Error-Free Integration: MuleSoft's Error Handling Strategies
MuleCraft Digital
An IT startup, that transforms data into powerful connections. We value efforts and uplift talents.
Error Handling
?????A surprise occurs when something unplanned happens while a computer program is running. Handling these surprises (or errors) is how the program deals with them to keep functioning. In Mule, we have various ways to deal with unexpected problems that may occur:
Error Object
These approaches give you flexibility in how you deal with unexpected issues in your Mule integration. When something goes wrong in a process, Mule creates an error object that holds information about the problem.
In Mule, the error object, often referred to as the Mule Error, encapsulates information about an error or exception that occurs during the processing of a message or event in a Mule flow. This error object typically holds the following key pieces of information:
Developers often use the error object to implement error handling and exception management strategies in Mule flows. By inspecting the error type, description, or code, they can determine how to route or process messages differently based on the encountered error. This allows for graceful handling of exceptions and the ability to send appropriate responses or take corrective actions when errors occur during integration processes.
The error type is made up of two parts: the namespace and the identifier. Think of it like a category and a specific name. For example, it might be labeled as HTTP: UNAUTHORIZED where HTTP is the category and UNAUTHORIZED is the specific name of the issue.
Mule looks at this label to figure out what to do with the error. It then sends it to the right part of the system called the Error Handler, where there are specific instructions on how to deal with that type of error.
Flow Types And Error Handling Abilities
The difference between a flow, a sub-flow and a private flow, is that sub-flow doesn’t have an Error Handling scope. So, it's just flow and private flow the ones that have an Error Handling block and can contain the On-Error Propagate and On-Error Continue.
Whether it is Propagate or Continue, Mule Executes all the components within those blocks. In Mule4, we can use On Error Continue, On Error Propagate, and Raise error at the flow level.
On-Error Continue
It is a type of error handler that allows a flow to continue processing?even when an error occurs. It captures and logs the error but doesn't halt the flow's execution, enabling graceful handling of errors without breaking the overall integration process. Any transactions at this point are committed.
On-Error Propagate
It is an error handler that stops the flow's execution?when an error occurs and propagates the error to higher-level error handlers or the calling process. It's used to handle and communicate errors effectively within an integration application. This rolls back any transaction.
We might place this error handler in the following situations:
Global Flow’s Error Handling
Try Scope
You can create a special error handler that's not directly connected to any specific part of your application. This error handler can have instructions like On Error Continue?or On Error Propagate?to deal with errors. You can set this error handler as the default?for your entire application in the global settings, so it works everywhere.
Then, in the main flow that contains the API kit router, you can refer to this error handler. So, whenever there's an error in that main flow, it will use the instructions you've set in the global error handler.
The most flexible approach is to put all error-handling instructions in a file called global-error-handler.xml. This is considered a good practice during development. Once we've caught an error, we can use information from it in different ways. We can send it as a response for an API, log it, or create an alert message to notify someone about the error. To get specific details from the error, we can find out what type of error it is and get its description. This helps us understand what went wrong.
What if we don't handle errors or don't set up error handlers? MuleSoft will use its default error handler. It will log the error and let it continue, which might not always be what we want.
Error Types
It's important to note that an error will only go to the Error Handling section if it's the same type of error that you've specified in your Error Handling setup. In Mule 4, there's a handy feature. It can figure out what types of errors might happen in a flow just by looking at the connectors you've used in that flow.
When you use components like HTTP Request and Database, Mule 4 can predict the kinds of errors that might happen based on how you've set up your flow.
Learning how On-Error Propagate and On-Error Continue works can make error handling easier. By following some rules, you can figure out what happens in your flow and what the result will be, like the payload and status code.
Process Of Error Handling
Let's understand these steps using the below examples.
Example-1
In this case, because there are no specific instructions in the error handling section, Mule will follow its standard procedure. It will show an error with a 500 status code and provide an error description like this: ?
?
Example-2
In this scenario, since we have an "On Error Propagate" instruction in the error handling section that matches the error type, Mule will follow those instructions. It will return a 500 status code and use the most recent data (payload) specified in the error handling section.
Example-3
In the third example, when we have an "On Error Continue" instruction in the error handling section that matches the error type, Mule will do something different. It will respond with a success status code, 200, and use the most recent data(payload) specified in the error handling section. So, it won't treat it as a typical error but rather as a successful outcome.
Example-4
In the fourth example, there are both "On Error Continue" and "On Error Propagate" instructions in the error handling section. However, when the errortype doesn't match the one in "On Error Continue," Mule will ignore that instruction. Instead, it will use the data (payload) specified in "On Error Propagate" and return a 500 status code for the response.
Cases of Error Handling
Case-1
Let us assume we have only one flow.
Rule-1:?If you've set up an error handler, but the type of error that occurred doesn't match what you've specified in the error handler, it doesn't matter if you've chosen "On-Error Continue" or "On-Error Propagate." In this case, Mule will ignore your custom error handling and use its own default error handler.
Because none of the error types match, and this is the main part of the program that isn't connected to other parts, it will follow Mule's standard way of handling errors.
This means it will display the information that was there before the HTTP Request component, and it will show an error with a status code of 500.
Final Response:?Response status code: 500
Case-2
Let us assume we have only one flow.
Rule-1:?If you've set up an error handler, and the type of error that occurred is the same as what you've specified in the error handler, then your custom error handling instructions will be followed.
Because both match, and this is the main part of the program without connections to other parts, we can move on to the other two rules.
Rule-2:?If the flow is set to "On-Error Continue," it will run all the actions in that error-handling block. In this case, we're changing the message to "Error Handled in Main Flow" using a Transform Message component.
Rule-3:?Because it's "On-Error Continue," and this is the main part of the program without connections to other parts, it will follow the instructions inside "On-Error Continue." It won't continue with the components after the HTTP Request, which is in the main flow.
Instead, it will display the message we set in the Transform Message component within "On-Error Continue."
Final Response:?Response status code: 200
Case-3
If we switch from using "On-Error Continue" to "On-Error Propagate" in Case 2, everything else remains the same. However, with "On-Error Propagate," instead of handling the error within the flow, it will send the error back to whoever called this flow with a status code of 500.
Final Response:?Response status code: 500
Case-4
Let us assume we have 2 flows.
Rule-1:?If you've set up an error handler, and the type of error that occurred is the same as what you've specified in the error handler, then your custom error handling instructions will be applied.
Note:?ANY?can handle any type of error.
Rule-2:?If the flow with the error (in this case, "Private Flow 1") is set to "On-Error Propagate," it will run all the actions in that error-handling block. In this case, we're changing the message to "Error Handled in Private Flow 1" using a Transform Message component.
Rule-3:?As per Rule 3, because it's "On-Error Propagate" and the current flow is called by another flow (the main flow), it will follow the instructions inside "On-Error Propagate" and then send the error back to the calling flow, which is the main flow.
This is how the error is raised back to the Main flow.
Rule-1:?If the type of error that occurred matches what's specified in the Error Handler, it means the error matches the expected type.
Rule-2: When "On-Error Continue" is used, it will execute a specific action, like changing the message to "Error Handled in Main Flow." After that, it won't continue with the other components after a certain point (in this case, after "flow-ref"). Since it's "On-Error Continue," and no other part of the program is calling this section, it will show the most recent message with a status of 200.
Final Response:??Response status code: 200
Case-5
This scenario is just like Case 4, with one difference: In the second part of the program (called "Private Flow 1"), we're using "On-Error Continue."
So, even if an error occurs, the program will keep going and won't stop. It will execute certain actions, but it won't halt at the error.
Rule-1:?If you've set up an error handler, and the type of error that occurred is the same as what you've specified in the error handler, then your custom error handling instructions will be applied.
Rule-2:?If the flow with the error (in this case, "Private Flow 1") is set to "On-Error Continue," it will run all the actions in that error-handling block. In this case, we're changing the message to "Error Handled in Private Flow 1" using a Transform Message component.
Rule-3:?Following Rule 3, because it's set to "On-Error Continue" and the current flow is called by another flow (the main flow), it will execute the actions inside "On-Error Continue" but won't raise the error. Instead, it goes back to the calling flow, which is the main flow. It then proceeds to execute all the components after "flow-ref," and the final message will be displayed with a status code of 200.
Final Response:?Response status code: 200
Mandatory For Robust Integration
In conclusion, effective error handling is a cornerstone of robust and reliable Mule integration applications. By implementing comprehensive error handling strategies, organizations can ensure graceful error recovery, improved system resilience, and enhanced overall data integrity. Embracing error handling best practices empowers developers to create resilient integrations that can withstand unexpected challenges and provide uninterrupted services to users.
?
?