The Enduring Threat: A Look at Scams, Old and New

Scams, the age-old art of deception for personal gain, have plagued humanity for centuries. From the earliest days of bartering to the sophisticated online landscapes of today, scammers have continuously adapted their tactics to exploit vulnerabilities. While the methods may evolve, the core motivation – exploiting trust and greed – remains constant. This article covers the historical context of scams, explores the current financial threat they pose in Australia, and outlines practical strategies organisations can adopt to fortify themselves.

A Timeless Deceit: A Historical Glimpse into Scams

Scams have existed as long as organised societies have. Early examples include pyramid schemes documented in ancient Egypt and confidence tricks employed in ancient Greece and Rome. The rise of trade routes opened avenues for elaborate scams, with counterfeit goods and bogus investments plaguing merchants.

The invention of the printing press facilitated the spread of fraudulent pamphlets and fake news, while the Industrial Revolution saw a surge in scams targeting factory workers. The 20th century witnessed the rise of telemarketing scams and Ponzi schemes, preying on the public's increasing reliance on communication technologies.

The digital age has ushered in a new era of scamming. The anonymity and global reach of the internet provide fertile ground for scammers, who can target a vast audience with minimal effort. Today's scams leverage sophisticated social engineering techniques, exploit people's emotional vulnerabilities, and utilise advanced technologies to appear legitimate.

The Australian Landscape: An Enduring Financial Threat

Financial scams continue to be a pervasive concern in Australia, despite some dip in the loss numbers from 2022 ($3.1B) to 2023 ($2.7B, as per National Anti Scam Center), scams continue to be a large contributor to Australia's overall financial crime landscape. This? excludes the ~30% of scam cases that go unreported.

Breaking down the figures further paints a stark picture:

• Investment Scams: Investment scams inflicted the heaviest losses, with Australians losing over $1.2 billion in 2023. These scams often exploit the public's desire for high returns, promising unrealistic gains on dubious investment opportunities.
• Payment Scams: Payment scams, including phishing and identity theft attempts, resulted in losses exceeding $800 million in 2023. Phishing emails and fake websites often target individuals and businesses, tricking them into revealing personal information or making fraudulent payments.
• Romance Scams: While the financial losses are lower compared to other categories, the emotional toll can be devastating. Romance scams, where individuals develop online relationships with scammers who exploit their emotions for financial gain, saw Australians lose over $100 million in 2023.

The financial burden of scams is not evenly distributed. Vulnerable demographics, such as the elderly and financially inexperienced individuals, are often targeted. However, even large organisations are not immune. Scams involving business email compromise (BEC), where scammers impersonate legitimate vendors or executives to trick companies into making fraudulent payments, have resulted in significant losses for Australian businesses.

In 2022 - 2023 FY, 2.5% of Australians (514,300) experienced a scam (as per the ABS).?

The impact of scams extends beyond the immediate financial losses. They erode trust in online interactions, stifle innovation, and create a climate of fear and uncertainty.

As financial crime professionals, we witness the devastating impact of scams firsthand. Victims often share their stories, detailing the elaborate schemes and emotional manipulation they endured. While empathy and support are crucial, this focus on the "how" of the scam inadvertently creates a narrative of helplessness.

We need to empower individuals to recognise scams, navigate them effectively, and minimise damage. Here's why:

• Dwelling on the "how" reinforces fear. Understanding common tactics is valuable, but overemphasise the specifics can make people overly cautious or paralysed by fear when a scam unfolds.
• It overlooks the "what to do." Sharing actionable steps for scam identification, prevention, and recovery equips individuals to navigate challenging situations and minimise losses.
• It discourages reporting. Fear of judgement or embarrassment can prevent victims from reporting scams, hindering law enforcement and hindering efforts to track and disrupt criminal networks.

How about we:

• Focus on red flags and prevention. Educate individuals on common tactics like urgency, promises of unrealistic returns, and pressure to share personal information. Knowledge is power!
• Empower action during a scam. Equip people with steps to take if they suspect a scam, such as ending communication, verifying information independently, and contacting financial institutions.
• Normalise reporting. Encourage victims to report scams to the appropriate authorities, regardless of the amount lost. This helps build a comprehensive picture of criminal activity and aids in catching perpetrators.

By shifting the narrative, we can empower individuals to become active participants in the fight against scams. This can be achieved through:

• Financial institutions: Incorporate educational resources and clear reporting procedures into client communications.
• Government agencies: Develop public awareness campaigns focused on scam identification and reporting.
• Media outlets: Promote stories that highlight the "what to do" in scam scenarios, offering practical advice for viewers/readers.

Let's move past dwelling on how victims were scammed and focus on equipping them to become victors – empowered to recognise scams, navigate them effectively, and minimise the damage.

Quorsus are here to help!

Contact Quorsus with any questions or if you would like to discuss Financial Crime further, please feel free to reach out to us at [email protected]. At Quorsus we are passionate about providing value for our clients. We offer a range of solutions to suit organisations big and small in facing financial crime risk management challenges, ensuring your organisation, customers and the community are protected.?

www.quors.us