The Economics of Generative AI: Feature or Product?

Introduction: Navigating the Generative AI Landscape

The conversation surrounding generative AI is rapidly evolving, with one of the most pressing questions being whether generative AI is best viewed as a feature or a standalone product. This distinction isn’t just academic; it has significant implications for business strategy, investment, and the future of technology itself.

Generative AI: Feature vs. Product

The fundamental difference between a feature and a product boils down to value. A feature enhances an existing product, adding incremental value, while a product stands on its own, offering value significant enough to drive consumer demand by itself.

Right now, we’re witnessing a proliferation of “generative AI as a feature.” AI is being integrated into a wide range of existing products—text editors, search engines, and web browsers, to name a few. This integration adds functionality but doesn’t necessarily define the product’s core value proposition. For example, Google’s AI-enhanced search summaries can be disabled without affecting the primary search function, showing that AI, in this context, is a nice-to-have, not a must-have.

On the flip side, companies like OpenAI and Anthropic are attempting to position generative AI as the core product. Tools like ChatGPT or Claude are built entirely around generative AI, making it the central offering. However, the success of these products hinges on the AI living up to user expectations. If it doesn’t, users can easily abandon the product, posing a higher risk for these companies.

Apple’s Strategic Approach: Generative AI as a Feature

Apple’s strategy exemplifies the generative AI as a feature approach. During the last WWDC, Apple revealed its collaboration with OpenAI to bring ChatGPT access via Siri. However, Apple isn’t betting exclusively on this partnership. By not paying OpenAI for this integration and by retaining the flexibility to incorporate other generative AI solutions, Apple minimizes its risk while enhancing its product ecosystem. Apple’s strategy focuses on making existing products, like the iPhone, more useful rather than selling AI as a standalone product. This approach highlights the importance of viewing generative AI as a complementary feature that augments core offerings, rather than as the core offering itself.

The Blurred Lines of Business Strategy

There isn’t a one-size-fits-all approach to integrating generative AI into a business strategy. While the technology itself is groundbreaking, its application and monetization require careful consideration. In the next decade, the companies that will emerge as the “big winners” in the generative AI space may not be those that developed the underlying technology. Instead, they could be those that effectively integrated AI into their products as a feature, enhancing the overall value proposition without relying on AI as the sole selling point.

The Business Strategy for Developing Generative AI

If generative AI is viewed as more of a feature than a product, the question arises: what’s the business strategy for its development? Should companies focus on building generative AI capabilities, or should they prioritize integrating these capabilities into existing products?

The tech industry has poured billions into generative AI research, betting on the continued improvement of these technologies. However, the rapid advancements seen in 2022–2023 may not continue indefinitely. We might be approaching the limits of what current AI models can achieve without more human-generated data for training. This brings into question the sustainability of continued investment in AI development.

Creating a product from advanced technology is not just about innovation. It involves understanding user needs, communicating the product’s value, and convincing consumers to pay a sustainable price. While there are many ideas for using generative AI, not all of them will prove essential or commercially viable.

The Role of Research in Generative AI

The focus on monetization has placed researchers in a challenging position. While research for research’s sake has always existed, the high costs associated with AI research are difficult to sustain without private investment. Unfortunately, academia, traditionally the home for pure research, has been underfunded, leaving scholars with limited opportunities to participate in generative AI research without private backing.

This shift is concerning because academic research often places a higher value on ethical considerations, security, and safety—areas that can be overlooked in the private sector’s rush to capitalize on new technologies. The lack of academic participation in generative AI research could result in missed opportunities to explore important questions, such as the long-term societal impacts of AI, in a rigorous and ethical manner.

The Future of Generative AI: Risks and Opportunities

The economic model driving generative AI development could lead to missed opportunities. Applications that are socially beneficial but not immediately profitable may never be fully explored, while those that offer quick financial returns—regardless of their societal value—receive investment.

As we continue to push the boundaries of what generative AI can do, it’s essential to strike a balance between innovation and practicality. The future of generative AI may not lie in standalone products, but in how effectively these technologies are integrated into existing products, enhancing their value without overshadowing their core functionality.

Conclusion: A Strategic Perspective on Generative AI

The debate over whether generative AI is a feature or a product reflects broader questions about technology, value, and business strategy. Companies need to carefully consider how they integrate AI into their offerings, balancing the allure of cutting-edge technology with the practicalities of user needs and market demands.

In the long run, the most successful strategies may be those that view generative AI as a powerful tool to enhance existing products, rather than as a product in itself. By adopting a flexible, feature-focused approach, companies can harness the power of AI while minimizing risk and maximizing value.

Discover how tailored mentorship, strategic tech consultancy, and decisive funding guidance have transformed careers and catapulted startups to success. Dive into real success stories and envision your future with us. #CareerGrowth #StartupFunding #TechInnovation #Leadership"

Book 1:1 Session with Avinash Dubey