Employee Feedback: Intent Matters

Employee Feedback: Intent Matters

A recent wave of sentiment has questioned the increasingly popular trend of strengths-based feedback, with some going so far as to suggest that ignoring weaknesses risks missing the boat on improving performance.

I am inclined to think there is a middle ground that depends on a simple premise (betrayed in the title): intent matters.

To me, the innovation of the strengths movement was a shift away from cynicism and negativity, not an abandonment of remedial employee development. Sure, we could debate the underlying question of whether fixing your weaknesses or amplifying your strengths is most important, but in the end, I think logic dictates that making progress on either front would deliver value to the subject of the feedback (and the organization to which she belongs).

Is there a way, then, to preserve the spirit of the strengths movement without avoiding "corrective" feedback entirely? I believe there is.

Teach managers empathy, respect and kindness. As anyone who's been blessed to have a truly outstanding manager can tell you, much is conveyed by the tone, timing, words chosen, body language and actions of the giver of feedback, regardless of positive / negative framing. It is our task (in HR) to unlock the right behaviors so critical messages can be received by employees.

If the culture of an organization is characterized by mistrust, backstabbing, political maneuvering and retaliation, no amount of engineering applied to the performance management process will fix things. 

Managers need to genuinely want to help their people before subordinates will be interested in accepting their guidance.

Rachel Brecht

Fractional Chief People Officer ? Executive Advisor ? Building Radically Aligned, Results-Focused, High Performing Teams, Cultures & Organizations ? Award Winning Board Director ? DEI Advocate ? Chief

9 年

Agreed! If managers show up authentically, with vulnerability and empathy, feedback will surely be transformational vs. transactional.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Aaron Ziff的更多文章

  • WHAT ARE JEWS SO WORRIED ABOUT? (An explainer)

    WHAT ARE JEWS SO WORRIED ABOUT? (An explainer)

    What the average American (or citizen of virtually any other country) can’t fully comprehend or relate to is that the…

    9 条评论
  • Welcome to Alcoa!

    Welcome to Alcoa!

    Ever have one of those weeks that you dread coming in on Monday? Well, this week I could not have been more excited to…

    3 条评论
  • The “Go-Live” of My Career

    The “Go-Live” of My Career

    Today marks a significant milestone for my employer, Alcoa. You see, today is our Go-Live, the day we release the HR…

    28 条评论
  • Is your recruiting strategy like Hipmunk? Indeed...

    Is your recruiting strategy like Hipmunk? Indeed...

    If you've ever searched for a flight using an aggregator like www.Hipmunk.

  • Don't Fight: What to do About the "War for Talent"

    Don't Fight: What to do About the "War for Talent"

    Look out, folks. With the economic recovery running at full partial strength approaching its seventh year, HR experts…

    7 条评论
  • Changing Expectations in HR Software Applications

    Changing Expectations in HR Software Applications

    Amid the frenetic pace of acquisitions in the HR and Talent Management software space, an interesting theme has…

    2 条评论
  • Recruiting in the Age of Machines

    Recruiting in the Age of Machines

    In the last several decades, the markets for both recruiting technologies (the outmoded - yet still dominant - ATS) and…

    4 条评论
  • Benefits + Analytics? You Betcha!

    Benefits + Analytics? You Betcha!

    I recently designed a new project for a large client that I am proud of and thought it might interest others. Have a…

  • Parenting, or Performance Monitoring

    Parenting, or Performance Monitoring

    Lately, it seems that everyone wants to fix performance management. There is good reason for this.

    2 条评论
  • Loss and Meaning

    Loss and Meaning

    Yesterday, we lost my wife's grandmother, a woman of unparalleled compassion and resilience. I had the pleasure of…

    6 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了