Downsizing the microalgae hype

Downsizing the microalgae hype

It has been some time since algae were the next fuel source. Given the substantial investment in research and development, I really wonder what happened to this technology, which had been so hyped 15 years ago. My PhD student Tong Wang at the Yale School of Engineering and Applied Sciences then got the opportunity to conduct a life cycle assessment and cost analysis of a specific technology for growing microalgae developed at the school by PostDoc Xiaoxiong Wang in Menachem Elimelech's lab.

The study shows that that the new technology can produce high-purity algae at lower cost and with lower impacts than alternative processes. The key of the new technology is that it uses heterotroph algea instead of phototrophic algea. The energy to grow the algea comes from straw rather than the sun directly. The costs are estimated to be close to $5 per kg algae, which can potentially be brought down closer to $3 per kg when various by-products are valorized. The production process causes just under 10 kg of CO2e per kg algae. Phototrophic algae production from sunlight in raceway ponds causes just over 10 kgCO2e, while the production in photobioreactors causes between 25 and 38 kgCO2e.

For me, these were indeed quite surprising findings. It is clear that algea cultiviation is miles away from being a process that produces energy, rather than consuming energy. It requires substantial infrastructure and inputs, and yields are modest. Producing algae using energy derived from straw is better than using sunlight directly. It also means that if you want to produce energy, do not use algae, use straw directly! Of course, growing biomass is a low-density way of energy harvesting to start out with, compared to wind turbines and photovoltaic cells. The commercial case for this technology is for cosmetics and other high-value specialty chemicals produced in small volumes only. An important clarification indeed!

Alexandra Angeletaki

Cultural and Digital heritage Researcher, Senior Academic Librarian at NTNU

2 年

Thank you for this... a hope for the future

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Edgar Hertwich的更多文章

  • Agrifood hungry for fossil fuel

    Agrifood hungry for fossil fuel

    As we seek to decarbonize our economy, can we reduce fossil dependency of agriculture? Not so long ago, all the energy…

    2 条评论
  • Climate protection and protection from climate impacts

    Climate protection and protection from climate impacts

    Despite record summer heat and now record flooding, Austria's media seem to be more concerned about the costs than the…

    1 条评论
  • Making sense of corporate carbon footprints

    Making sense of corporate carbon footprints

    Corporate carbon footprinting is all the rage, scope 1, 2 and 3, which means taking the supply chain and potentially…

    2 条评论
  • Sky-high energy footprints of buildings in Dubai

    Sky-high energy footprints of buildings in Dubai

    Rich Arab Gulf countries top lists of per capita energy consumption, toghether with Iceland and Singapore. Contrary to…

    3 条评论
  • Climate misinformation from Norway spreads internationally

    Climate misinformation from Norway spreads internationally

    Colleagues in the Climate Advisory Board report that they have been confronted with the arguments presented in a…

  • Life cycle emissions of investments

    Life cycle emissions of investments

    Never before have climate risks been so starkly visible. This October, the worst floods in a decade killed 600 in…

    11 条评论
  • Material efficiency to reconcile development and climate protection

    Material efficiency to reconcile development and climate protection

    Developing countries can achieve prosperity while reducing emissions substantially in three ways: Shift to low carbon…

  • Tiny homes to save the climate?

    Tiny homes to save the climate?

    Original with more interactive features at "Medium" In a new study by the International Resource Panel, we show that…

    1 条评论
  • Why does Norway punish mobile scientists?

    Why does Norway punish mobile scientists?

    At the New Haven science march, a physics professor held up a poster of Albert Einstein. He was a migrant, too.

    5 条评论
  • How to force down the US climate impact

    How to force down the US climate impact

    Carbon emissions comparable to all international air transport are required to support the US trade deficit. The…

    1 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了