The Economic Crisis in China

Introduction

China is widely regarded as one of the world's economic superpowers, with a remarkable growth rate that has lifted millions of people out of poverty and transformed the global landscape. However, in recent years, China has faced a series of challenges that threaten to undermine its economic stability and future prospects. In this article, we will examine three of the most pressing issues that China is facing: the role and performance of state-owned enterprises (SOEs), the mounting debt burden, and the accuracy and reliability of its GDP figures. We will also explore the implications of these issues for China and the world.

State-Owned Enterprises: A Drag on the Economy?

State-owned enterprises are companies that are owned or controlled by the government, either directly or indirectly. They play a significant role in China's economy, accounting for about 40% of its industrial output and 30% of its employment. However, SOEs are also widely criticized for being inefficient, unprofitable, and dependent on subsidies and preferential policies. According to a report by the World Bank, SOEs in China had an average return on assets of 2.9% in 2019, compared to 9.4% for private firms. Moreover, SOEs have contributed to the overcapacity and oversupply of many sectors, such as steel, coal, and cement, leading to lower prices and profits.

One of the main reasons why SOEs are underperforming is the lack of market discipline and competition. SOEs enjoy various advantages over private firms, such as easier access to credit, land, and natural resources, lower tax rates, and protection from bankruptcy. These privileges distort the allocation of resources and create moral hazard, as SOEs have less incentive to innovate, improve productivity, and reduce costs. Furthermore, SOEs are often subject to political interference and corruption, as they are used as tools to achieve social and political goals, such as maintaining employment, supporting strategic industries, and promoting regional development.

The Debt Dilemma: How Sustainable is Chinas Growth?

Another major challenge that China is facing is the rapid accumulation of debt, both public and private. According to the Institute of International Finance, China's total debt reached 317% of its GDP in the first quarter of 2020, up from 300% in the fourth quarter of 2019. This is one of the highest debt ratios in the world, and well above the average of 230% for emerging markets. The main drivers of China's debt surge are the corporate and household sectors, which account for 163% and 60% of the GDP, respectively. The government debt, on the other hand, is relatively low, at 51% of the GDP.

The main cause of China's debt problem is the reliance on credit-fueled investment to sustain its growth. After the global financial crisis of 2008, China launched a massive stimulus package of 4 trillion yuan ($586 billion) to boost its economy, which led to a surge in bank lending and infrastructure spending. However, this also resulted in a lot of wasteful and unproductive investment, such as ghost cities, zombie firms, and excess capacity. Moreover, as the returns on investment declined, China had to borrow more and more to generate the same amount of growth, creating a vicious cycle of debt and leverage.

GDP: A Reliable Measure of Chinas Economic Performance?

The third issue that China is facing is the credibility and validity of its GDP figures. GDP, or gross domestic product, is the most widely used indicator of a country's economic performance, as it measures the total value of goods and services produced within a given period. However, many experts and observers have questioned the accuracy and reliability of China's GDP data, as they suspect that they are manipulated or inflated by the government for political and social reasons.

One of the reasons why China's GDP data is dubious is the discrepancy between the national and provincial figures. According to the National Bureau of Statistics, China's GDP grew by 6.1% in 2019, the lowest rate in 29 years. However, if we add up the GDP growth rates of all the 31 provinces and municipalities, we get a much higher figure of 6.7%. This suggests that the local governments are overstating their economic performance to meet the targets and expectations set by the central government, as well as to attract more investment and funding.

Another reason why China's GDP data is questionable is the methodology and calculation of the indicator. China uses a top-down approach to estimate its GDP, which means that it starts with the output of the major sectors, such as industry, agriculture, and services, and then aggregates them to get the total GDP. However, this approach is prone to errors and biases, as it relies on the quality and consistency of the data collected from various sources, such as enterprises, local governments, and surveys. Moreover, China does not fully follow the international standards and practices for measuring GDP, such as the System of National Accounts, which makes it difficult to compare and verify its data with other countries.

What's next?

China is facing a serious economic crisis, as it struggles to cope with the challenges of SOEs, debt, and GDP. These issues have profound implications for China and the world, as they affect the sustainability and quality of its growth, as well as its role and influence in the global economy. Therefore, it is imperative that China undertakes comprehensive and credible reforms to address these issues, such as improving the governance and performance of SOEs, reducing the debt and leverage of the corporate and household sectors, and enhancing the transparency and reliability of its GDP data. Only then can China achieve a more balanced and resilient economic development.

?