The Essential Guide to DoD Agile: What You Need to Know About the Definition of Done in Agile

What is the Definition of Done (DoD in agile)?

The question, “Is this task done?” might seem simple, but answering it accurately requires a clear understanding of what "done" actually means. In Agile project management, especially in methodologies like Kanban and Scrum, a task isn’t truly considered complete unless it meets a predefined set of criteria known as the Definition of Done (DoD in Agile).

In Agile, “done” is more than just reaching the end of a task; it’s about ensuring that the task or product increment has fully met the agreed-upon standards. On visual boards used in these methodologies, the “done” column is the rightmost one, signifying that an item is fully completed and ready for delivery.

The DoD in Agile is a critical tool for teams, such as those in DevOps or Scrum, as it helps streamline the process and ensures that tasks are completed to a consistent standard. This guide delves into the concept of the Definition of done in Agile methodologies and provides insights on how to establish one to enhance the effectiveness and value of your projects.

The Importance of the Definition of Done in Agile

The Definition of Done in Agile is a set of criteria that a product increment must meet for it to be considered complete and ready for release. It’s a shared understanding among all team members, including developers, testers, product owners, and other stakeholders, that defines when a product increment is truly finished, even if it consists of multiple items.

By establishing a clear DoD in Agile, teams can concentrate on delivering value with each sprint and reduce the likelihood of rework. The DoD in Agile serves as a guide, ensuring that everyone on the team is aligned on what constitutes "done," leading to a smoother process during sprints.

It's important to note that just one person does not create the DoD; it is a collaborative agreement made by the entire project team. This collaboration ensures that the DoD reflects the needs of everyone involved, which can be especially crucial if your project involves hand-offs to other teams. In such cases, it's essential to consider what is needed to ensure the success of the next team in the value stream and incorporate those requirements into your DoD agile.

By working together to define "done," teams can better support each other and contribute to a more efficient and successful project outcome.

Crafting an Effective Scrum Definition of Done

The Scrum Definition of Done should be created collaboratively by the entire project team. This collaboration ensures that the Scrum Definition of Done reflects the needs of everyone involved, which can be especially crucial if your project involves hand-offs to other teams. In such cases, it's essential to consider what is needed to ensure the success of the next team in the value stream and incorporate those requirements into your DoD.

By working together to define "done," teams can better support each other and contribute to a more efficient and successful project outcome.

Examples of the Dod agile

The Definition of Done (DoD) varies based on the type of project and the team's goals. Here are a few examples illustrating how the DoD can differ:

Mobile App Development Project

• All images have been compressed.
• All code is minified and gzipped for optimal performance.
• Software Development Project:
• All code has undergone thorough testing, including unit, integration, and end-to-end tests.
• The product increment has been deployed to a staging environment and tested by the team.

Generic Project

• All errors have been identified and resolved.
• All release documentation has been completed, reviewed, and edited.

Definition of Done vs. Definition of Ready in Agile

While the Definition of Done in Agile outlines the criteria that determine when a product increment is complete, the Definition of Ready (DoR) focuses on when a product backlog item is prepared for work. The DoD in Agile is a set of high-level criteria used to ensure the quality and consistency of deliverables at the end of a sprint. In contrast, the DoR consists of specific, low-level criteria that must be met for a backlog item to be ready for development. Teams typically use the DoR during backlog refinement at the start of a sprint to ensure that items are fully prepared for work.

Why is the Definition of Done (DoD Agile) Important?

The Definition of Done in Agile is crucial for delivering high-quality products that meet customer expectations. It clarifies when a task can be considered complete and ready for inclusion in a product increment. Here are some key benefits of having a well-defined DoD in Agile:

1. Enhances Quality: By consistently checking each product increment against the DoD in Agile criteria, teams maintain a focus on quality throughout the development process, ensuring that every release meets the necessary standards.
2. Reduces Risk: Adhering to the DoD in Agile minimises the risk of rework and potential delays by clearly outlining the criteria that must be met before marking an item as complete. This ensures quality control at every stage of the project.
3. Improves Team Alignment: The Definition of Done in Agile serves as a shared understanding of what "done" means within the project, enabling teams to stay aligned on customer requirements and consistently deliver value with each sprint.
4. Tracks Progress: A clear DoD in Agile allows teams to measure progress by tracking the number of product increments that meet the "done" criteria. For instance, Scrum metrics like velocity can help gauge the number of completed product increments delivered within a specific timeframe.

Crafting a Scrum Definition of Done (DoD): Steps to Success

Creating a Scrum Definition of Done is essential for ensuring that your team has a clear, shared understanding of what it means to complete a task or product increment. While the specific steps may vary depending on the project and team, the process generally follows these key stages:

1. Collaborate with the Right Team

Involving the right team members is crucial when establishing a Scrum definition of done. This group should include everyone who has a stake in the project's outcome, such as product owners, Scrum masters, developers, testers, product managers, and other relevant stakeholders. Each member brings unique expertise and insights, ensuring the DoD is comprehensive and relevant. Missing out on key voices can lead to incomplete criteria and a substandard final product.

2. Define Clear Criteria

The most significant part of creating a DoD is establishing the specific criteria that will determine when a task or increment is considered "done." These criteria must be clear, measurable, and relevant to the project at hand. The team should consider the following questions:

• Are the criteria specific? For example, instead of saying "All code tested," specify "All code thoroughly tested via unit, integration, and end-to-end tests."
• Is the criteria customer-focused? Ensure that each criterion adds value for the end user, such as "All documentation is written and updated for easy user guidance."

Remember, the DoD is different from the acceptance criteria. While the DoD outlines the steps needed to complete a user story, acceptance criteria are specific conditions that must be met for a user story to be considered satisfactory by the customer.

3. Create a Completion Checklist

Even smaller tasks or issues can benefit from a DoD. By developing a completion checklist based on the DoD, teams can maintain consistency and quality across all deliverables. This checklist helps ensure that every task is completed to the same high standard, regardless of its size.

4. Assign Acceptance Criteria to User Stories

Acceptance criteria (AC) are specific conditions that a user story must meet to be acceptable to the customer. While similar to the DoD, AC focuses on individual user stories rather than product increments. For instance, if a user story states, "As a user, I want to use a search field to find products," the acceptance criteria might include:

• The search field is located in the top navigation bar.
• The search initiates after the "Search" button is clicked.
• The search field contains placeholder text like "What are you looking for?"

By setting clear AC, teams can ensure that user stories are completed in a way that meets customer expectations.

5. Continuously Revise and Update the DoD

The DoD should be a dynamic document that evolves with the project. As the team encounters bugs or learns more about the project, the DoD should be updated to prevent similar issues from recurring. Regular reviews, such as during sprint reviews or backlog refinement meetings, offer opportunities to refine the DoD, ensuring it remains relevant and achievable. By revisiting the DoD periodically, teams can adapt to new insights and maintain alignment with project goals.

6. Utilize Tools like Jira to Maintain a Strong DoD

Effective use of project management tools like RMsis can help teams maintain and enforce their DoD, keeping everyone aligned and ensuring that the quality of work remains high throughout the project.

Dod Agile: Frequently Questions Answered

Who is Responsible for Creating the Definition of Done?

The Definition of Done (DoD) is primarily created by the development team, often under the guidance of the Scrum Master. However, they must gather input from various stakeholders, including product owners, testers, and other key participants. This collaborative approach ensures that the DoD is comprehensive and aligns with everyone’s expectations.

What is the Difference Between the Definition of Done and Acceptance Criteria?

The Definition of Done is a set of overarching criteria that apply to every product increment. It defines what it means for the increment to be considered complete and ensures the overall quality and readiness of the product.

Acceptance Criteria (AC), on the other hand, are specific to individual user stories or features. They outline the conditions that a particular user story must meet to be considered acceptable to the customer. For instance:

• Example of DoD: "All documentation is written and updated."
• Example of AC: "The link to the user documentation is accessible from the navigation menu."

While the DoD applies across the board, AC is tailored to each user story, ensuring it meets the specific needs of the end user.

Best Practices for Crafting a Definition of Done

Involve the Entire Team

Creating the Definition of Done (DoD) should be a team effort, bringing together developers, testers, product owners, and other key stakeholders. This collaborative approach ensures that everyone has a shared understanding of what it means for a product increment to be truly complete.

Make it Accessible and Visible

The DoD should be easily accessible and regularly referenced, especially during sprint planning and discussions about product backlog items. Consider displaying it prominently in the workspace, adding it to a team wiki, or including it in the project plan. Regular visibility helps keep the team aligned on what "done" means.

Focus on Practicality and Relevance

Ensure that the DoD is realistic, achievable within the given time frame, and aligned with the resources available. Most importantly, it should address the actual needs of the customers, ensuring that the product increments deliver real value. Keep the DoD practical, focusing on criteria that genuinely contribute to the product's success.

Conclusion

The Definition of Done (DoD) in Agile is a vital component of Agile methodologies, serving as the foundation for ensuring quality and consistency across product increments. By clearly defining what "done" means, teams can align their efforts, reduce the risk of rework, and maintain a focus on delivering value to customers. A well-crafted Scrum Definition of Done not only enhances team collaboration but also improves the overall efficiency and success of a project. Remember, the Definition of Done in Agile is not a static document; it should evolve with the project, reflecting the team's growing understanding and the changing needs of stakeholders. By regularly revisiting and refining the DoD in Agile, teams can continuously improve their processes and deliver high-quality products that meet or exceed customer expectations.

Visit us for more information on Optimizory