The Erosion of Rites of Passage: Threads of Healthy Masculinity in Modern Culture

This week's edition of the EZ Reflections newsletter is a topic I have thought about throughout the calendar year of 2023, and I would like to share some of my reflections. Last week, this topic was also explored on the EZ Conversation podcast with Luke Entrup (Listen Here). We explored Luke's passion for working with men and their boys to conduct Rites of Passages, which was very cool. We are entirely lost in society today, and what we are experiencing all around us is passivity. I also reflected on my own life and realized that I never had my transition from boyhood to manhood; it just happened on its own, from being coddled at home for most of my life, to trying to figure it out in the real world. However, I feel like I have only truly become a man in the last two years - I turned 40 this year. It took me a while, but I figured out how every choice I make has consequences, and most of them trickle down to how our species evolves.

There's something to be said to have a rite of passage, a transition from boyhood, a celebration, and a sense of community. Being in the safety and comfort of other men, feeling vulnerable but not judged, for everyone goes through it. That is also something we lack in our current times, a sense of safety, acceptance, and no judgment - which is why men's groups are gaining prominence. The lack of this shows up in the statistics; most numbers I have seen from different sources have consistently shown that 3 out of 4 deaths from suicide are men. That's one side of the coin; the other side is the inability to learn how to channel aggression, which leads to unhealthy forms of masculinity. Something we have come to call "toxic." Boys need guidance and mentoring in working through aggression from masculine men who have learned to regulate themselves, which is a rare breed nowadays for many reasons. It has become a perpetual cycle. If aggression is not channelled, it can lead to tyranny. There are several examples from the past and present to see the consequences of that.

Therefore, this week's newsletter edition inspired me to share something I have reflected on all year: I am convinced we need more love. We have too many people with closed-off hearts, we are capable of so much when there is love. In the tapestry of human history, rites of passage have served as crucial milestones marking the transition from one life stage to another. These ancient rituals, deeply embedded in cultural and societal fabrics, provided individuals, particularly young men, with a roadmap for navigating the complexities of life. However, in the contemporary landscape, these time-honoured ceremonies have gradually faded into obscurity, leaving a void that has profound implications for the development of healthy masculinity. This void, some argue, contributes to the manifestation of aggression and, in extreme cases, the emergence of oppressive behaviour among men. In this exploration, I wanted to delve into the reasons behind the decline of rites of passage, dissect the consequences on masculinity, and consider potential avenues for revitalizing these essential cultural practices.

Rites of passage, encompassing initiation ceremonies, rituals, and symbolic transitions, were once the crucibles in which young men underwent transformative experiences. These rites played a pivotal role in instilling a sense of purpose, identity, and responsibility, fostering the growth of well-rounded individuals within their communities. However, as modernity has surged, traditional rites of passage have gradually eroded, giving way to a more fragmented and individualistic society.

One of the primary factors contributing to this decline is the weakening influence of traditional institutions. As societies shift towards secularism and globalization, the significance of communal rituals diminishes. The breakdown of extended families and local communities further exacerbates the erosion of these rites, leaving individuals adrift in a sea of disconnection. Moreover, the acceleration of technological advancements has created virtual spaces that often replace physical gatherings, hindering the transmission of cultural wisdom and values.

The absence of rites of passage has profound implications for the development of healthy masculinity. In the vacuum left by these ancient practices, young men may find themselves lacking clear markers of maturity and purpose. The result is a potential vulnerability to toxic influences and a distorted understanding of masculinity.

Some young men may seek alternative paths to affirm their identity and establish dominance without structured rites to guide them. This can manifest as an exaggerated display of aggression, as they grapple with the absence of a healthy outlet for their innate primal energies. The lack of a constructive means to channel these energies may lead to a skewed expression of masculinity, marked by dominance, control, and, in extreme cases, oppressive behaviour.

Unchecked aggression, when left unaddressed, can escalate into behaviours that mirror tyrannical tendencies. The absence of rites of passage that once facilitated the controlled expression of male energy may contribute to a distorted power dynamic. As young men struggle to find their place in the world without guidance, some may resort to asserting control over others as a misguided means of proving their masculinity.

The repercussions of the erosion of rites of passage extend beyond the individual, affecting the very fabric of society. The unchecked aggression and potential for tyranny in some men may contribute to a climate of hostility, polarization, and violence. The absence of well-defined rites also hampers the ability of communities to foster a collective sense of responsibility and mutual respect, eroding the foundations of a healthy and harmonious society.

In the face of these challenges, revitalizing rites of passage becomes imperative for nurturing healthy masculinity and building resilient communities. Efforts to reintegrate these rituals into modern life must be multifaceted, involving families, educational institutions, and communities.

Education plays a pivotal role in this process, as curricula can be designed to incorporate elements of traditional wisdom, ethical teachings, and emotional intelligence. Community-based initiatives can organize mentorship programs, creating spaces for intergenerational connections where young men can glean insights and guidance from experienced mentors. Additionally, families can play a crucial role by instilling values, fostering open communication, and creating meaningful rituals within the household.

The erosion of rites of passage has left a void in the cultural landscape, impacting the development of healthy masculinity and contributing to the manifestation of aggression and, in extreme cases, tyranny. Recognizing the importance of these ancient practices and actively working towards their revitalization is essential for building a society where individuals, particularly young men, can navigate the complexities of life with purpose, dignity, and a sense of responsibility. Through a collective effort to reintegrate rites of passage into modern culture, we can hope to forge a path towards a more balanced and harmonious expression of masculinity, fostering a healthier society for generations to come.

If you're enjoying this newsletter, please share or subscribe. Additionally, please check out the EZ Conversations podcast on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Finally, I can be found on all social media platforms under EunoiaZen.

?