioning the government when it is wrong and demanding better governance, not treating it as an infallible entity.

The Role of Parents: Beyond Material Provision

Parents, on the other hand, occupy a profoundly different role in our lives. They are our first teachers, our moral guides, and often our most significant emotional support system. Unlike the government, which functions as an institution with a mandate to serve its citizens, parents are not bound by any legal contract to provide for us. They do so out of love, commitment, and a sense of duty.

Despite their immense contributions, parents today are often subjected to scrutiny that goes beyond reasonable questioning. The question, "What have you done for me?" is not just unfair; it undermines the countless sacrifices parents make to provide a better life for their children. Many parents sacrifice their dreams, desires, and even health to ensure that their children have access to opportunities they themselves never had. This selflessness and dedication are beyond any quantifiable measure.

The question should instead be, "What can I do for you?" or "How can I honor your sacrifices?" Our parents deserve our respect, not because they are flawless but because they have invested in us in ways no one else ever will. To question them as one would a service provider like the government reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of their role in our lives.

Why This Shift?

Several factors contribute to this shift in perspective:

1. Changing Cultural Norms: Modern Indian society is increasingly influenced by global values that emphasize individualism over collectivism. While individualism encourages self-reliance and personal responsibility, it also sometimes leads to a diminished appreciation for the family unit and the sacrifices inherent in it.
2. Influence of Social Media and Pop Culture: Social media platforms and popular culture often glorify figures of authority while portraying parents as traditionalists who are out of touch with modern aspirations. This narrative can skew the perception of the younger generation, leading them to question parental authority while uncritically accepting governmental narratives.
3. Economic Pressures: The younger generation faces unprecedented economic pressures, from student loans to job insecurity. In their struggle, they may feel unsupported by their families, especially if they perceive their parents as not understanding the contemporary economic landscape. This can create friction and lead to a questioning of parental roles.
4. Political Manipulation: There is also a deliberate attempt by certain political forces to encourage an uncritical, almost reverent attitude towards the government. This tactic can distract from genuine governance failures and redirect dissatisfaction towards more vulnerable targets like parents.

The Ethical Recalibration: A Balanced Perspective

It is essential to recalibrate our ethical compass and recognize that while the government, as a public institution, should be questioned and held accountable, our parents deserve a different form of respect and consideration.

1. Question the Government, Not to Demean, but to Improve: A vibrant democracy relies on informed citizens who hold their government accountable. Questioning policies, demanding transparency, and seeking justice are not signs of disrespect but of engaged citizenship. The government is there to serve us, not the other way around. The notion of "worshipping" the government is dangerous because it leads to an unquestioning populace, which can pave the way for authoritarianism.
2. Respect Parents, Not Blindly, but Gratefully: Respecting parents does not mean agreeing with them on everything or not holding them accountable for genuine mistakes. It means understanding the depth of their sacrifices and honoring their commitment to our well-being. We must recognize that the role of parents is not that of a service provider but of a caregiver, mentor, and moral guide. Even when we disagree, we should engage with them with empathy and understanding, not with a transactional mindset.
3. Encourage Critical Thinking, But in the Right Context: Critical thinking is essential in all aspects of life, but it must be applied with context in mind. While it's necessary to critically evaluate government policies and actions, applying the same scrutiny to familial relationships can be misplaced and damaging. Instead, we should aim to foster open dialogues with our parents, understanding their perspectives and sharing our own, rather than merely questioning their contributions.

Conclusion: Toward a More Ethical Society

As India strides toward becoming a global leader, it is crucial to uphold the principles of democracy by ensuring that governments are held accountable while respecting the unique and irreplaceable role of parents in our lives. It is high time we stop confusing the government's role as a service provider with that of our parents, who have selflessly shaped our lives. Question the government to demand better governance; respect and honor parents for their unquantifiable sacrifices. This is the ethical way forward in a truly new and enlightened India.

For Guest Lectures & Sustainability Requirements Contact

Dr Rakesh Varma Ex-IAS (VR)

+91-9415334449

Founder/CEO ESGmitra? www.esgmitra.com

[email protected]

https://www.esgcompliance.co.in/

Certified ESG Professional |Certified GRI Standards Sustainability Professional (CGSSP) | Govt. EGOsystem & ECOsystem Coder | ESG BRSR GRI Leader | MBA, LLB, Public Policy Maker & Analyst