Empowerment: Why to Use Scripts and Flow Charts for Confident Communication in School Settings and Beyond

Confidence is essential for people in general and especially teachers in the challenging circumstances of international education. It’s also not just in the classroom but in everyday interactions with colleagues, parents, and school leaders. Confidence in everyday interactions outside of school also matters as these interactions contribute to the overall well-being of a person (yes, teachers are people and life can be scary).

From staff meetings and parent discussions to even negotiating salary and working conditions, these high-stakes situations can feel overwhelming. Why would a school want to help a teacher negotiate better? Why would a school not want a teacher who feels like they are undervalued? Student outcomes. Confidence in staff meetings means a greater likelihood of valuable contributions. Confidence in dealing with parents is likely to improve the perception of the school in the wider school community.

By using scripts and decision-making flow charts, teachers can navigate these scenarios with greater clarity and assurance. When teachers feel more prepared, confident, and importantly valued, they contribute positively to school culture, which ultimately enhances student learning outcomes.

Being prepared for common scenarios—and even the unexpected—fosters a sense of control and reduces stress in both professional and personal life. This leads to better outcomes for everyone. Confidence leads to efficacy, and efficacy is essential.

?

The Power of Preparation

Recently, I have enjoyed reading Matt Abrahams book ‘Think Faster, Talk Smarter’, where he emphasises that preparation and structured communication reduce anxiety in high-pressure environments. Teachers who come prepared to staff meetings or parent conferences with clear, planned responses, or response structures, are more likely to speak confidently and effectively. This preparedness not only reduces stress but also allows teachers to engage more constructively in discussions.

When teachers face unexpected challenges, they often need to rely on fast, intuitive thinking (Kahneman, 2011). According to Kahneman’s ‘Thinking, Fast and Slow,’ this system 1 thinking is useful but can lead to errors, particularly in emotionally charged situations where we revert to our natural biases (Bazerman and Moore, 2013). Scripts and decision-making flow charts support more deliberate, thoughtful system 2 thinking, enabling teachers to handle even difficult conversations with poise and avoid the interference of bias.

?

Scripts for Staff Meetings

Staff meetings can sometimes become contentious or stressful, especially when discussing sensitive topics like curriculum changes or new policies. The utilisation of a prepared script can help teachers present their ideas and concerns in a professional, solution-oriented manner, especially younger staff members.

?

Consider a scenario where a teacher disagrees with a proposed policy:

Script: “I appreciate the intention behind this new approach, but I have concerns about how it might impact student learning and teacher workload. Can we take some time to consider this and explore some possible adjustments?”

This script validates the school leadership’s efforts while expressing concerns diplomatically. It invites dialogue rather than confrontation, reinforcing a collaborative environment. As Hargreaves and Fullan (2012) discuss, effective communication during staff meetings enhances teacher collaboration and builds professional capital, leading to stronger school cultures and improved student success.

?

Scripts for Parent Meetings

Parent meetings are another area where confidence is key. Whether discussing a student’s academic performance or behavioural issues, teachers often face heightened emotions from parents. By having a structured script, teachers can guide these conversations with clarity and empathy. For instance, when a parent expresses frustration over their child’s performance:

Script: “I understand your concerns about [student’s name]. Let’s review their recent work together and discuss ways we can mutually support their progress.”

This response validates the parent’s feelings while maintaining the focus on collaborative problem-solving. Minke and Anderson (2005) highlight the importance of teacher-parent partnerships, showing that when teachers approach these conversations with greater confidence, it leads to stronger parent-teacher relationships and better student outcomes.

?

Decision-Making Flow Charts for Salary Negotiations

Negotiating salary and working conditions is often a challenging aspect of a teacher’s professional life. Many teachers feel uncomfortable advocating for themselves, which can result in dissatisfaction and even burnout. Having a decision-making flow chart can help teachers feel more confident and assertive in these situations. The idea, inspired by Bazerman and Moore’s Judgment in Managerial Decision Making (2013) (a favourite book of mine), is that these flow charts provide a clear framework for negotiation that serves to avoid detrimental personal biases that may hamper negotiations and lead to a feeling of a negative outcome. In salary negotiations the school has an interest in ensuring the teacher is happy with the outcome - if you don't care about them being happy why are you hiring them?

?

Here’s an example of a simple flow chart for salary negotiations:

1. Evaluate the Offer: Is the proposed salary/contract aligned with industry standards or your expectations??

If yes, proceed to accept. If no, proceed to Step 2.

2. Clarify Priorities: What are your priorities—salary, benefits, work conditions??

Consider what trade-offs you are willing to make and formulate your counteroffer.

3. Negotiate: Present your counteroffer with evidence, explaining why it is reasonable based on your experience and contributions.

4. Respond to Counteroffers: If the employer counters, return to Step 2 and re-evaluate your priorities.

This approach aligns with the findings of Sergiovanni (2001) and Hargreaves and Fullan (2012), who argue that when teachers are empowered to advocate for themselves effectively, they are more likely to stay in the profession. While neither specifically mentions salary, they repeatedly point pout that this self-advocacy fosters a stronger sense of community and commitment to a positive school culture.

?

Flow Charts for Life Outside of School

Beyond the workplace, the skills developed through scripts and flow charts can have a significant impact on personal life as well. Teachers who practice these strategies in professional settings are better equipped to handle difficult conversations in their personal lives, such as managing conflicts with friends or making important decisions.

Kandel, in his book In Search of Memory, explores how repeated practice creates neurological pathways, reinforcing positive behaviour patterns. By practising scripts and using decision-making flow charts, teachers can develop strong mental habits that empower them in both personal and professional situations. As teachers build confidence in managing difficult conversations, they are more likely to experience reduced stress and greater personal satisfaction.

?

Building a Positive School Culture

A confident teacher is an empowered teacher, and an empowered teacher contributes to a thriving school culture. When teachers are prepared for the challenges of staff meetings, parent conferences, and negotiations, they contribute more effectively to a positive, collaborative environment. This culture of openness and support, in turn, benefits students.

According to Hargreaves and Fullan (2012), confident, empowered teachers are more likely to engage in reflective practices and contribute to school improvement initiatives. This confidence leads to better communication with colleagues, stronger relationships with students, and improved learning outcomes.

As Matt Abrahams (2023) notes, confidence in communication is key to making meaningful contributions in any setting. Teachers who feel prepared are more likely to contribute to decision-making processes, advocate for their needs, and create a positive learning environment for students.

?

Final Thoughts

By incorporating scripts and decision-making flow charts into their professional lives, teachers can approach staff meetings, parent conversations, and salary negotiations with greater confidence and clarity. The benefits of these tools extend beyond individual situations—they foster a school culture of collaboration, trust, and professionalism. Prepared, confident teachers are better equipped to handle the challenging demands of their role, leading to improved student outcomes and a more positive work environment and school culture. As teachers practice these strategies, they not only enhance their professional lives but also build the foundation for happier, more fulfilling personal lives. This is as essential as their classroom performance.

The prime question is how to develop the scripts and flow charts. This is a topic for another article. I'm off to find the script that I use to explain to my wife how "5 more minutes" turns into 5 more hours. Wish me luck.

?

References

Abrahams, M. (2023). Think faster, talk smarter: How to speak successfully when you're put on the spot. Simon & Schuster.

Bazerman, M., & Moore, D. A. (2013). Judgment in managerial decision making (8th ed.). Wiley.

Hargreaves, A., & Fullan, M. (2012). Professional capital: Transforming teaching in every school. Teachers College Press.

Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, fast and slow. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

Kandel, E. (2007). In Search of Memory: The Emergence of a New Science of Mind. W.W. Norton & Company.

Minke, K. M., & Anderson, K. J. (2005). Family—School Collaboration and Positive Behavior Support. Allyn & Bacon.

Sergiovanni, T. J. (2001). Leadership: What's in it for Schools?. Routledge.